Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry Zierlein and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
steelermatt, @MattKappeler: Besides LB, is TE now the greatest area of need from the draft?
Starkey: Interesting question, Dr. Kappeler, because people aren’t really talking about tight ends. The focus is more on receiver in the absence of Mr. Big Chest.
In the end (pun intended), when you spread the field, does it make a difference? A sleek, new-age, pass-catching tight end (read: Noah Fant, Iowa) is really a receiver, right?
Just give me another pass catcher.
Vance McDonald had a career-best season, and I believe there is still more to be mined there. But there’s no rule against deploying two at a time, and the other tight end right now is Goal Line Grimble. I would think the Steelers would be looking at a tight end somewhere in the draft. They should be.
Read More
After inside linebacker, however, the priority should be playmakers in the secondary.
That means anywhere in the secondary. As with the “receiver/tight end” designation, the positional line has become blurred in the defensive backfield. Safety? Corner? Slot guy? Dime backer? Who cares? Just give me people who can cover and make plays.
That is their second-biggest need.
Brett C. Williams, @BrettCWilliams: Is there any reason to think Starling Marte's base running will have evolved beyond that of an 11-year-old little leaguer?
Starkey: Yes, all the way to that of a 12-year-old little leaguer, Mr. Williams.
Actually, that’s harsh. While Marte has a penchant for the spectacular mistake — and isn’t always in Carl Lewis mode on the base paths — FanGraphs had him rated as an above average baserunner last season, based on a complicated metric called BsR.
Feel free to call B.S. on BsR, but at least somebody is trying to quantify good base running.
On the other hand, Marte was caught stealing 14 times, tying for the major league lead. I don’t need advanced analytics to tell me that isn’t good. He also grounded into 11 double plays, which is too many.
Gary Morgan, @garymo2007: You are universal commissioner of all Major Sports Leagues. ...1 immediate rule change for each and why. NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, so you don't have people complain you aren't fixing NASCAR
Starkey:
NFL — Make more plays reviewable (such as: a man jumping the snap by approximately one hour, as in Steelers-Chargers game).
NBA — Any shot from 28 feet = four points.
MLB — Salary floor of $110 million.
NHL — Zero tolerance on hits to head (even incidental = minor penalty).
NASCAR — Cancel it.
Barry Sherry, @TrekRef: Most iconic AB on-the-field moment: The Stretch; the Goal Post; the Hurdle/kick in the face; the Helmet catch; other.
Starkey: Has to be The Stretch, right? It beat the Ravens. It won the division. And he didn’t just bust through anybody at the goal line. He busted through C.J. Mosley and Eric Weddle.
My personal favorite, however, was The Goal Post — the groin busting celebration that saw Mr. Big Chest go footballs-first into the goal post.
Whatever else you think about the guy — narcissist, quitter — he is a breathtaking talent and a natural showman.
Bobby Reese, @BuSt607: Harder worker. Crosby or Bigchest?
Starkey: That’s Mr. Big Chest to you, Bobby. I’d rate them even in terms of dedication to physical conditioning. But when I think of “hard work,” I include the part about, you know, showing up to work.
As in, reporting for your job. On time and stuff. Big Chest never seemed to grasp that concept and eventually said the heck with it, I'll just quit altogether before the biggest game of the year.
Devin, @kontayjis422: Should the Steelers trade some of their picks to move up for one of the Devins (White or Bush)?
Starkey: I have never in my life dealt with this many Devins in one conversation, Devin.
Your name can’t really be Devin, too, can it?
The short answer to your question is yes. The Steelers need a young, all-over-the-field game changer at that position. There are two of them (potentially) available in the draft. If they need to trade up, by all means, trade up.
Quality over quantity.
Chris Haggart, @ChrisHaggart2: Will Baker Mayfield be the next Jameis Winston? Seems everyone has already enshrined him in Canton.
Starkey: First of all, Mr. Haggart, I’m not ready to write off Winston just yet. The raw material is there. He hasn’t been terrible, as his career touchdown-to-interception ratio (88-58) would attest. Let’s see what Bruce Arians can do with him.
But if your point is that early returns on quarterbacks can be deceiving, point well taken. Whether we’re talking RGIII, Winston or Marcus Mariota, young quarterbacks — for a variety of reasons — sometimes regress after early success. Could be injuries. Could be defensive coordinators finding flaws. Could be the team around them crumbles.
Mayfield, to me, looks like a star. He walked into the Browns lineup with barely any meaningful reps (good call, Hue, going with Tyrod Taylor) and had an immediate and dramatic impact. He’s accurate. He’s tough. He’s elusive. He can make any throw. And he appears to have some magic about him, not to mention plenty of weapons.
But you are right: He must prove himself over time.
Ryan Harvey, @CavemanHarvey88: When ZAR gets healthy do you think he will sit out considering how all four lines are playing?
Starkey: Absolutely not, Mr. Caveman. Zach Aston-Reese will play. Whether he will slide back into his slot on the second line — the spot he flourished in — remains to be seen, but there will be a spot for him.
Collin Sturchio, @Collin_S18: How far do you see the Penguins going in the playoffs this season?
Starkey: I see them winning the Stanley Cup, Mr. Sturchio. I really do. Quietly, they are ramping it up for a run. Matt Murray looks like a championship goaltender again. The key, as always, will be health.
While people were focused on late-game malfunctions, the Penguins were getting better and better.
Michael Telek, @mktelek: Pittsburgh barroom brawl: which current and former athlete would be the last one standing?
Starkey: Brian Gibbons.
Dutch Van Loon, @DutchIsClutch: Of the current Steelers receivers, who do you think has the biggest net gain and why?
Starkey: Is your name really Dutch Van Loon? That might be the greatest name of any mailbag participant in history.
To answer your question, Dutch Van Loon, I’d rate James Washington the favorite. After a massive struggle early on, including the infamous jump-when-he-didn’t-need-to drop against the Broncos, Washington started to look like the guy everybody thought the Steelers drafted.
He made plays against New England. He made plays against Cincinnati. I’m incredibly curious to see what happens next.
Thank you, Dutch Van Loon.
A quick aside for our intergalactically popular “Twitter Polls” segment. I posed this question late Monday night and in six hours received nearly 800 votes:
Pirates will win ...
90 or more games (10%)
80-89 games (40%)
70-79 games (36%)
Less than that (14%)
What we learned: People are relatively sane. The Pirates should win between 80-89 games (likely lower 80s), and that was the most popular choice.
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille, who was supposed to work with me on multi-media projects but no longer returns my texts. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.