Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry David and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Holly Thomas, @hmd121: Saquon or Conner?

Starkey: Great question! Mailbags were made for queries like this, although we should clarify here.

If you’re asking who I would start a franchise with, it’s Barkley.

Advertise with us

If you’re asking who is having the better season, it’s a toss-up — and I’m just about ready to say Conner deserves to start even if Le’Veon Bell reports in shape.

You might counter with something like, “Hey, wasn’t last week’s mailbag about how Le’Veon could save the Steelers’ season?”

I would say yes (I’d have to, because it’s recorded for history on the internet), but that was before Conner saved the Steelers’ season. Or helped to, anyway. He was downright transcendent against the Falcons, notably on the play where he snapped like Nick Saban at a news conference and broke five tackles down the left sideline (he never did get tackled).

Before the Falcons game, the book on Conner was this: He had one great game; what do we really have here?

Now it’s two great games. Now we’ve seen it twice. Barkley has more been consistently productive, but look at the overall numbers …

Advertise with us

• Conner: 581 yards from scrimmage, five touchdowns, 5.5 yards per touch, three runs of 20-plus yards (as many as Bell had all of last season).

• Barkley: 582 yards from scrimmage, five touchdowns, 5.7 yards per touch, five runs of 20-plus, including a 68-yard touchdown run. He also has a 57-yard touchdown catch (on a pass from OBJ, who is actually a better quarterback than Eli Manning).

Also, Conner has fumbled twice (lost one), and Barkley has not fumbled.

So it would appear Barkley has the edge, except for this little nugget from Pro Football Focus:

“Most missed tackles forced as a runner and a receiver through the first 5 weeks this season: James Conner - 32; Saquon Barkley - 27; Kareem Hunt - 26.”

Advertise with us

How about that?

I’m going to call it a tie, which is actually a win for Conner, considering Barkley was the second overall pick.

Brian shindledecker, @geetpicker: How is Alex Smith still in the NFL?

Starkey: Let’s not bury the lede here: Is your name really Brian Shindledecker? That is a first-ballot Hall of Fame name, my friend, and your question arrived just before our guy Smitty threw a pass directly upward, like a champagne cork popping. He isn’t good. But at least Washington didn’t sign him to a long-term deal with $71 million guaranteed.

Oh, wait …

Advertise with us

Jacob Anders, @Jakea_92: How long until Bell is an Eagle? Especially now that Ajayi is out for the year?

Starkey: Long, apparently. The Eagles’ running game is in tatters. Bell would obviously help. But here’s the latest on that situation from Adam Schefter and Chris Mortensen.

Chris Drake, @Drakester45: What’s your level of concern with Matt Murray? Is Riccola really the real deal?

Starkey: The way the Penguins (don’t) play defense, my level of concern for Murray is quite high. Through two games, the Penguins are 31st in goals-against average, which wouldn’t be a problem except that the NHL has only 31 registered teams.

I’m worried for him, quite frankly, as long as this team shows zero defensive conscience. And when I say defensive conscience I’m extending that notion to things like managing the puck all over the ice, which means not giving it to the other team with very little regard for what they might do with it.

Advertise with us

My level of concern with Murray is lower — I still believe he’s very good — but I must admit: Evaluating him is a challenge unlike any other I can recall, regarding any local athlete.

On one hand, Murray, who missed practice Tuesday after being diagnosed with a concussion, has won two Stanley Cups. That stands forever. He was great. On the other, we really don’t have an overwhelming regular-season sample size — 107 games — and nearly half of that has been somewhat underwhelming.

Here is what I think we all forget: Murray is still only 24. He punched the league. The league punched back. His move. And he needs more help.

As for “Riccola,” let us first at least come close to spelling his name correctly. It’s Juuso Riikola, with two i’s — and my two eyes, combined with what I’ve heard from every trusted hockey person I know — tell me he is very much the real deal.

Bobby Reese, at BuST607: Is it easier for college quarterbacks to come in and have success in the NFL now that defense is harder then ever to play?

Advertise with us

Starkey: I think that would stand to reason, yes Mr. BuST607.

Dac, @Dac00272734: If you can’t hit the quarterback, are pass rushing defensive ends out of a job?

Starkey: You can hit the quarterback, Mr. Dac00272734 (are you serious with that Twitter handle?).

