Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lafayette Lever and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Andrew Ingatz, @ajignatz: Should the Steelers go after Patrick Peterson?
Starkey: We talked about this last week, Mr. Ingatz, and the answer remains the same:
YES YES YES YES YES YES!!!!!!!
Of course they should go after him. They should at least be interested. They are a team with Super Bowl aspirations, in a pass-crazed league, and they have a catastrophe on their hands at the cornerback spot opposite Joe Haden.
So yes, they should be in the market for an affordable star cornerback in his prime who is not a rental player. If that requires a first-round pick, so be it. I’m pretty sure the franchise would survive.
Read More
Besides, Antonio Brown wants this to happen.
Automatic chip @P2 to @steelers 🧐🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🙏🏾🙏🏾🤙🏾
— Antonio Brown (@AB84) October 22, 2018
However, there are several significant roadblocks:
The Steelers won’t do it.
The Cardinals won’t do it. Or at least Cardinals owner MIchael Bidwell says a Peterson trade is “not happening.”
In case Bidwell wasn’t clear, Cardinals coach Steve Wilks says a Peterson trade is “out of the question.”
Me thinks they doth protest too much?
I mean, it sure doesn’t sound like the Cardinals are trading Peterson — but it just makes too much sense for them to act here. They absolutely should deal a player who wants out and who will likely be far removed from his prime by the time they are ready to contend again.
The Cardinals have everything to gain here, notably a first-round pick, like the one the Oakland Raiders just got for Amari Cooper. Maybe more.
Which brings us to Bryant McFadden. to whom Steelers fans should always be grateful, because if he doesn’t make the play below, Jerome Bettis becomes Bill Buckner and that Super Bowl case on the South Side has one fewer trophy.
No, the Steelers aren’t going after McFadden (although he might be an upgrade even though he last played in 2011). Rather, it was McFadden who gloriously tweeted this the other day:
#Cardinals All-Pro CB @P2 ideal trade destination is the #Saints. Per source Patrick Peterson. #Whodat
— Bryant McFadden (@BMac_SportsTalk) October 22, 2018
The important detail here is that McFadden, a CBS analyst, happens to be Peterson’s cousin.
The other important detail is this: ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported Monday that, “Peterson feels as if the situation is deteriorating and continues to reaffirm to others that he ‘desperately’ wants out of Arizona.”
The Saints, Patriots and Eagles reportedly have interest.
So should the Steelers.
Carlo Gambino, @Gambino_166: Two free agent outfielders the Pirates should target due to Polanco's injury — McCutchen (for the right price ) and Carlos Gonzalez. Both would bring consistent production and a needed veteran presence to the lineup — your thoughts?
Starkey: McCutchen isn’t consistent anymore, Mr. Gambino — and a reunion at this point would be millions of miles beyond awkward. Gonzalez is interesting, but how much of his offensive production is inflated by playing in Colorado?
Maybe a lot, if you consider this: Over the past three years, his home/road OPS splits go like this: home — .946; road — .675. In other words, I’m not seeing a guy who would flourish at PNC Park.
Swanny, @weswanson: If you could add any current NFL player to the Steelers roster who would it be?
Starkey: Aaron Donald (in case Patrick Peterson isn’t available).
J.D. Haltigan, @JDHaltigan: Question: if the Raiders are unhappy with Martavis Bryant and dangle him again would the Steelers be interested in him again? Sounds preposterous but think on it…
Starkey: I’m thinking on it …. and it sounds preposterous. In five weeks, Mr. I Want Mines, Period, has just 14 catches and no touchdowns. He is also one misdeed from disaster.
By the way, I seem to remember people saying the Steelers had no interest in trading Bryant.
Things change.
Ryan Knee, @Elbowuindagut: Sprong is getting less and less ice time it seems. Yet he’s got three assists in only six games. Is it time for more ice time to help him find a rhythm, or does he need to do more fundamentally before they trust him with more time?
Starkey: This is a conundrum, Mr. Ryan Knee, and this is my concern: Sprong’s confidence has to be waning. The Penguins need to keep him on their roster, because sending him to the minors would require him clearing waivers, and I don’t see him ever flourishing in a fourth-line role.
In the coaches' eyes, it seems he can do nothing right (which might lead one to call him Daniel Wrong).
He’s a sniper, and snipers need to play with highly skilled linemates. He is the classic case of a player who is only maximized in your top six — but the coaches clearly don’t trust him. Sully has nailed him to the bench in third periods. This is a tough case with no clear solution. I’d like to see him get a shot with Sid, but do Sid and Sully want that?
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: If you were a backup QB turned punter at Pitt, what jersey number would you wear?
Starkey: 34, in honor of the late, great Jim Braxton.
Starkey: By the way, I didn’t hate the fake punt featuring one Jeff George Jr. If you look at the replay, Qadree Ollison tripped or he would have been wide open in the flat, and Pitt possibly could have come back to win, and we’d be talking about the legendary mystery punter play forever.
Bill Elm, @BillElm: How much wood could a woodchuck chuck, if a woodchuck could chuck wood?
Starkey: A decent amount, Bill. Certainly enough to fill your fireplace.
Timothy S. Pumpkins, @Timarific: Hi Joe. Why were similar pyramids built by different civilizations on different continents? All around the same time period too. It can’t be a coincidence can it?
Starkey: I mean, it can.
The Spike, @anationofone: Your opinion? The Steelers try to trade for Peterson?
Starkey: Doubtful. But have I mentioned they should?
Donald Hilenbrant, @Hildebeest24: If a car was traveling at the speed of light, would the headlights still shine?
Starkey: Yes, Mr. Hilenbrant. Yes they would.
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.