Joe Starkey’s Mailbag: Who would look better in a Steelers jersey — Patrick Peterson or Larry Fitzgerald?

Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lafayette Lever and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Jonathan Banahasky, @JBanahasky: Is it true Arizona’s shopping Patrick Peterson? If so, who and what would you trade to get him?

Starkey: It’s true if you believe Jason La Canfora of CBS Sports, Mr. B., and I believe him. I'd give up all kinds of things for an affordable star cornerback in his prime, too — unless you think Artie Burns is the better option. I’d rather have Peterson than, say, Le’Veon Bell at this point. I can tell you that.

Advertise with us

Can you imagine Peterson opposite Joe Haden on this defense?

Here is what La Canfora wrote Sunday:

Peterson could be a potential blockbuster that would put the Cardinals in position to make significant noise in the next few drafts. He continues to play at a truly elite level, he is incredibly versatile, and, with the corner market exploding since his last contract, his salaries of $11M in 2019 and $12M in 2020 (when he turns 30) significantly increase his trade value as well.

Salary cap difficulties are real — but almost always workable. The Steelers are in position to strike. Here is what USA Today said about the cap implications:

The Cardinals are still on the hook for $3.7 million of Peterson’s $14.9 million cap hit in 2018. The rest of that ($11.2 million) would transfer over to his new team’s books. His new team could always restructure his deal, convert most of that $11.2 million into bonuses if Peterson is willing to do so. That would bring Peterson’s cap number in 2018 to around $6 million. As for trade compensation, La Canfora reports the Cardinals are looking for multiple draft picks. A first-rounder, or a package of second- and third-round picks should be able to get a deal done.

Can you think of a good reason why you wouldn’t do it? The Steelers are currently riding with Burns and Coty Sensabaugh opposite Haden. This move would make all the Sensabaugh in the world. The trade deadline is 4 p.m. Oct. 30.

Oh, and that wasn’t all La Canfora wrote. Check this out …

Advertise with us

In the past, future Hall of Fame receiver Larry Fitzgerald has always been emphatic about wanting to remain a Cardinal for his entire NFL career, a wish the franchise would always grant, but some general managers wonder if the receiver might alter that stance by the end of the month should this season look hopeless in Arizona and if Fitzgerald, year-to-year with retirement plans, wanted a chance to get a ring elsewhere.

What’s more, Larry’s dad just went off on how the Cardinals are utilizing his son. It’s a pipe dream, I know, but if Fitzgerald would go anywhere to chase a ring, wouldn’t his old stomping grounds make more sense than just about anywhere else?

I bet he’d get Justin Hunter — “Mr. August” — to give him No. 11, too.

Mike D, @TheRealMikeD3: How much longer do we have to deal with the Artie Burns project?

Starkey: I’m still trying to get over the positioning on that touchdown pass to Tyler Boyd late in the first half, Mr. @TheRealMikeD.

It was 1st-and-10 from the Steelers’ 14 with 19 seconds left in the half. Burns was literally 10 yards off the line of scrimmage — he was practically sitting in the stands — in man-to-man coverage with no sign of safety help. How is that possible?

Advertise with us

Boyd could have done anything he wanted. He did. Burns just looked lost. I don’t believe he was seen again after his penalty during the Bengals’ go-ahead drive late in the game. He wound up with 29 snaps, compared to 35 for Sensabaugh, according to Pro Football Focus.

To answer your question, it would seem that Burns’ playing time is on the decline. Maybe toward none. He went from 88 snaps against Cleveland to 58 versus Kansas City to 25 on that disastrous night in Tampa to 52 against Baltimore, 41 against Atlanta and 29 against Cincinnati. He has already allowed four touchdowns this season, as much as he totaled in each of the last two years. He has no interceptions and only one pass breakup. It’s as if he isn’t even there.

It’s not like Sensabaugh is Rod Woodson back there, but he’s probably the better option at the moment. I would say it makes all the Sensabaugh in the world, but I already used that line.

NaNa, @johnnyna04: Why do people call into sports talk radio? 95% on them are morons.

Starkey: To talk with Mullsy.

Advertise with us

Peter F., @petefrompitt: Who is Pitt’s head football coach in 2019? How bout 2020?

Starkey: I actually have inside information on this, Mr. @petefrompitt:

2019 — Pat Narduzzi.

2020 — Bob Pompeani.

Listen, Pete, Narduzzi isn’t going anywhere. He is practically signed for life (the seven-year extension he signed last December takes him through 2024). And as badly as this season has gone, it’s far from finished. Pitt is 2-1 in the ACC with a chance to win more games in a manageable division.

Advertise with us

Narduzzi also deserves next season, no matter what happens the rest of this season. I believe almost any coach deserves five full years. After that, we should have a pretty good idea of what we have. But unless this reaches Kevin Stallings-like proportions, he’s not going anywhere.

In other words, Pomp ain’t coachin’ Pitt anytime soon.

Dustin, @Andrews17D: Will Burfict ever get the physical punishment he deserves, returned to him?

Starkey: [Ed. note — Joe’s only answer here was this link.]

Matt dicicco, @DiciccoMatt: Top 3 sing out loud in the car songs.

Advertise with us

3. “Amie” — Pure Prairie League.

2. “Get Together.” — The Youngbloods

1. “Wild Horses.” — Rolling Stones

— In an unrelated note, I very much like to whistle the “Hogan’s Heroes” theme song.

Mike D, @TheRealMikeD3: Who is worse, Tom Wilson or Vontaze Burfict?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Man, that’s a tough one. I’m gonna say Burfict, because in addition to all the assassination attempts on his fellow union members, he seems to pout and quit (he wasn’t out there for the two-point conversion attempt after the Steelers scored the go-ahead TD, for example, and you all saw him mysteriously leave the field and sit on the bench by himself after Vance McDonald emasculated him).

William Jamison, @MadViking67: Do you think Brassard should be a wing on Crosby’s line? I don’t. It takes away from their strength down the middle.

Starkey: You make a fair point there, Mr. MadViking67. The Penguins are deep, there is no question about that. I just wonder if they’re balanced. I wonder if all the parts fit. They seem to me like a high-end pickup team. Just take the best guys and worry where they fit later.

Tony, @bigteecee: I’ve been in the mailbag more than once, and I’m still not famous. I’m starting to doubt your powers, Stark.

Starkey: Who says you’re not famous, Tony?

Advertise with us

Third time’s a charm.

Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).