Did you miss the Steelers’ six sacks and multiple hits on Matt Ryan the other day? You can’t hit the quarterback in the head or below the knees, and the NFL has probably gone overboard on protecting them. But surely you understand the rationale: Quarterbacks, especially talented young ones, are the lifeblood of the league. I heard J.J. Watt say something last week about how the NFL has prioritized one position over the rest in terms of player safety.

My response: You’re (darn) right they have.

Advertise with us

Tim Kastagir, @tkastagir: How came the Steelers couldn't evaluate that LJ Fort should have been starting in playoff game against Jags last year, over Sean Spence? Or at least make the switch at halftime.

Starkey: Great question, Tim. It wound up Fort played more snaps on special teams (23) than on defense (13). Spence played 54 snaps. Not a lot of them went particularly well. Having said that, I’m not sure I’m ready to christen L.J. Fort as the next Jack Lambert. He appeared to play well against Atlanta, with a sack that ruined Atlanta’s first drive and a touchdown late in the game. That’s for sure. But I’m curious to see more.

Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.

Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.

E.J. Borghetti, @PittBorghetti: If you built your own all-time Bills 53-man roster, who would be the top backup to Jim Kelly: Joe Ferguson or Jack Kemp?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Good morning, E.J. I never saw Jack Kemp play (how old do you think I am?). But the clear and obvious top three among those I have seen:

3. Frank Reich: A backup, yes, but all I need is two games, my friend. He eliminated Cowher’s first team the week after he led the greatest playoff comeback of all time (down 35-3 to Jack Pardee’s Houston Oilers; I was in my apartment in Shadyside furiously consuming cantaloupe and water).

2. Doug Flutie. Bills betrayed him by starting Rob Johnson in a playoff game after Flutie played the whole season. I disowned them and will hate them forever for that.

1. Kelly.

Patrick McCullough, @patnpatty2205: Counting college, where does James Connor rank on the list of rushing TDS at Heinz Field?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Are you serious?

db9876, @db62078: Will we ever see James Washington’s ability to stretch the field this year? Is he actually a legit deep threat at the NFL level? Do we need either him or Switzer to step up as the clear #3? Or will it suffice for them both to contribute equally in that role?

Starkey: Well, Mr. db, it feels like we are a long ways from Randy Fichtner’s succinct scouting report when the Steelers drafted Washington. It went like this: “Runs fast, scores touchdowns.” Washington does not have elite speed. Let’s get that straight. But I wouldn’t give up on him just yet. And he does have a touchdown.

My question is whether winning all those 50/50 balls in college games and exhibition games will translate when he’s going against the best of the best. I think he’ll get more opportunities as we move forward.

As for Switzer potentially being a “clear No. 3,” he was practically phased out against Atlanta. I’m not betting on that.

Advertise with us

Ross Insana, @RossInsana: What realistic position player(s) would you like the Pirates to pursue via free agency or trade to upgrade the lineup? Key word is realistic, so rule out Bryce Harper.

Starkey: Manny Machado? Wonderful question, and when you really look at it the free-agent market isn’t exactly bursting with quality choices, Mr. Insana. Maybe a player like Marwin Gonzalez would interest you? On the other hand, there are various ways to accumulate talent, and one is via trade. You know, like how the Milwaukee Brewers got Christian Yelich.

Chris Mueller, @ChrisMuellerPGH: How are you?

Starkey: Anxious, angry, sleep-deprived and borderline hopeless. You?

FiddyNapy, @fiddy2nap: Is it just me or are a LOT of the other kickers missing XPs and FGs, too?

Advertise with us

Starkey: It’s just you, Dr. FiddyNapy. Thirteen kickers are making field goals at a rate of 90 percent or better, and 25 are perfect on extra points (although a few of those guys are not kicking anymore).

The only kicker worse than Chris Boswell on field goals (50 percent) who hasn’t been fired is Phil Dawson, and he’s 87 years old (yes, Phil Dawson is still in the league! I think he beat Chuck Noll’s first team with a late field goal. I think Jim Thorpe was his college teammate.) Boswell also has missed three extra points, and the only kicker to miss four is Caleb Sturgis, which I’m sure you already knew.

Caleb’s older brother, Nathan, was a pro soccer player with the Seattle Sounders. I went to Seattle once and enjoyed going to the original Starbucks.

Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).