Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Pink, Buffalo and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Halvy Buckets, @halvybuckets: Ok...who does Pitt hire and who should they hire?

Starkey: Well, Mr. halvybuckets, I’ll start here: Every time I see a new name hit the rumor mill, I type his name and “FBI” into Google just in case. And whaddya know, I keep finding bad news. Or potential bad news.

The Sean Miller situation, you know of. I mean, if you’re Heather Lyke and Pitt, and you’re trying to whittle a buyout based on a coach addressing hecklers during a game, how do you in good conscience hire a coach whose top assistant was recently indicted by the Feds?

Advertise with us

Pete Thamel of Yahoo Sports helped break the scandal-in-college-basketball story, and this is what he wrote about Miller’s immediate future: “The trickiest part here is the timing. The federal investigation into basketball is ongoing, and the final of the three trials associated with it isn’t slated to begin until April 2019. Then there’s the NCAA piece of this, some of which may not be able to begin until after the trials. Full clarity on what Miller and Arizona may or may not have done might not come until the onset of the next decade. There are so many foggy variables tied to the case that it’s hard to conceive all the billable hours pondering them: What if (ex-assistant Book) Richardson turns over information on Miller to the feds? What if the FBI wiretaps are played during trial? What if they’re not? There are no easy answers here.”

Thamel then answers the question of whether Miller could simply walk away from Arizona: “It’s hard to imagine any college president hiring him with all this uncertainty looming. This includes his beloved alma mater Pittsburgh, which is coming off an 0-18 ACC season. (There’s an argument for familiarity and mutual desperation there, but no administrators would be likely to risk it considering the severity of the unknown elements in this situation.)”

This doesn’t sound like a workable solution for Pitt, though I’m sure plenty of donors would love to have a “Pitt guy” in place. Never mind that it would be a Pitt guy who might consider Pitt only if he has no other choice.

Another name that has emerged is Kevin Willard, son of ex-Pitt coach Ralph Willard, whose tenure here did not go especially well. Not that anyone should hold that against Kevin, who turned around a Pitt-like disaster at Iona and has taken Seton Hall to three straight NCAA tournaments.

But then there is this:

Advertise with us

“The USA TODAY NETWORK spoke with three people who have experience in Division I basketball compliance matters, and they hammered home the same point: (former Seton Hall assistant Dwayne “Tiny”) Morton’s involvement is the most pressing issue as Seton Hall enlists New York City law firm Jackson Lewis to conduct an internal probe.

“Morton, who came aboard Kevin Willard’s coaching staff as part of a ‘package deal’ with (star player Isaiah) Whitehead, spent the 2014-15 season in South Orange before returning to his roots as the coach at talent-rich Lincoln High School in Brooklyn (Whitehead’s alma mater).

During his time on campus, Morton was a divisive figure who contributed to the locker-room tension that imploded the team. The question now, though, is why Morton is listed as receiving $9,500 from the agency at the center of the FBI’s investigation — Andy Miller’s ASM Sports — and more importantly when he may have received such a payment.

“As reported by the New York Post, Morton’s relationship with Miller dated back years before his time at Seton Hall. But if he accepted such payment while on the university’s payroll it would be an infraction of NCAA rules — unless Morton could prove it was for prior services rendered. Moreover, if there is evidence that Morton connected Whitehead with ASM while the two were at Seton Hall together, that’s a major infraction of NCAA rules.”

Wonderful. That doesn’t necessarily implicate Willard, just as the Arizona situation might not implicate Miller. But at this rate, why not consider Rick Pitino?

Advertise with us

He is, without question, the best available coach. Disgraced, yes, and if he were to lead Pitt to a Final Four, all the wins might be vacated. But the winning would be fun.

Anyway, your question …

Who should they hire? Buffalo’s Nate Oats.

Who will they hire? I’d be lying if I said I had a clue.

