Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lawrence McCutcheon and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Sion, @prog_doc: Tomlin? Should he stay?

Bobby Campbell, @steelcurtain_md: Tomlin out? McCarthy in? Or someone else? Or Tomlin stays?

Ryan M, @genofan: When will Tomlin be fired and the Steelers stop accepting mediocrity and failure?

Advertise with us

#YinzerSportThoughts, @yinzersports45: At what point is enough enough? This team is never prepared under Tomlin and the excuses are getting old. If they lose out the remaining games, is he gone?

DJ Fitzgerald, @Yinzer78: If the Steelers fail to make the playoffs OR play one game and lose again, is Mike Tomlin gone?

Starkey: Even I can detect the theme of today’s mailbag — and I’m the guy who had the Steelers winning big.

Let me answer this question — Will the Steelers fire Mike Tomlin under any circumstance after this season? — with a three-word answer: Not bloody likely.

I never say never, but the Steelers will tell you, with good reason, that stability is the cornerstone of their organization. That when you have a good coach, you stick with him through thick and thin and kickers running up to the ball like Charlie Brown. They might also tell you that Tomlin has won 65 percent of his games and been to two Super Bowls (and still has a chance to win a third straight AFC North Division title, which no team has done).

Advertise with us

Friendly reminder: The season isn’t over.

So no, even if the Steelers miss the playoffs — even if they lose out — I’m saying Tomlin stays, albeit with significant changes to his staff, which includes two of his old buddies in Randy Fichtner and Keith Butler.

And please stop asking about Mike McCarthy. If you believe Tomlin has underachieved with a franchise quarterback, then so has McCarthy (and so has Sean Peyton with Drew Brees; so did Don Shula with Dan Marino, Marv Levy with Jim Kelly, Tony Dungy with Peyton Manning, etc.).

It ain’t easy to win Super Bowls, even with a great quarterback.

The McCarthy and Tomlin resumes are similar, but Tomlin’s is more impressive. He has a higher winning percentage and has been to two Super Bowls instead of one. He also has never lost a team (not yet).

Advertise with us

Now, if you’re asking me if Tomlin should be fired if the Steelers lose out or miss the playoffs — well, that’s a topic we can flesh out later in another forum.

Robert Black, @blackcpa: Do you regret a lopsided Steeler win in your prediction? #0forOakland

Starkey: I do, Robert. It was even worse than Chris Boswell’s final kick, which, by the way, absolutely deserves a nickname.

We have the Mark Sanchez “Butt Fumble,” so how could we not have a name for a kick that banked off David DeCastro’s derriere?

Off the top of my head, I’ll present two. Feel free to submit your own:

Advertise with us

“The Heine Maneuver.”

“The Fanny Whack.”

Ah, maybe it was just an old-fashioned butt-kicking.

Kathy Gasper, @KathyCoffey: Can Boswell be replaced next year?

Starkey: Boswell can, and should, be replaced next hour, Kathy. Enough is enough. If he kicked this year like he did last year, this team would be 9-3-1 (think Cleveland opener, Oakland). Incidentally, him continuously bailing the team out last season might have made some of us believe the Steelers were better than they were.

Advertise with us

Todd Bradley, @ToddWBradley: Does Tomlin really understand “clock management”?

Starkey: It’s more like clock “mangle-ment” in his case, Todd. It’s astounding how he gives away time and fails to explain himself. He treats these matters like a coach who knows he will never get fired (see above).

Tomlin’s refusal to call timeouts before the two-minute warning when his team is about to get the ball back costs his team time in the end. Period. His refusal to stop the clock the instant Oakland got a first down inside the 10 qualified as derelict of duty. Or how about last year’s playoff game, at the end, when instead of kicking a field goal and trying an onside kick — a tiny hope, granted, but the ONLY hope the Steelers had — he insisted on taking shots at a touchdown until he finally got one with one second left on the clock! Just insane.

Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break down the Steelers' loss to the Raiders

Tom, @Tom33541139: Why do the Steelers refuse to run the ball with supposedly an amazing O-line, one of the best in the NFL by many pundits? They faced two horrible rush defenses and still don’t run the ball. Nice lead in the chargers game and still don’t run. Classic game where Cowher runs a lot.

Starkey: I think the plan was to run in the second half against the Chargers, Tom, but holding calls kept putting them behind the sticks. Exhibit A: James Conner’s long run on the first series was wiped out by a holding call away from the play.

Advertise with us

Generally, I agree: They abandon the run too often. I believe offensive lines, like backs, thrive on rhythm in the run game.

I also think there were some opportunities to make yards in Oakland, and the running backs weren’t up to it. Jaylen Samuels appeared to be moving in cement shoes at times, and Stevan Ridley, on what appeared to be a designed run to the right (where there was room), inexplicably cut left, into several humans dressed in silver and black.

So why aren’t they running more in general?

Several reasons. One, I would imagine, is they have a great quarterback. Another might be that the quarterback, like every quarterback, likes to throw a ton. To the point where the Steelers hardly ever run anymore. And his coordinator and head coach apparently have no problem with that.

Ken Sickles, @bstg: What is the return policy on Morgan Burnett? Do we still have the receipt?

Advertise with us

Starkey: They did, but it was intercepted, Mr. Sickles. And certainly not by Burnett himself. He has become the defensive version of Ladarius Green.

Magdy Mikhail, @magdy_mikhail: Why not use last TO to settle down Boswell, slow tempo down a little , psyche him down and check kicking spot on the field?!

Starkey: Great question, Magdy. I agree. Especially the part about checking the spot on the field and testing it thoroughly to try to avoid, oh, I don’t know, falling flat on your rear end?

On the other hand, if Tomlin calls timeout and Boswell misses, people are killing him for psyching out his own fragile kicker.

Steven J Shaffer, @shfe46: How about Tomlin’s obsession with Patriots: guarantee held Conner out, held Ben back for advantage against Pats. Always looks past current game.

Advertise with us

Starkey: Conner’s injured. But Tomlin’s delusional arrogance in believing he could beat Oakland without Ben was astounding. Has he not watched most of his other teams lose to a terrible opponent on the road? Has he never been to Oakland before?

You know what all coaches say, though: We take ’em two games at a time.

Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).