There should really be some kind of punishment for the anonymous “scout” who ripped Josh Bell. Nobody should be allowed to be that wrong without repercussion.

Maybe the guy should be forced to reveal his name. Or pitch batting practice to Bell with no cage to protect him.

More likely, he’ll want to stay anonymous forever, given the way Bell is bashing the ball.

Mr. Mystery Scout called Bell a “big lump” in Sports Illustrated's season preview, you’ll recall, and added this little gem: “Supposedly [Bell] is a big power threat, but he hit 12 home runs at first base. This is not a kid! This is his third year in the big leagues! I don’t think he’s got the ability to get better.”

Advertise with us

I wondered what Bell thought of that, a half-hour after he smashed a 472-foot home run into the Allegheny River on Wednesday. That brought his season home-run total to nine (on pace for 44) and raised his slugging average to .648, good for third in the National League. He’s not in Cody Bellinger territory — who is? — among NL first basemen, but he is out-slugging the rest of his considerable competition. He is trending toward a richly deserved All-Star Game invite.

But back to SI.

“I didn’t really read it,” Bell said. “Didn’t really want to respond. But I feel like everyone’s entitled to their opinions. I’m sure there are people right now who can still find flaws in my game. I’m just trying to play for my boys. That’s the most important thing: try to scrap out wins with the guys in the clubhouse and try to leave the rest, you know, with the rest.”

The rest of this story should be fun to track. Bell might never be Keith Hernandez defending his position, but he’s improving, particularly at picking the ball. And as Joe Garagiola once said of then-red-hot Royals first baseman Willie Mays Aikens, “If he hits like this, they don’t care if he leaves his glove at the hotel.”

If Bell hits like this, he could make history this season — especially with baseballs leaving ballparks at a rate never before seen. He could become the first Pirates player to hit 40 home runs since Willie Stargell in 1973 (Stargell had 44).

Advertise with us

Let us pause for a moment there. No Pirate has hit 40 home runs since 1973? How is that possible? It’s not like they haven’t had any dynamic offensive teams over the past 45 years. The ‘70s Pirates weren’t called The Lumber Company for nothing. Every other team has had at least one 40-homer guy since 2004.

Were you aware of the Pirates’ drought, Josh?

“I wasn’t,” Bell said. “But I am now.”

That led me to wonder if 40 is a number on his mind.

“For the most part, after my first year [26 home runs], I was thinking about 30,” he said. “But my mom wants 42.”

Advertise with us

Why that number?

“I guess that’s just her number in her mind,” Bell said. “She’s always said, ‘Oh, you’re going to have 42 homers. That’s your thing.’ So hopefully I can get in between those two or maybe closer to her number.”

I think he will, and not just because he’s “on pace” to crack 40. A lot of people are on pace for a lot of things in early May. It’s the eye test. It’s the way Bell is hitting the ball. It’s the raw, prodigious power.

I dare say it’s Stargell-like, which is not the same as predicting Bell will be another Willie Stargell. So relax. But did you see him send that Shelby Miller fastball rocketing toward the Highmark sign atop Fifth Avenue Place on Wednesday?

The only surprise was that it splashed into the Allegheny before it got there.

Advertise with us

The exit velocity was faster than Antonio Brown on McKnight Road (albeit barely, at 114.5 mph). Bell’s blast was just the fourth in PNC Park history to reach the river on a fly and the fifth-longest overall, and it wasn’t even his longest home run this season. He went 474 feet over the batter’s eye in center field against the Reds.

One cool thing about Wednesday’s shot was that it came 46 years to the day Stargell hit one completely out of Dodger Stadium. He became just the second player (he was the first, too) to accomplish that feat. It measured 470 feet off Andy Messersmith and smacked the top of a bus.

Richard Peterson, in his book, “Pops: The Willie Stargell Story,” wrote that Messersmith later asked Stargell for the bat. Willie complied but not before issuing a warning: He had four more just like it, Peterson wrote, “in case Messersmith intended to bury or burn it.”

Bell smiled when I asked what comes to mind when the name “Willie Stargell” is mentioned.

“Just ‘Pops,’” he said. “Stargell’s a guy I’ve learned a lot about, being a Pirate. I’ve been able to check out his golfing event in the offseason in [Wilmington], North Carolina. So it’s cool to hopefully be in that company at the end of the season.”

Advertise with us

The Lumber Company, that is.

Joe Star­key: jstar­key@post-ga­zette.com and Twit­ter @jo­e­star­key1. Joe Star­key can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show week­days from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.