I get it. Conor Sheary was expendable. The Penguins needed cap space. Jim Rutherford apparently will use a chunk of it to sign defenseman Jack Johnson, and we all will live happily ever after (assuming Johnson isn’t the next Christian Ehrhoff).
Such is the business of hockey. Sheary is prone to lengthy scoring droughts, and, like several of his teammates, had a forgettable playoff. Rutherford should be trusted on account of his track record.
Sensible. All of it. I just think Sheary deserves more than what feels like a “Thanks for the cap space” farewell from the masses.
I mean, he wasn’t exactly a bystander for those two Stanley Cup runs.
He scored in overtime of Game 2 of the 2016 final — the famous “Sid Calls His Shot” goal.
He had four goals and six points in 12 Stanley Cup final games over two years.
Read More
He beat the New York Rangers Henrik Lundqvist in back-to-back games in the first round in ’16.
He assisted on Patric Hornqvist’s overtime winner in Game 4 against Washington that year. (OK, Capitals defenseman Mike Weber actually assisted on that goal, but Sheary made a quick, nifty play at the left point and propelled the puck toward the net.)
And Sheary, for all his struggles, put up 41 goals and 83 points in 140 games over the past two seasons. Ten of those goals were game-winners.
Yes, it helped to play periodically with Crosby on the top line. Of course it did. But Sheary earned his shifts there. And even if he wound up on the Line of Misfit Toys with Derick Brassard and Tom Kuhnhackl by the time this most recent postseason ended, he deserves to be remembered fondly.
Just getting to the NHL was a monumental feat. The kid’s listed at 5-feet-9, but that’s on stilts. He was cut from his Cushing Academy high school team and bypassed by the bigger programs (Boston College, Boston University) near his home. He wound up at Massachusetts, where he became a star.
Sheary’s story is an inspiring one for undersized athletes. I remember asking his older sister, Courtney, about the hard road he traveled. She had preceded him as a Cushing standout and later became the girls varsity coach there. She used her brother as an example.
“He never really had a growth spurt,” Courtney recalled. “When you go to Cushing, you go through an interview process with the admissions team. One of the guys who interviewed Conor tells me he was so little his feet were dangling from the interview chair. It’s a bit of an exaggeration, but it’s a story we tell kids who have a long way to go.
“We talk about Conor as an example of someone who really stuck with it.”
I once asked Sheary about the day he discovered he had been left off the varsity.
“I probably had to hold back some tears,” he said. “But it was motivation, for sure.”
After Sheary went undrafted out of UMass, then-Penguins assistant general manager Tom Fitzgerald offered him an AHL contract in the spring of 2014. Barely two years later, he scored one of the most dramatic goals in Penguins history, beating the San Jose Sharks in overtime of Game 2 of the Cup final.
Crosby laid out the plan before an offensive-zone faceoff. Sheary found a clearing, took a deft pass from Kris Letang and used a Hornqvist screen to rip a shot past Martin Jones for a 2-1 victory.
Crosby’s plan was brilliant, but somebody had to make the shot. Go back and watch how Sheary reached behind his left skate to take Letang’s pass and then fired accurately with a lightning-quick release.
Keep the video rolling, and you might see Pierre McGuire interviewing a jubilant Sheary about the goal.
“I’m just trying to play in the moment right now,” Sheary gushed. “It’s pretty surreal, this moment I’m having.”
It sure was. And that is how I’ll choose to remember Conor Sheary in a Penguins jersey.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.
Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.