Criticism was warranted. I’ll grant you that.

Phil Kessel wasn’t just awful in that six-game loss to the Washington Capitals. He was invisible. By Game 6 you would have needed a motion sensor to detect his presence.

But does one terrible series undo everything he has accomplished in a Penguins sweater?

That seems ridiculous.

Advertise with us

Should one terrible series restore his pre-Penguins rap as a coach-killing malcontent?

That seems patently unfair (it always did).

Did one terrible series signal the end of Kessel’s time here?

Now we’re talking. That’s the question. And you know what? You’d be crazy not to wonder, as Phil-related rumors swirl like ticker tape heading into Day 1 of the NHL draft Friday in Dallas.

But that hardly means Kessel’s gone. It shouldn’t mean that, anyway.

Advertise with us

It better not mean that.

First, Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford is not in the business of giving away stars. As teams come calling for Kessel — and they will call, because who doesn’t need elite offense? — Rutherford will ask for the world, as he should.

Secondly, and more importantly, the Penguins are a better team with Kessel. We’re talking about one of the top five wingers in the NHL here. Maybe the best playmaking winger in the world. Even a brilliant horse trader like Rutherford would have trouble winning a Kessel trade, because Kessel will be the best player in that deal.

Kessel is what separates the Penguins from the rest of the league. Who else has three prodigious talents to match Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kessel? He helps make the power play what it is by working his magic on the left side. He wants to play with Malkin at even strength (does anyone know if Malkin wants that, too?), but coach Mike Sullivan prefers a balanced lineup with each star basically having his own line.

There are merits to both schools of thought — and the difference in thinking doesn’t have to be a deal-breaker. I mean, are we sure Kessel and Derick Brassard couldn’t mesh on a potentially lethal third line? A fresh and healthy start for both could do wonders. They spent about five minutes together.

Advertise with us

We’ve all seen the pre-Kessel playoff Penguins. They once scored two goals in an an entire series (Boston). They couldn’t beat Henrik Lundqvist if they had two nets to shoot at.

They needed big goals. Kessel provided them. TONS of them. He led the NHL in playoff goals over the 2016 and ’17 postseasons. He then posted the best season of his career before he mysteriously disappeared against the Capitals.

Kessel isn’t the first Penguins star to have a rough playoff. It’s just that his pratfall seemed so inexplicable. Was he injured? Was he pouting? Was he just playing poorly?

Impossible to say, but I believe this: Kessel, like goalie Matt Murray, deserves a mulligan. Both have earned as much.

Meanwhile, it’s hard to believe the Sully-Kessel relationship is irreparable. Whatever issues existed, they didn’t prevent Kessel from putting together a 92-point regular season.

Advertise with us

Maybe the Penguins believe they’ve gotten the best of Kessel and will see diminishing returns as he heads into his early-30s and the remaining four years of his contract. I could respect that line of thinking. I would simply counter by saying he showed up in the best shape of his career last season (relatively speaking), delivered over 82 games and shows zero signs of suddenly disintegrating. He had one terrible series.

I would counter with this, too: His contract, contrary to popular belief, is not an albatross. At $6.8 million a year, it’s actually a bargain.

The Penguins could help fortify their future by dangling Kessel for a top-five pick (hello, Arizona) or by securing a younger impact player or two. But this should still be a win-now operation.

Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

Advertise with us

Spare me the idea, by the way, that Daniel Sprong would somehow make up for losing Kessel. I like Sprong — I can picture him next to Crosby — but he and Kessel exist in entirely different solar systems.

Rutherford’s take, in speaking to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey last week, acknowledged the obvious: Sully and Phil aren’t best friends. This is old news. And it's as much on Sully as Phil to find a way to work it out.

“I think it will be resolved,” Rutherford said. “Will they get together for a special meeting? I’m not sure that’s necessary at this point. If it is, they’ll figure that out themselves. Knowing Phil the way I know him, knowing Sully the way I know him and their passion for winning, when they come back to camp, it’ll be business as usual.”

Nobody doubts Sullivan’s intelligence or competitive fire. They shouldn’t doubt Kessel’s, either.

He had one terrible series.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.