Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lanny McDonald and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

BustedLockerPodcast, @bustedlocker: How much more rope does Sullivan have until people start clamoring for a change behind the bench? It’s not like a midseason coaching change is unprecedented (especially in the NHL), and Joel Quenneville is out cruising for a job.

Starkey: Some are clamoring, Mr. BustedLockerPodcast. Some are clamoring. And they really need to stop. If the Penguins lose the rest of their games — indeed, if they finish 7-71-4 — Mike Sullivan will and should remain the coach.

Do I agree with everything he does? I don’t. But those two Stanley Cups speak much louder than all the “clamoring” in the world. It’s not like the Penguins were a bust last season, either.

Advertise with us

If I were to order the blame for this season’s struggles, it would look like this:

• General manager Jim Rutherford, who put the pieces together.

• The players, several of whom (starting with the goaltender) have been underperforming.

• Sullivan, who seems to expect more from marginal players (see: Sheahan, Riley) than is reasonable.

Your point is well-taken that midseason coaching changes can work in the NHL, but if you believe in your guy — and how could Rutherford and this fan base not believe in Sullivan? — then you stick with him. Not forever, of course. Nothing is forever. But the notion that Sullivan would or should be in any kind of hot water at the moment is ludicrous.

Advertise with us

As for Quenneville, look what happened in Chicago. The Blackhawks exercised plenty of patience with their three-time Cup-winning coach. But after failing to advance beyond the first round of the playoffs two straight years, missing altogether last year and getting off to a rotten start this year, GM Stan Bowman (at least as culpable as Quenneville in Chicago’s decline) finally acted. Perhaps out of mercy more than anything else.

If something like that happens here, we can talk.

For now, and for the love of God, people need to stop.

Dac, @Dac00272734: Is Pens coach and GM on the same page? I don’t see it.

Starkey: What’s up, Doc? I think on certain issues — as one would expect with any GM and coach — there is a difference of opinion, and I think Rutherford probably defers to his coach too often. Seems when the coach isn’t enamored with a player (hello, Ian Cole and Daniel Sprong), the coach gets what he wants.

Advertise with us

But does that represent some kind of irreparable divide? Hardly. When you hire a guy and he wins you consecutive Cups, you tend to put your trust in him.

Near as I can tell, the Sully-Rutherford relationship is fine.

Daniel, @charden2126: When is everyone gonna get off the AB train and come hang out with @TeamJuJu ! His plays down the stretch win ball games when it matters!

Starkey: Your memory is short, Mr. @charden2126. It wasn’t that long ago that AB made one of the legendary plays in Steelers history to beat the Ravens. He made all kinds of late plays last year (Baltimore, Kansas City, Cleveland) to win or help win games. Just two days ago, he made a huge catch to set up Ben’s winning touchdown run.

JuJu has arrived as a legit NFL star. But not at the expense of Antonio Brown. There is room enough for both.

Advertise with us

And did you happen to notice AB has caught a touchdown pass in eight straight games and might finish with 20? His eight-game streak is second-longest in team history to the great Buddy Dial (11).

I would say he is dialed in, but I’ll refrain.

kev redford, @thekevinredford: Is there any truth to the rumor that it was my buying my first ever shersey (Murray), the day of Game 3 in PGH against the Capitals last year, led us to where we are today?

Starkey: That’s what the players think, Kev. To a man, they blame you.

Big Ry, @RyanSchilinski: Write about Pitt football! What happens when we play Clemson? Is there still a bright future for Pickett? Is Pitt playing that well or is ACC Coastal not good?

Advertise with us

Starkey: I do write about Pitt football, Dr. Schilinski, as you can see here. And here.

And I shall answer your questions in order ….

1. What happens when Pitt plays Clemson? Pitt pounds the ball and makes it a very competitive game. I’ll save my official prediction for a later version of the “The Cook & Joe Show.”

2. Is there still a bright future for Pickett? Absolutely. I’ve always loved the kid’s guts. I didn’t like his performance in the pocket for most of the season. I’m sure he didn’t, either. But he picked a great time to find his touch, against Wake Forest. The Pitt passing game showed signs of life the previous week against Virginia Tech. I’m encouraged.

3. Is Pitt playing that well or is ACC Coastal not good? Both. But then again, how many great teams and conferences are there? N.C. State, just last week, was ranked 14th in the country!

Advertise with us

James Walther, @Jwalther623: Didn’t Jags almost deserting the run have a lot to do with Steelers winning?

Starkey: The Jags ran on six of their final nine snaps (excluding the desperation play at the end), Mr. Walther. That would include three straight line bucks to Leonard Fournette — including one on third-and-5 — before they punted back to the Steelers with 1:50 left. Fournette’s last eight runs netted 6 yards.

Blake Bortles is what had a lot to do with the Steelers winning. The Jags don’t trust him.

Would you?

Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).

Advertise with us