Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry Demery and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions, which this week were laced with Pirates-related rage …
Doug Vandivner, @vandivner_doug: What do you think is [going to] happen with Hurdle if you think this losing continues?
Starkey: Nothing, Vandy, and I’ll tell you why: Bob Nutting decided that of all the things in the world to spend big money on — baseball players being off the table, of course — a manager would top his list. Can you believe that?
There are several managers making $1 million or less per season. Nutting, the cheapest owner in baseball, decided to spend triple that amount ON A MANAGER. As of late last season, he was matching the Boston Red Sox and beating the New York Yankees and Los Angeles Dodgers in money spent ON A MANAGER!
I mean, it would be one thing if Clint Hurdle were some kind of miracle worker. He’s a decent manager, but he’s also one who has never won a division title, has a career losing record and is currently presiding over yet another epic collapse. And remember this: Word of his FOUR-YEAR extension two years ago (and a similar one for GM Neal Huntington) leaked to Ken Rosenthal as the Pirates piddled along in last place. It’s not like Nutting extended them on a wave of success.
The Pirates are collapsing (again) in ridiculous fashion before our very eyes. That would make six second-half collapses under Hurdle, sandwiched around three consecutive playoff appearances (for which he deserved and received immense credit, although it should be noted the Pirates had a chance to win the NL Central each of those years and came up short in September).
Read More
Let’s be honest: No manager in all of baseball, except Hurdle, survives this. The Pirates have fallen apart. They appear to be dispirited and disheveled. But the fact is, if Nutting fired Hurdle today, he would have to pay him more than $6 million to sit at home over the next two-plus seasons. I’d rather bet on Jordan Lyles to win the Cy Young Award.
Here is the list of 2018 manager salaries, as compiled by USA Today …
• 1. Mike Scioscia, Los Angeles Angels: $6 million.
• 1. Joe Maddon, Chicago Cubs: $6 million.
• 1. Bruce Bochy, San Francisco Giants: $6 million.
• 4. Terry Francona, Cleveland Indians: $4 million.
• 4. Buck Showalter, Baltimore Orioles: $4 million.
• 6. Ned Yost, Kansas City Royals: $3.7 million.
• 7. Clint Hurdle, Pittsburgh Pirates: $3 million.
• 7. #John Farrell, Boston Red Sox: $3 million.
• 9. Bob Melvin, Oakland A’s: $2.5 million.
• 10. Don Mattingly, Miami Marlins: $2.4 million.
• 11. #Mike Matheny, St. Louis Cardinals: $1.9 million.
• 12. John Gibbons, Toronto Blue Jays: $1.7 million.
• 13. Ron Gardenhire, Detroit Tigers: $1.5 million.
• 13. Craig Counsell, Milwaukee Brewers: $1.5 million.
• 13. Paul Molitor, Minnesota Twins: $1.5 million.
• 13. Bud Black, Colorado Rockies: $1.5 million.
• 17. #Bryan Price, Cincinnati Reds: $1.4 million.
• 18. A.J. Hinch, Houston Astros: $1.2 million.
• 18. Rick Renteria, Chicago White Sox: $1.2 million.
• 20. Aaron Boone, New York Yankees: $1.15 million.
• 21. Kevin Cash, Tampa Bay Rays: $1 million.
• 21. Dave Roberts, Los Angeles Dodgers: $1 million.
• 21. Andy Green, San Diego Padres: $1 million.
• 24. Jeff Bannister, Texas Rangers: $950,000.
• 25. Torey Lovullo, Arizona Diamondbacks: $900,000.
• 26. Davey Martinez, Washington Nationals: $850,000.
• 26. Mickey Callaway, New York Mets: $850,000.
• 28. Gabe Kapler, Philadelphia Phillies: $803,000.
• 29. Alex Cora, Boston Red Sox: $800,000.
• 29. Scott Servais, Seattle Mariners: $800,000.
• 29. Brian Snitker, Atlanta Braves: $800,000.
• 32. @Jim Riggleman, Cincinnati Reds: $700,000 (prorated).
• 32. @Mike Shildt, St. Louis Cardinals: $700,000 (prorated).
#No longer employed as manager, but being paid this season.
@Interim manager
Scioscia retired. Showalter was fired. Farrell is now a lobster fisherman (no, really). That would appear to leave Hurdle alone as the fifth highest-paid manager in the majors.
Bob Nutting never outspends the competition. He decided to do it, big-time, on a manager.
Can you believe that?
Steve Smail, @SteveS813: If the Pirates fire Hurdle, who is your suggestion for the replacement?
Starkey: They won’t. But I think Bob Pompeani would be a fine choice.
David Chirdon, @dave_chirdon: What can we as fans do, to get Nutting to sell the team? I’m sick of this.
Starkey: Have you seen all those empty seats, David? The fans have spoken. Even if attendance is up this season — and quite frankly, I’m shocked by the numbers, given that nearly every time I look at the stands they’re practically void of human life — the Pirates still have the second-worst attendance in the National League. The fans have spoken. And it won’t matter. Nutting won’t sell. The money comes from many other streams, better-stocked than attendance.
Christopher Luff, @christopherluff: Honest question: Should I be worried about losing the Pirates within the next 10 or so years when Nutting runs fan interest in the franchise into the ground?
