Nobody was surprised when the question arose after Game 1: Who is your goaltender?

Merry Goal-round

No fewer than 23 men have started in goal for the Philadelphia Flyers since Ron Hextall retired in 1999. Precisely none of them became a franchise goalie. Here’s the list, in alphabetical order:

Johan Backlund — One career start: a 4-1 loss to Penguins on March 27, 2010. Matt Cooke scored.

Advertise with us

Martin Biron — Penguins wrecked him in 6-0 series clincher in ’08, marking first trip to Cup Final since 1992.

Sergei Bobrovsky — Won the Vezina his first full season with Columbus after Flyers impatiently dealt him for picks.

Brian Boucher — Made 57 saves to beat Penguins in five OT game in 2000, helped Flyers to Cup Final 10 years later.

Ilya Bryzgalov — Roasted Brian Elliott with a tweet during Game 1 Wednesday. Flyers insanely signed him to a nine-year, $51 million contract in 2011.

Sean Burke — Was 1-4 in Flyers playoff career.

Advertise with us

Roman Cechmanek — Traded after season in which he had 1.86 GAA and .925 save pct, said of Philly fans, “They hate me.”

Brian Elliott — Sort of a rough Game 1.

Ray Emery — Volatile, talented, ultimately underachieved in two stints.

Robert Esche — Nicknamed Chico

Jeff Hackett — Pretty much cooked by the time he got there.

Advertise with us

Cal Heeter — Who?

Michael Leighton — Helped Flyers to Cup fnal in 2010, now plays for Penguins’ minor-league team in Wilkes-Barre.

Neil Little — Claim to fame was racing down ice and leaping into minor-league brawl.

Alex Lyon — His topic for senior thesis at Yale: Global nuclear war.

Steve Mason — Was pretty good in Philly, but not good enough.

Advertise with us

Petr Mrazek — Could see him real soon if Penguins keep scoring touchdowns.

Michal Neuvirth — He’s still there.

Antero Nittymaki — Tied franchise record with 29 losses in 2006-07.

Maxime Ouellet — Started one game, gave up two goals to Brett Hull.

Anthony Stolarz — Jersey kid has battled knee injuries.

Advertise with us

John Vanbiesbrouck — Did OK, got traded.

Rob Zepp — Who?

It’s a question the Philadelphia Flyers have been trying to answer since the turn of the millennium. That position, ever since Ron Hextall (the team’s current general manager) called it quits in 1999, has become a virtual merry goal-round.

The issue actually goes back further than that, just not as far as some people think. The notion that Philly never found a decent replacement for 1970s hero Bernie Parent, for example, simply is not true.

Pelle Lindbergh won the Vezina Trophy in 1985 before his tragic death in a car accident. Hextall had one of the great rookie seasons of all-time in 1986-87, winning the Vezina Trophy and then the Conn Smythe despite the Flyers losing in the Stanley Cup final.

Advertise with us

But now? In this particular century? Substitute quarterbacks for goalies, and the Flyers are the NHL’s highest-profile version of the Cleveland Browns.

The Browns have employed 28 starting quarterbacks since ’99. The Flyers have started 23 goalies, by my count. The latest is Brian Elliott, who was lit up like the Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree in Game 1 before he was mercifully pulled from what would become a 7-0 Penguins victory Wednesday.

Go ahead, scroll through the list of “Flyers goalies of the 2000s.” Shake your head in disbelief. It doesn’t sink nearly to the level of Cleveland’s quarterback carousel — the general pedigree is much higher than that of, say, Spergon Wynn, Brandon Weeden or Brady Quinn — but it’s astounding how the Flyers, much like Khloe Kardashian, cannot settle on one man.

There’s a Sergei Bobrovsky here (the Flyers traded him right before he won a Vezina in Columbus) and an Antero Nittymaki there. A Brian Boucher here and a Steve Mason there.

They’ve had no-names such as Cal Heeter and Johan Backlund start precisely one game. They’ve tried aging vets such as John Vanbiesbrouck, Jeff Hackett and Sean Burke.

Advertise with us

They tried Ilya Bryzgalov, who roasted Elliott in a Game 1 tweet, is afraid of bears, believes aliens live among us and was signed to a nine-year, $51 million contract in 2011 (which the Flyers subsequently bought out).

They tried Roman Cechmanek, who was weirdly traded after a season in which he put up a 1.86 goals-against average and .925 save percentage and said of Philly fans, “They hate me.” He then vanished from the NHL after a lost season in L.A.

And they tried Michael Leighton, who helped them to the Stanley Cup final in 2010 and who now plays for … the Penguins’ minor-league affiliate in Wilkes-Barre?

He sure does, and at age 36 boasts a 5-0 record as Tristan Jarry’s primary backup.

I was hoping to speak to Leighton for this piece, to ask him about life as a Flyers goalie, but he apparently wanted no part of it.

Advertise with us

Can you blame him?

Every time something good happens to one of these guys, the other skate drops. I’m sure many an observer has tried to identify the core issue. Ex-Flyers goalie Martin Biron believes the team has lacked patience with some of its goalies — Bobrovsky being the prime example — and that its restiveness has infected the media and fan base.

“Somehow, in Philly, it’s embedded in everyone’s mind that goaltending is the issue,” said Biron, a broadcaster for the Buffalo Sabres. “I don’t think it always is, but it’s the easy one to focus on.”

It is now, after the Penguins put up a 7-spot. So whose turn is it — Elliott, Petr Mrazek, somebody else? Anybody else?

Flyers coach Dave Hakstol wavered a bit late Wednesday before backing Elliott.

Advertise with us

“He’s our guy,” Hakstol said, quite unconvincingly.

Elliott — who looked like Elliott “Mess” in Game 1 — has played three games since missing nearly two months on account of core muscle surgery. He had a disastrous playoff with Calgary last season.

Mrazek would seem to be a decent alternative. In 11 playoff games (10 with Detroit), he has a 1.98 GAA and a .927 save percentage. But since when do the Flyers make sensible decisions with goalies? Somehow, this team finished strong despite cycling through four of them — Mrazek, Alex Lyon, Michal Neuvirth and finally Elliott.

And you know what they say: When you have four goalies, you probably have none.

It’s almost unimaginable seeing the Flyers making this a series given their latest issues at the most important position on the ice. The good news for them, I suppose, is that a hot prospect named Carter Hart continues to impress.

Advertise with us

Hart won a gold medal for Canada at the World Junior Championships, outdueling then-Penguins prospect Filip Gustavsson in the gold-medal game. Some say Hart could arrive as early as next season.

If he does, God help him.

Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the "Starkey and Mueller" show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.