Joe Musgrove didn’t so much call out Pirates management the other day as state the obvious.
“It would be nice to have another starter we can run out there,” Musgrove said.
Who wouldn’t agree with that? I’m fully on board with the Pirates making a run at Dallas Kuechel, or, more realistically, James Shields. Shoot, before Steven Brault’s brilliant performance Wednesday in Cincinnati, I was on board for a run at Josh Fogg or Jimmy Anderson.
But you know what the Pirates need more than Kuechel or Shields or any other outside help?
They need Joe Musgrove. That’s who. And Chris Archer. And they need them now.
The pitching staff is reeling. The only healthy starters (depending on Jordan Lyles' situation) left in the season-opening rotation are the same two who’ll open a big series against the Milwaukee Brewers — Musgrove and Archer. They also were the centerpiece acquisitions in blockbuster trades, trades that don’t look great at the moment, and the Pirates need them to deliver. Immediately.
Read More
It’s time. This team was in danger of falling into a last-place tie with the Cincinnati Reds in the NL Central on Wednesday, a day after preening Derek Dietrich smashed three more home runs (he has seven against the Pirates this season) and somehow resisted the urge to perform naked cartwheels around the bases. Thursday begins a stretch of 14 consecutive games against two quality offensive teams in the Brewers and the Atlanta Braves.
More is needed from Musgrove and Archer. Much more. Their May earned-run averages are bloated to near-Neverauskas levels.
Musgrove: 8.25.
Archer: 8.56
To be fair, even combining those two numbers won’t get you near Dovydas Neverauskas’s 18.90, but it’s not Neverauskas these guys are getting compared to. It’s Gerrit Cole, Tyler Glasnow and Austin Meadows — the three main players sent out in separate deals that brought in Archer and Musgrove, among others.
Those comparisons are not flattering as June beckons.
Cole, who faded late in his Pirates tenure, leads the majors in strikeouts and is coming off a Cy Young-worthy season with the Houston Astros. Meadows has become Mickey Mantle in Tampa Bay — he just smashed his 12th home run and would easily lead the AL in batting (.356) if he had enough at-bats — and Glasnow was 6-1 with a 1.86 ERA before he got injured.
The Pirates don’t need Archer or Musgrove to lead the league in anything. They don’t need them to be stars. They just need them to be consistently good.
Both have battled injury. Both have experienced stretches of success. Musgrove was spectacular in April and very good last July. But he also has sprinkled in months with ERAs of 5.47, 5.40, 4.20 (not terrible but not good enough) and the aforementioned 8.25.
Nobody questions Musgrove’s arsenal or competitive desire. He’s plenty intense, as he showed with that slide against Javier Baez and the Chicago Cubs last season. He obviously has the guts to speak up on personnel matters, as he did the other day. But the fact of the matter is he remains an unknown quantity as a starting pitcher, and the Pirates need him to become a consistent force. That is what they projected upon dealing for him. That is what his stuff warrants.
Archer was great last September, but that was a month too late. His numbers across the board are in alarming decline. Take his ERA, which has gone this way by season, beginning in 2015: 3.23, 4.02, 4.07, 4.31, 5.75. Or his strikeouts per nine innings, which has gone like this: 10.70, 10.42, 11.15, 9.83, 8.85.
It’s Chris Archer Bobblehead Night on Saturday at PNC Park. The Pirates obviously planned on Archer being a huge part of their team this season.
He still can be, starting Friday.
It’s time.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.