Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Tike Redman and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
tchoumi, tchoumi19: Chances the Penguins go after a great d-man (Subban, Karlsson?) sacrificing a forward (mainly Kessel) to ice a team « a la » San Jose 2018?
Starkey: Did I miss San Jose’s Cup parade, Mr. tchoumi? They only survived the first round because of an idiot referee.
Anyway, that won't happen. I do still see a Kessel trade this offseason, even if some of the best reporters in the business are pulling back the reins.
Bob McKenzie: “I think Phil is trying to push the Penguins to talk to other teams that he knows have interest in him that would be more interested in going to than Minnesota. And I get the sense that Pittsburgh is having none of that. I think the latest [sense] in Pittsburgh would be that if we can’t get the Kessel-for-(Jason) Zucker deal done then fine, we’ll keep Phil and he’ll be part of our team. Knowing that obviously it’s not the most favorable situation when you’re a player like Phil Kessel knowing that the Penguins are trying to move on from you. We’ll see how that soap opera plays out.”
Pierre LeBrun: “A week ago I would have told you it was 99 percent certain that Phil Kessel would get dealt this summer. Now that has softened. That’s because the Penguins have let Kessel know they’re more than happy to keep him if a trade can’t be worked out. My read on that is that GM Jim Rutherford is only going to trade Kessel in a real hockey deal where he gets tangible assets in return. He’s not looking to make a soft deal where it’s just about dumping Kessel — who remains an offensive force — Rutherford wants a return that reflects that.”
Read More
My read on that: The Penguins insisting they are perfectly happy to keep Kessel reminds me of when Kevin Colbert was vouching for Antonio Brown's impeccable character. It’s a last-resort effort to try to retain the best possible trade value when everybody in the world knows you REALLY want to trade the player.
As in, “Hey, we’re perfectly happy to keep Kessel — just so you know!”
The Penguins aren’t perfectly happy to keep Kessel. They want to be rid of him. He knows that. I suppose there’s a small chance he stays — it might be just like Phil to want to stay with a team where management no longer wants him — but it’s far more likely the Penguins settle for the best deal they can get. Even if it’s to Oakland for third- and fifth-round picks.
Brian Morris, @BrMorris1: Why do golf spectators wear golf spikes when all they do is sit and watch golf all day long?
Starkey: I don’t even know why golf spectators exist, Mr. Morris. Who wants to watch grass grow? This is a better question for @KDPomp. He sometimes wears golf spikes to our show on Mondays.
Nick Papagiorgio, @Tbuettner1979: Did you know that anyone under 35 has no idea what a mailbag is ... stay relevant my friend
Starkey: Good morning, Nick. I’ll let the people respond …
jaeson, @_tesey: my man i’m 19 and all it takes was being born with a brain to know what a mailbag is.
Ryan Knee, @Elbowuindagut: I’m 27. Not only do I realize mail still comes in a bag (like seriously, mail still exists) but I also used my context clues to figure it out
Tom Reynolds, @tomreynolds56: Methinks anyone who can't put that together is probably also trying to listen to your radio show on a toaster or a smart fridge. So I wouldn't worry.
Greg Spicuzza, @greg_spicuzza: I'm 31 and not an illiterate moron, so yes, I know what a mailbag is
Thank you, Nick, for participating.
Rob Perkey, @Perk-ocet21: Which Pittsburgh athlete would be the best Jeopardy! contestant?
Starkey: A week ago, I would have said Josh Dobbs (literally a rocket scientist). But that was before I spoke with Christian Scotland-Williamson.
Now I think it’s a draw.
Rob Gateway, @RobGateway: Do you think Bob Nutting honestly cares about winning?
Starkey: Does he care? Of course he cares — sort of in the way I care about my dilapidated back deck getting restored. I care about that. I really do. I wish it wasn’t such an eyesore. I’d prefer it looked great.
So yes, I care about the deck. But that really isn’t the question, is it, Mr. Gateway? The question is whether I care enough to do something about it. Like spend the necessary money to get it fixed, and have you seen what a job like that costs?
I don’t care that much.
not a pirate, @RevD98: Worse? Spider or bee in the car?
Starkey: This is the kind of question that has people from across the planet — the universe, even — reading the “mailbag.” It’s a wonderful question. I have nearly crashed from both, but it’s definitely a bee.
Bees fly. That’s the difference.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Click here to subscribe to our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.