“They took a shot at our catcher when he had his back to him, and he was unable to defend himself, and we thought that was wrong.” — Joe Musgrove

We weren’t crazy, after all.

By “we,” I mean those of us who saw Anthony Rizzo’s dirty, dangerous blindside shot on Pirates catcher Elias Diaz and thought, ‘Wow, that was a dirty, dangerous, blindside shot.’ ”

I don’t care if Ty Cobb did this a hundred years ago. It was a gutless, illegal, potentially injurious play that deserved retribution.

Advertise with us

Will retribution carry the Pirates to a division title? Not bloody likely. But sometimes a team really needs to make a stand.

One point none of the old-school, baseball-zealot Rizzo defenders made was this: It wasn’t even a “slide” at the point of contact.

Rizzo, after dramatically and illegally changing his path in order to make contact — he had a FOOT ON THE GRASS, for God’s sake — crashed into the back of Diaz’s leg before his knee or rear end hit the dirt. That’s more of a football clipping-penalty scenario than a “slide.”

The sane among us realized as much. We knew it because we saw it. And yet we were told it was fake news. Just a good old-fashioned baseball play by a good old-fashioned baseball guy.

To his credit, ex-Pirates catcher Michael McKenry said this on AT&T SportsNet after the game: “The more I watch it, the more it could have been really, really bad. You never, ever want to see that happen. And if that was Rizzo’s intent, shame on him. Shame on him is what I say.”

Advertise with us

The sane among us were told, against all reason, that it was Diaz’s fault! That he over-dramatized the contact. That he didn’t deserve to be avenged. That he didn’t give Rizzo enough space, even though replays showed him well off the plate by the time he cocked his arm to throw.

The Cubs actually wanted us to believe Rizzo couldn’t have done anything but what he did.

“[Diaz] didn’t really give a choice there,” Rizzo said, laughably.

“That’s how you should teach your kids to slide and break up a double play,” said the Cubs’ condescending, disingenuous manager Joe Maddon. “The catcher’s gotta clear a path.”

Maddon, of course, is the same guy who watched one of his players (Chris Coghlan) destroy Jung Ho Kang’s knee a few years ago and then flippantly wonder afterward if Kang was suffering from “Plantar fasciitis.”

Advertise with us

God, what a jerk.

And can’t you just imagine your kid’s next Little League practice ...

Coach: “OK, boys, if you ever see the catcher make a force play at home and try to throw to first, change your path and crash into the back of his leg while he’s totally defenseless. Make sure you don’t hit the dirt until after you’ve slammed into his leg.”

Parent: “But isn’t that kind of dangerous?”

Coach: “Maybe, but Joe Maddon says it’s the way to play, regardless of the rules, and he invented baseball.”

Advertise with us

But it wasn’t just the Cubs. There were baseball militants in these parts, and ex-players everywhere, who went out of their way to defend Rizzo.

We were told nobody in the Pirates clubhouse had a real problem with Rizzo, so why should we?

The message, essentially, was this: “Don’t be such a wimp; that’s how real men play the game.”

I began to wonder if I’d lost my mind. Did I see what I saw? Was this really going to go unavenged? (Although, the Pirates did hit Cubs catcher Willson Contreras twice the next night — the second of which appeared intentional).

Then along came Joe Musgrove, and Joe Musgrove reversed the narrative with one hard slide and one beautiful quote.

Advertise with us

Peddlers of fake news aim to confuse. Joe Musgrove aims to clarify.

You saw Musgrove’s slide. So did Cubs second baseman Javier Baez. That’s kind of the point. He saw it, and therefore had a chance to avoid it. That he chose not to is his problem.

Here is what Musgrove told 93.7 The Fan after the game. Read closely:

“[Baez] had every opportunity to get out of the way, but he decided to stand right on second base, and I don’t think I did anything wrong by going in hard. They took a shot at our catcher when he had his back to him and he was unable to defend himself, and we thought that was wrong.”

Let’s be clear, then, because accuracy is the antidote to fake news: Musgrove and others on his team thought it was wrong to shoot a guy in the back. Why? Because it is wrong.

Advertise with us

Let’s be clear again: Musgrove was offended by the Rizzo play. Now, would anybody care to question Musgrove’s toughness? ‘Cause if you know his story, he seems like a pretty tough guy to me (loved the fact that he sprinted out a sacrifice bunt later in the game, too).

And guess who was waiting in the dugout to congratulate Musgrove after the dust-up?

Elias Diaz, that’s who. Diaz was the one guy who had publicly ripped Rizzo. Diaz thought he deserved retribution. He did. And it came. Good for Joe Musgrove, and good for us.

We weren’t crazy, after all.

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Advertise with us

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.