Look, it’s not easy to make a case for a guy who’s 23 points off the NHL scoring lead as the best player in the world.

I’m not looking for easy.

I’m looking for right.

The “best player” question arises because the Edmonton Oilers were in town Wednesday. Which means Connor McDavid was in town (which means your defensemen should probably avoid ill-advised pinches while he’s on the ice).

Advertise with us

And while NHL scoring leader Nikita Kucherov and a few others could probably qualify as the current “best player,” I’m going to narrow it to McDavid and Sidney Crosby, and I’m going to start with a question of my own:

Do you value all 200 feet of ice?

If you do — if you value the defensive side of the sport — then Crosby’s your guy. He followed the path of his childhood idol, Steve Yzerman, by radically expanding his game in the 30s phase of his career.

Crosby is killing penalties these days. He has makes a significant difference on the Penguins’ kill. He also is a legitimate candidate for the Selke Trophy as the NHL’s best defensive forward. And he’s not exactly slacking on the offensive end. Going into Wednesday’s game, he had 24 goals and 65 points in 53 games. He’s a hot two weeks away from vaulting himself into the top 10.

Crosby and McDavid didn’t fill the scoresheet Wednesday, but each could have if teammates had finished brilliant plays. You saw their respective styles on full display — McDavid’s ability to make plays at the speed of light and Sid’s incredible vision and passing ability in the offensive zone.

Advertise with us

The two took turns turns puttin’ on the ritz, whether it was Crosby dropping a between-the-skates-pass to Kris Letang or McDavid pirouetting at full speed as he received a pass at the Penguins blue line, then nearly scoring on a high-velocity backhander.

McDavid was awarded a penalty shot at 17:25 of the second period — a Crosby turnover set him up — only to see Matt Murray rob him with a glove save. It also marked the first time I’d seen McDavid skate slowly.

McDavid is the best offensive player in the game. A monster. Early in Wednesday’s game, he started stride for stride up ice with Bryan Rust — who isn’t slow — and quickly made him look like Krzysztof Oliwa. He’s on pace for 120 points. He is the two-time defending scoring champ and the most exciting player around.

But there is more to the game than points and speed. Listen to Oilers coach Ken Hitchcock, who spoke Wednesday morning on the differences between his guy and Crosby. Hitchcock spoke of the stuff only hockey people see.

First, he mentioned Crosby’s unmatched cerebral acumen.

Advertise with us

“Sid thinks at a level, when the other team has the puck, that’s above anybody in the league,” Hitchcock said. “His thinking on the ice when the other team has the puck is so elite that he knows when to pick it off and when to freeze people.”

Then came the critical piece relating to this discussion — and this had to be Hitchcock delivering a message to McDavid, who didn’t exactly bathe himself in glory on Teddy Blueger’s second-period goal (“McDavid’s controller disconnected,” wrote one observer on Twitter).

“Sid thinks (the game) defensively, too,” Hitchcock said. “He’s got both going. That’s what Connor is going to get to.”

Winning counts for something, and Crosby has now won all six meetings with McDavid. Resume counts for something, too, and this is how Toronto Maple Leafs coach Mike Babcock put it earlier this season, in comparing Crosby to the NHL’s young guns, notably McDavid: “I think one guy's got two Olympic gold medals and three Stanley Cups.”

Somebody asked about the other guys.

“They don’t,” he said.