If you saw Ichiro Suzuki’s goodbye to baseball Thursday and felt nothing, check your pulse. You're probably dead.
Seattle Mariners manager Scott Servais lifted Ichiro just before the bottom of the eighth. The other Mariners waited at the dugout as 46,000 adoring fans rocked the Tokyo Dome. Each man wrapped his arms around one of the most unique baseball players who ever lived.
When rookie pitcher Yusei Kikuchi stepped forward … well, I’ll let Seattle Times reporter Ryan Divish describe the scene. He was there. Just know Kikuchi grew up in Japan idolizing Ichiro.
“When it was Kikuchi’s turn [to offer his congratulations],” Divish wrote, “his arms shook and his eyes welled up with tears. He didn’t want to see Ichiro leave, his experience as Ichiro’s teammate ending after such a short time. Minutes later in the dugout, Kikuchi still was trying to stop the tears.”
What happened next was even more profound, to me. Ichiro simply picked up his bats and walked down the runway. A fitting exit for maybe the most understated superstar in baseball history.
Ichiro had 10 straight 200-hit seasons. He batted .372 in 2004. He had a rocket arm from right field. He stole 509 bases. He accumulated 3,089 hits even though he didn’t reach the majors until age 27, racking up 1,278 professional hits in Japan before that.
And yet, I barely remember watching him play. Maybe it was the fact he spent his best years in the Pacific Northwest. Maybe it was never seeing him in a World Series. Maybe it was his monk-like demeanor.
In any case, as Ichiro disappeared down that runway, it got me thinking: Who had the quietest great career in Pittsburgh’s modern sports history?
I’m not talking Ichiro-level excellence, because so few ever get there. But whose career should we look back on with much more reverence than we do?
I posed the question on Twitter, and Twitter fairly exploded.
A sampling of responses …
— Heath Miller. Oh, come on. He was quiet and humble, sure, and very good. But hardly forgotten. Fans still chant his name when Vance McDonald catches a pass!
— Jack Wilson. Popular pick, but when I look back at Wilson’s career, I don’t think “great.” I apologize for that.
— Johnny Ray. I liked him. A lot. But this is not the category for a .286 hitter sans power.
— Josh Harris. Very funny.
— Levon Kirkland. OK, now we’re warming up. Made the NFL’s All-Decade second team of the 1990s (as did Carnell Lake, who also merits discussion here).
— Hydroplane Deloplaine. OK, now we’re cooling off.
— Martin Straka. Scored some clutch goals and had a serious penchant for weird injuries. I kind of like the pick.
— Alexei Morozov. Really? I mean, I do wonder what would have happened to the KLM line (Alexei Kovalev, Mario Lemieux, Morozov) if Morozov hadn’t been injured. Just not very often.
— Brian Giles. Hugely popular pick. Put up some of the greatest numbers in Pirates history, including the best career OPS (1.018). But he wasn’t even here for five full seasons.
— Jim Morrison. From “The Doors”?
— Rick Kehoe. Another popular pick. Sixth in franchise history in goals (321), fifth in points (636). Jean Pronovost isn’t out of place in this discussion, either.
— Freddy Sanchez. Wasn’t here long enough, but hit .301 as a Pirate — including a batting title at .344 in 2006.
— Louis Lipps. His first two years were amazing — 23 total touchdowns, more than he compiled the rest of his career — and I still remember his ribs joint below the Balcony in Shadyside.
Bryan Hinkle, Jay Bell, Larry Murphy and even Vonteego Cummings (?) were among those who drew votes, and I'm sure we're missing all kinds of quality picks. But enough.
The Final Four …
4. Aaron Smith. Made Sports Illustrated’s All-2000s Team. Did his job and did it incredibly well year after year.
3. James Farrior. Smith’s teammate — and the greatest free-agent signing in Steelers history. A tackling machine, a two-time Super Bowl champion and the undisputed leader of one of the great defenses of the 2000s.
2. Al Oliver. All he did was hit .296 with 135 home runs playing center field for some of the greatest Pirates teams of all-time, including the 1971 champs. If he was overlooked, especially early, it was probably because Roberto Clemente played next to him.
1. Bill Madlock. My Post-Gazette colleague Ron Cook voted for Madlock. Who am I to disagree? I’ll even put him first. “Mad Dog” won two batting titles and a World Series here. Hit .375 against the Orioles. Won two batting titles after that, including a year he hit .341.
Did you remember that? Me neither.
Which is kind of the point.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.