In almost any circumstance, I’d say Jim Rutherford was out of line. You don’t make an insinuation about another organization without explaining yourself, the way the Penguins’ gloriously blunt general manager did Sunday upon the signing of defenseman Jack Johnson.
“He was a healthy scratch at the end of the season [in Columbus],” Rutherford said. “I know the reason why. It wasn’t because of how he was playing.”
Why was it, then? Rutherford didn’t say, leaving folks to wonder what might have been going on that the Blue Jackets didn’t reveal (as opposed to, you know, Johnson just being terrible for most of the season). That puts the Blue Jackets in position to have to defend themselves. That is unfair.
Rutherford easily could have said a million other things, such as, “I’m not sure what happened with Jack in Columbus, and it doesn’t matter. We like him.”
Or, “We know Jack has the worst plus-minus rating in the NHL since he came into the league, but we feel like he can flourish here.”
So again, under normal circumstances, I’d say Rutherford was way out of line. But that would be ignoring the fact that John Tortorella coaches the Blue Jackets — and Tortorella has never been one to mind his business. So why should anyone else?
Read More
Tortorella’s mere existence invites antagonism. He had a chance to be the bigger man here, but at 5-foot-8 and with skin as thin as tinfoil, he is rarely the bigger man. He may, in fact, be the all-time best example of “Napoleon Complex,” maybe better than Napoleon himself (although Napoleon won more big games).
It was Tortorella who once said of the Penguins, before Rutherford arrived, “It’s one of the most arrogant organizations in the league.”
He was coaching the Rangers at the time. Penguins defenseman Brooks Orpik tripped Derek Stepan with a questionable hit.
“I wonder what would happen if we did it to their two whining stars,” Tortorella said. “They whine about this stuff all the time, and look what happens. It's ridiculous, but they'll whine about something else over there, won't they? Starting with their two [expletive] stars.”
That was one of many times Torts has flipped, whether it’s chasing down an opposing coach to try to fight him in the locker room (Bob Hartley) or badgering opposing players on the ice. He wasn’t minding his business, for example, when he confronted Alex Ovechkin during a playoff series this year and accused him of diving to draw a penalty. Torts apologized afterward, but it still happened.
Having said all that, I’m glad — grateful, even — that Tortorella shot back at Rutherford. Nobody said he's not entertaining. He’s actually not a bad guy. And it’s great for business.
Torts did more than shoot. He dropped a nuclear bomb. The added twist here, of course, is that he goes way back with his good friend and longtime assistant Mike Sullivan.
“To have a general manager question our decision-making from three hours away, he must be a [expletive] magician,” Tortorella told Aaron Portzline of The Athletic, later adding, “The thing that [ticks] me off the most is a general manager in this league questioning and talking about our decision-making. Shut the [bleep] up!”
Lots to unpack there. Let’s start with the word “magician,” which is, unbelievably, a word Rutherford used in relation to himself just a week ago, when people were insanely wondering if the Penguins might pursue John Tavares in free agency.
“I’m creative,” Rutherford said. “I’m not a magician.”
So is he a magician or isn’t he? I suppose if he were, he could make Tortorella disappear — and if he went Houdini-level, he could make Tortorella win a playoff series.
Torts has been living on 2004 for about 14 years now. He took the Lightning to a Stanley Cup that year. He is 3-8 in playoff series since, losing in the first round six times and missing the playoffs altogether four times. It didn’t go much better when he was called on to coach Team USA at the 2016 World Cup of Hockey. They didn’t win a game. (Tortorella, by the way, scratched Johnson for the showdown against Canada.)
This story doesn’t end with Tortorella and Rutherford, who declined a chance, for now, to respond to Tortorella’s comments. Johnson took an apparent shot at his former team, telling local reporters, “I’ve really been wanting to be a part of a winning culture, in a place where the expectations to win are as high as can be, and there’s a chance to win.”
Johnson later went into damage control, telling Portzline he didn’t mean it as critical of the Blue Jackets. Which is a pretty tough sell.
Needless to say, Torts returned fire, even alluding to Johnson’s horrifying financial crisis that reportedly was caused by his own parents.
"All I know is this organization, from the lawyers, the front office, J.D. [John Davidson], the managers, the coaches, players ... has done nothing but try to help Jack,” Tortorella told Portzline. “And for him to backhand slap us like this is utter [expletive], and he should know better.”
Of Rutherford and Johnson, Tortorella said, “They’re both good people. But what the [heck] are they doing? Get on with your business! I hope [Johnson] plays his [butt] off for ’em, but stay the [heck] out of our business when you don’t know what’s going on.”
He should have just said, “Here, take my advice. I don’t use it.”
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.