Starkey: Nothing would surprise me, Christopher. I believe the Pirates’ lease at PNC Park runs out in 2030 (or 11 second-half collapses from now). I ran across an interesting piece by Steve DiMiceli at pointofpittsburgh.com. I’ll quote it here:
“[Pittsburgh’s] demographic decline could also strain the franchise’s future. More than any other sport, baseball has typically aligned to the largest markets in terms of population. Milwaukee is much smaller than most MLB cities, but there aren’t any outliers in baseball like Buffalo, Green Bay, or Salt Lake City like you see in the other major sports leagues. The Pittsburgh metropolitan area has show a slight decrease in its population since the last census and has dropped to 26th in the nation. By 2030, when the Bucs’ lease runs out, rapidly growing Las Vegas, Sacramento and Austin will likely shoot past it. Meanwhile, baseball-less markets that passed Pittsburgh by in the 2010 census like Charlotte, Orlando and San Antonio could have more than 500,000 more residents by 2030. That’s not even considering Canadian or even Mexican cities. Some of those markets will likely get a franchise in the next round of expansion as 32 teams could be on the horizon. Most won’t and they’d be candidates for relocation if the Pirates business model broke down here.”
Like I said, nothing would surprise me when it comes to Nutting. If the money’s right, who knows?
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: What do you think of Cody Ponce?
Starkey: I can honestly say I’ve never thought of Cody Ponce, Mr. Holtzy. But he seems like a wonderful man.
Keith, @WhiteW0lf6913: Will the Pirates ever be relevant again? I hoped that I would see a World Series in Pittsburgh before I die, but I don’t think it will ever happen with Nutting as owner of this team.
Starkey: I’ll let that one stand, Keith.
Brian Bolton, @Steelheartzombo: Why isn’t Lonnie [Chisenhall] being forced to watch this garbage in the dugout, like Cervelli and others who are out? He’s being paid almost $3 million and probably doesn’t know what the Pirates’ record is.
Starkey: Make him sit in the dugout and watch this? I don’t believe in capital punishment, Brian.
But I will say this: The Chisenhall situation is very strange, to say the least, and another strike against Huntington. Nutting overlooks a lot, but if anything could attract his attention, it’s flushing $2.75 million down the toilet.
michael griser, @steeltown67: Favorite Cape May County bar and restaurant. Yes, they can be the same place, but that’s the easy way out.
Starkey: Bar — Ugly Mug.
Restaurant — Louisa’s Cafe.
godhatesyeast, @godhatesyeast: What are the odds on a public referendum stripping Bob Nutting of [Pirates] ownership and putting the club in a civic trust?
Starkey: About the same as Lonnie Chisenhall winning National League MVP.
Vic S., @VicSchmidt5: Do you think they should just put a huge screen up and show movies instead of Pirate games? Nutting could run commercials for 7 Springs in between movies.
Starkey: I think they should put up a huge screen showing Lonnie Chisenhall watching movies.
BustedLockerPodcast, @bustedlocker: Is there anything — and I mean ANYTHING — for Pirates fans to be excited about in the coming years? Or are we embarking on another long run of ineptitude and failure?
Starkey: Some would say zero playoff series wins since 1979 is a long run of ineptitude and failure, Mr. Busted.
Man Davidson, @PlatinumBulge: Why can’t Josh Bell throw a baseball accurately?
Starkey: Great question, Man. I cannot figure it out. It’s like watching Pedro throw the ball all over again, and I’m amazed more teams don’t try to take advantage of it.
I think back to July 16, when the Cardinals foolishly failed to challenge Bell’s arm. Game was tied 1-1 in the bottom of the seventh with nobody out and men on first and third. On the first play, Matt Wieters hit a grounder to Bell. Dexter Fowler did not break from third immediately and did not even break when Bell threw a one-hopper to second. Unreal. The next hitter, Harrison Bader, fouled out to Bell behind first base and down the line a bit. Any other first baseman, I would not have thought to tag and run home. Against Bell, the Cardinals were derelict of duty not to. And to their eternal shame, they lost a baseball game to the Pirates. That is one of two Pirates wins since the All-Star break.
Nick Parrilla, @pghnjpiv: What is your favorite mailbag question of all tine?
Starkey: This one.
Mike Mikus, @MikeMikusPA: How long will it take the Pirates to really become a contender again? The farm system is lacking, especially when it comes to starting pitching. I see nothing but mediocrity (at best) in their future.
Starkey: If by contender you mean legit World Series threat, long would be the answer, Mike. If by contender you mean hanging around a wild-card spot, that could be as early as next season, for this reason: It’s really hard NOT to hang around a wild-card spot. You have to be truly terrible. Like, nine-game-losing-streak terrible. My God, the Reds are within 5.5 games of a wild card. But I assume you mean World Series contention, and that’s not close, which makes it practically imperative the Pirates turn a relief pitcher (Vazquez) into high-end young talent.
I’m kidding, it’s Dave, @TotallyNotDave: When do you think fans can reasonably expect a World Series appearance and why?
Starkey: As I said a few mailbags ago, Dave, I have a gut feeling about 3018 — with Clint Hurdle still the manager.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Click here to subscribe to our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.