Nobody lives in the moment anymore. They video the moment. Technology killed vitality.
So it’s only natural, I suppose, that replay reviews have killed spontaneous celebrations across the sports world.
LSU upset Kentucky on a last-second shot! Wait … did it? Let’s go to replay (and still get it wrong).
Vegas beat San Jose in overtime! Players are spilling off the bench! Wait … was that goaltender interference? Hmmm. I guess it was. No goal. Buzz kill.
The New Orleans Saints just clinched a trip to the Super Bowl! Wait … well, you know the ending to that one.
Get it right. Wasn’t that the mantra when replay reviews infiltrated the American sporting scene 32 years ago? The system the NFL adopted in 1986 called for a replay official upstairs to initiate all reviews and reverse a call only with “indisputable visual evidence.”
Read More
It all seemed so innocent. So noble. Countless injustices (none in favor of your team, of course) over decades of time could never be repeated now. Perfection would be ours.
Soon enough, the NBA, Major League Baseball and the NHL instituted replay — all in the name of making sure “the right team wins.”
So let me ask you: How’s that working out?
I was watching that LSU-Kentucky game a few weeks ago when LSU’s Kavell Bigby-Williams appeared to win it, 73-71, on a last-second tip-in. The play went to review (most plays do in college basketball these days), and I figured they were looking for two things: whether the shot beat the clock and whether he interfered with the ball in the cylinder.
Turns out he beat the clock. That was clear. But get this: Even though replays showed Bigby-Williams clearly interfered with the ball, NCAA rules don’t permit the use of replay in determining “whether basket interference or goaltending occurred.”
Whaaaat?
Now go back to either of the NFL’s conference championship games.
You know about the NFC game, which featured maybe the most blatant, big-moment missed call in league history. Rams defensive back Nickell Robey-Coleman tackled Tommylee Lewis before the ball arrived, but, like goaltending in college basketball, interference cannot be reviewed in the NFL.
Millions of us saw it. Replays proved it. And nothing happened. They got it wrong in one of the biggest games of the year — the year 2019.
In the AFC game, America watched New England’s Julian Edelman maybe or maybe not muff a punt. Officials on the field awarded Kansas City the ball, but the NFL’s supervisor of officiating, our pal Al Riveron, overruled them, claiming to have seen what was not seeable even with the Hubble Telescope. Riveron somehow determined that Edelman did NOT touch the ball.
I immediately thought of Patric Hornqvist’s goal in Game 2 of last year’s playoff series in Washington. And it was a goal. NBC had a clear shot of a black hockey puck sitting just past the red goal line. That is the definition of a goal.
But that’s when we learned of the “parallax angles” phenomenon. I won’t bore you with the details, which I pray you’ve forgotten. Bottom line is, the goal didn’t count. Which proved, like the Edelman play, that replay is no guarantee you’ll get it right.
Full disclosure: I once was a replay zealot.
I am now a replay heretic. I wish for its eradication from the planet Earth.
Were hockey games really meant to be slowed to Zapruder levels to determine if a man skating 100 mph lifted his skate a hair above the blue line (maybe so, if you’re a Penguins fan remembering the last two Cup runs)?
What about the three-on-one that was mistakenly blown down on a bad offside call? Any recourse for that?
Baseball is a story unto itself, as we watch to see if Player A lifted his pinky above the bag on a steal (“You’re out!”), and we contemplate whether to hire a team of linguists to decipher the blocking-the-plate rule.
In the NFL, a man can jump an hour before the snap (see: Steelers-Chargers) or tackle somebody before a pass arrives (New Orleans knows) and there is no replay recourse and apparently won’t be next season, either. How dumb is that?
Let's face it -- replay is an experiment gone terribly awry, like the creature in "Young Frankenstein" (look it up).
“Are you saying you put an abnormal brain in a 7-foot-tall, 54-inch-wide GORILLA?”
Pretty much, yes. And I’m ready to go one of two ways here:
— Fast forward.
— Far backward.
Fast forward would simply mean using all the technology we have. Such as a computerized strike zone in baseball (they will experiment in the Independent League this year). Such as a member of a football officiating crew sitting upstairs and buzzing down to correct egregious calls or missed calls. No sense going halfway.
Way backward, my preference, would mean reviewing the obvious — home runs, goals, last-second shots — and leaving the rest to a challenge system. Every coach gets two challenges per game. Win ’em, you get a third. Lose one, you lose a timeout. And you live with the results.
Or die with them.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.