The stench of September was real. The criticism of Mike Tomlin was valid (some of it, anyway). The Steelers were a disheveled mess a quarter of the way into a season of great promise.
Players spoke bluntly of communication failures on defense. Chaos is what it looked like, the kind of clown-car stuff even a novice fan could spot. Like having the wrong number of players on the field in key situations.
This defense, which became Tomlin’s baby when Dick LeBeau was sacked, seemed hopeless. Between last year’s playoff debacle against Jacksonville and this year’s home opener against Kansas City, it surrendered 80 points. It didn’t look appreciably better when the Baltimore Ravens rolled up 451 yards to drop the Steelers to 0-2 at Heinz Field.
On the other side of the ball, the star running back was jet skiing in Miami, the star receiver was in meltdown mode — even failing to show for work one day — and the star quarterback was off to an up-and-down start.
The special teams weren’t helping, either. Notably the kicker who suddenly couldn’t kick straight.
If I heard one talk-show caller, I heard ’em all: Tomlin’s lost the team.
Read More
They almost sounded sane.
Honestly, as the Steelers lugged a 1-2-1 record into a home date with the high-scoring Atlanta Falcons, it seemed like one of the few critical-mass moments of the Tomlin era. Meaning a time you couldn’t help but wonder if things might come apart.
That hadn’t happened since 2014, when, after consecutive non-playoff years, the Steelers imploded in Cleveland to drop to 3-3. But things did not come apart. They never do. That team went 8-2 down the stretch.
A year earlier, the Steelers unthinkably started 0-4 — another potential crisis — but things did not come apart (they never do). That team fell to 2-6 after dropping a 55-31 squeaker in New England. But it won six of its final eight and nearly made the playoffs.
So maybe we should have known this would happen. The Steelers hammered the Falcons, won three more in a row and then achieved football Nirvana on Thursday against Carolina. They have firmly established themselves as a Super Bowl threat.
If Tomlin was a legitimate target for criticism a month-and-half ago, he is a logical target for praise right now.
We could keep it general and point out that he is 26-5-1 in his past 32 regular-season games. We could also say what’s true of every good coach from pee-wee soccer to professional football: Their teams improve.
Since the “unleash hell” season of 2012, his teams have won 75 percent of their games (34-11) from November onward.
We could also get specific. Start with Tomlin’s demeanor and philosophy. He treats his players like grown men. That sometimes comes back to bite him, but in the end, isn’t that more on the stunted player than the coach?
In times of trouble, Tomlin reacts like a strong leader should — calmly. Nobody wants to the see the pilot sweat when the plane’s shaking. Tomlin doesn’t sweat.
“He doesn’t freak out,” safety Sean Davis said.
Linebacker Jon Bostic appreciates the consistency of his new coach’s approach.
“It’s so much of the same here,” Bostic said, when I asked what he has discovered in his first few months in the organization. “Guys play hard, and they play for each other.”
Terry Bradshaw was alarmingly inaccurate when he said in September that Tomlin isn’t the CEO type. He even criticized Tomlin for “chest-bumping” players. Does anybody rip Sean McVay when he chest-bumps Jared Goff after a touchdown pass?
In fact, Tomlin comports himself as any effective CEO would — with the utmost self-assurance. With the perfect balance of patience and urgency.
That doesn’t mean he’s unemotional, especially on game days. Bill Cowher was similar in that way. He’d be spraying spit on Sundays, but he actually ran the place with a steady hand.
And while we’re on the topic, let’s be clear. This all starts at the top. The following fact isn’t news, but I often shake my head when I say it out loud: The Steelers have employed three head coaches since 1969.
The Cleveland Browns have employed three coaches since 9 o’clock this morning.
More specifically on this season, here’s some of what Tomlin has done right, or so it would appear …
• Replaced Todd Haley with Randy Fichtner as offensive coordinator. Bradshaw and many others couldn’t fathom the move. They should now. The Steelers are on pace to average more points than any team in franchise history, largely because Fichtner has succeeded where Haley did not — the red zone.
• Had outside linebackers T.J. Watt and Bud Dupree switch sides.
• Switched Sean Davis to free safety, where has overcome early struggles to flourish.
• Chose second-year pro Josh Dobbs over Landry Jones as Ben Roethlisberger’s backup.
A deficient coaching staff doesn’t come up with the kind of short-week plan Tomlin & Co. conceived for Carolina.
Give the man some credit. He deserves it.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.