Jim Rutherford looks around and sees a team in a slump. I look around and see Jim Rutherford in a slump.
If indeed team chemistry is whacked, as Rutherford suggested Wednesday, then I have to look at the master chemist first. If it’s simply a bad assemblage, I have to look at the guy who bought the parts.
It’s Rutherford’s team, and if he were a goal scorer, he’s finding the net about as often as his bottom six these days — although history tells us his touch could return at any moment. One of his great strengths as Penguins general manager has been the ability to identify his mistakes and correct them, often to astonishing results. Exhibit A: replacing Mike Johnston with Mike Sullivan.
I feel about Rutherford the way he feels about his team at the moment.
“For the most part,” he said, “I still believe in [them].”
Trader Jim has more than fulfilled his mission here. He deserved the three-year contract extension announced Wednesday. He should already be in the Hockey Hall of Fame. But he is indisputably mired in a year-plus cold streak, and he better snap out of it fast, because the window he spoke of Wednesday as remaining open could shut on his fingers in a flash.
Read More
This is a fragile situation, and in Rutherford’s words “a fragile team.”
Look at his significant acquisitions since the Penguins won their second straight Stanley Cup. They have included Derick Brassard, Matt Hunwick, Jamie Oleksiak, Riley Sheahan, Antti Niemi, Jack Johnson, Ryan Reaves and now Tanner Pearson. Three are gone. Four remain huge question marks. Pearson just got here as the return for Carl Hagelin.
Is this the deal that marks Rutherford’s turnaround?
Maybe, although Hagelin is a guy I want on my side when the big games begin. How many times, when the Penguins were shrinking each spring, did we complain of players flourishing in the regular season and flopping in the playoffs? Hagelin was the opposite.
He was never going to be a big scorer. He did the dirty work. He killed penalties. He won puck battles. He sacrificed his body. He helped spark Evgeni Malkin’s huge second half last season. Guys such as Hagelin and Nick Bonino have a special mojo about them that is difficult to replace.
Plus, Hagelin was the player who as much as anyone personified the Penguins’ newfound identity as a speed team under Sullivan. They have slowed considerably in the years since.
What is their identity now?
These Penguins are among the oldest teams in the league, and any team with Johnson and Olli Maatta representing a third of its defense is not going to win many sprinting contests.
Hagelin, a pending unrestricted free agent, was worth that $4 million annual salary because he changed games that mattered the most. On a team with a solid bottom six, he wouldn’t need to score.
This team, however, has been woefully short on depth scoring, and that falls on Rutherford.
So maybe Pearson, who has one less goal than Hagelin this season (which is to say, zero), will find his touch next to Malkin. Or maybe he clicks with Brassard and returns to his 24-goal form of a few years ago. It helps that he has multiple years left on his deal, although that could be the good news or the bad news.
Rutherford has identified several struggling players on other teams — including Hagelin — and pegged them for a turnaround here. He has often been right. I have to give him and his Cups the benefit of the doubt.
I see the Hagelin move as one designed to rattle what Rutherford considers an overly comfortable locker room. Sullivan and his players, notably Patric Hornqvist, adore Hagelin.
I believe Rutherford when he suggests “this could be the start of more changes.” If I’m Maatta or Daniel Sprong, I’m probably checking my phone more than usual.
In the meantime, the Penguins sure could use more from the likes of Sheahan, Brassard (when he returns from injury) and Johnson, who easily could have been scratched like so many of his fellow defensemen earlier this season but was promoted instead. Rutherford signed him to a five-year deal — an eternity in the NHL.
When asked if his intent was to shake up the room with the Hagelin deal, the GM replied in something of a Don Vito Corleone, keep-your-friends-close-and-your-enemies-closer tone.
It sounded cold, but that is as it should be. Bosses don’t need friends. They need results.
“I’m sure [the deal] will affect the chemistry; he's a very popular guy in the room," Rutherford said. "But I’m not sure how strong the chemistry is right now, based on what I’m seeing.”
Me neither. And that falls on the master chemist, who knows the following to be true: If his newest experiments don’t work, he might have to blow the whole thing up.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.