Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Bob McAdoo and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Actually, we start today with our intergalactically acclaimed Twitter Poll segment and a simple question: Who’s going to have more sacks this season — Bud Dupree or T.J. Watt?
As you know, the Steelers plan to have the two switch sides — Dupree moves to the right side, Watt to the left — reasoning that Dupree missed a bunch of sacks last season because the quarterback COULD SEE HIM.
And that’s reasonable, right? I mean, how can you expect a first-round pick to tackle the quarterback if the quarterback can see him? The idea now is to give Dupree the advantage of attacking from the passer’s blind side. If that doesn’t work, they will presumably rush him only if the quarterback is blind-folded.
And if that fails to materialize, Bud Dupree will only be asked to rush the quarterback if the quarterback is dead.
Anyway, I’m not sensing a ton of confidence in Dupree based on the results of the poll I posted late Monday night. Precisely 999 people (couldn’t have gotten one more?) responded, and the results evoked a Dodgers-Pirates game:
Read More
Who gets more sacks this season ....
— Joe Starkey (@JoeStarkey1) July 17, 2018
I’m somewhat surprised by that, considering Watt only had one more sack than Dupree (seven to six) last season, but I’m with the idea that Watt could make a major leap in year two. It’s not hard, by the way, to find plenty of college highlights of Watt causing mayhem from the right and left side at Wisconsin.
On the other hand, you won’t find a ton of highlights of either guy cleanly beating an offensive tackle last season. That needs to change. I know the Steelers set a franchise record in sacks with 56; that was impressive, even if a full 23 percent of them (13) came against the Cleveland Browns and therefore should not count. But where was the pass rush when it mattered?
Where was the outside heat when Joe Flacco came here and dropped 38 on the Steelers? (Yes, Watt finally got to him on the last play of the game, rushing from the left side while Dupree watched from the bench.) Where was it when Tom Brady waltzed down the field late in the Jesse James game? Where was it when Blake Bortles went all Joe Montana in a Heinz Field playoff game?
I have not totally lost hope in Dupree, and I feel like Watt is just getting started. But the time is now for both to make a massive impact, no matter which side they're on (and they will likely switch from time to time).
The Steelers need at least one of them to become a star.
Now to the questions ….
Howard Wiley, @hwileyiii: Why are we spending this much energy on Bell? Nobody's that good.
Starkey: I guess because he has the most total yards in NFL history (since the 1970 merger, anyway) through 62 career games, because he accounts for a ridiculous percentage of their offensive output, because he’s a great runner, receiver and blocker, because he’s on the field for virtually every play, because they’re 2-1 when he plays in the playoffs, averaging better than 30 points a game, and 1-3 when he doesn’t (or leaves real early), averaging less than 20. Other than that, I can’t think of any reasons why the Le’Veon Bell topic is important, Dr. Wiley, or why the Steelers are paying him $14.5 million.
Can you?
JP Hilzendeger, @j3pgh: Joe, did you have a favorite cartoon or tv show as a kid?
Starkey: Yes, I did. “Inch High Private Eye” (which was followed, as I recall, by “Hong Kong Phooey”).
Chris Ganster, @Ctopher2683: Left or right Twix?
Starkey: What?
Joel Sirota, @joelsirota: Worst first round draft choice: Sean Burnett or John Van Benschoten?
Starkey: We could have a long conversation about Pirates disasters in the first round, Mr. Sirota, and Sean Burnett does not belong in it. He never panned out as a starter, but he had a quality major-league career. In 380 appearances, he had a 3.52 ERA.
Van Benschoten, on the other hand, was 2-13 with a 9.20 ERA in 19 starts (26 appearances). You might recall that after picking Van Benschoten in 2001, the Pirates turned the country's leading college home run hitter (he had 31 home runs in his final year at Kent State) into a full-time pitcher.
I once asked Van Benschoten about that.
"I think it surprised a lot of people. But I was like, 'If they want to pay me that much ($2.4 million signing bonus), I'll do anything.’ "
He’s still not the worst, though. That award could go to any number of people, from Bobby Bradley to J.J. Davis.
The worst quote upon drafting a player in the first round, however, indisputably goes to Dave Littlefield, who said of Bryan Bullington — the FIRST OVERALL PICK — “We feel comfortable projecting him as a No. 3 starter.”
Let’s Go Bucs?
Robert Gillespie, @OboeRob: What current Pirates player could win the HR Derby?
Starkey: Austin Meadows … oh, wait.
Trample Under Foot, @Piper_atTheGate: Better Darrin, Dick York or Dick Sargent?
Starkey: Dick York, by a bigger landslide than T.J. Watt over Bud Dupree in the Twitter poll above, Mr. Trample Under Foot. And I might add: Much like a movie sequel, it is exceedingly rare for a second actor to trump the first in a sitcom. The greatest example is “M*A*S*H,” where every follow-up was far worse than the first. That is not an opinion. It’s a fact.
I also didn’t realize that Dr. Bombay (Bernard Fox) lived until 2016. He was an underrated utility player.
joacon, @joeconr: The Steelers can pull their Franchise Tender offer, if Bell doesn't sign, up until the 1st regular season game. Bell would have trouble signing with anyone at that late date. Steelers could use freed cash for defense. Will/should they do it???
Starkey: No.
And no.
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.