A quick detour to our ever-popular Twitter Polls segment …

Advertise with us

Question courtesy of former Pitt football star and 93.7 The Fan radio host Dorin Dickerson: Which time of the year do you enjoy more, CFB Bowl Season/Playoffs or March Madness (564 votes)?

• CFB Bowl Season/Playoffs: 28%

• March Madness: 72%

What we learned: Some people have working brains. OF COURSE March Madness is better, particularly this year. We’ve seen everything in the first two rounds — buzzer beaters, historic upset, Buffalo emptying its bench against Sean Miller, brilliance from Duke, Villanova and Texas A&M. You name it. What we have here is basketball bliss.

Now some rapid-fire …

Advertise with us

Brian Fennell, @BFGolferguy122: What was your most painful sports injury?

Starkey: I’ve told this story many times: Torn Achilles playing Andrew Fillipponi (@ThePoniExpress) in a one-on-one about seven years ago. Three-game series. I won Game 1 and was leading late in Game 2 when I landed on a simple jump shot and heard it snap. Taken out on gurney at LA Fitness. Nobody paid attention. Poni did not accompany me on ambulance ride. Should he have? That could be a poll question.

jon montag, @JonMontag: Team Home Run total. Over or under 151? Which is last years total.

Starkey: Over. Pirates will get more home runs from RF, LF, 1B, 3B than they did last year. It will help if baseballs still juiced.

Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.

Advertise with us

Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.

Mike, @PITT1pap: With the banter between you guys and the morning show, could Mullesy take either Josh Miller or Colin Dunlap 1:1 in hoops?

Starkey: Josh would crush him (6-foot-4 athlete, played lots of hoops, I trained with Josh for my series v Poni so I know he’s very good). Dunlap? Could go a full seven games.

JohnHussar, @JohnHussarFTW: Highest seed to make final four?

Starkey: Kansas. Lowest seed: WVU.

Advertise with us

J to the izz-O B to the izz-A, @joeybagovdonuts: Why does 40 degrees seem warm in winter but really cold in fall?

Steven, @Heysteve011: Yes, I would like to know this as well.

Starkey: I refuse to answer the question, but I loved the follow-up from Mr. Heysteve.

Russell Miller, @BigHate1981: Who is Karl Malden?!??!

Starkey: Type “Malden” into “Google.” Or watch “On the Waterfront.”

Advertise with us

Tony, @bigteecee: If you had to give Heather Lyke a letter grade for the way she handled the Stallings situation, what would it be and why?

Starkey: Incomplete, because she hasn’t hired a coach yet. As for the Stallings “for cause” debacle, that is a university action, not a Heather Lyke action. And unless more comes out regarding Stallings, the university is embarrassing itself by reportedly using the Louisville fan “incident.”

Chris Mueller, @ChrisMuellerPGH: rank your most favorite bars from "Joe Starkey: The College Years”

Starkey: Awkwardly worded question, Mullsy. “Most” was not necessary. But here we go:

5. Third Base ($1.50 pitchers Thursday nights)

Advertise with us

4. Mr. Goodbar (25-cent drafts Tuesdays)

3. Gabels (incredible wings)

2. The Steer (don’t ask)

1. The Peppermill (a green bus would pick us up at Cortland State dorm — Cheney Hall — and take us to the “Peppermill,” whereupon one could hear way too much Madonna and Cyndi Lauper and drink way too much horrible beer. Then the bus would take us home).

JosABank, @JosABank: Rank your favorite college from “Joe Starkey: The College years”

Advertise with us

5. Daemen College: My dad taught there. Great school. Where I got my teaching certificate (secondary English). You’ll notice that was not a complete sentence.

4. CCAC: Awesome place, took credits to make teaching certificate permanent.

3. Cortland State: No recollection.

2. Duquesne: Loved my teachers (including Beverly Carroll, wife of basketball coach John; she taught fabulous freelance writing course).

1. University at Buffalo. No explanation needed. Did I mention UB emptied the bench against Sean Miller and that UB women are in Sweet 16?

Advertise with us

No?

Well, in that case: UB emptied the bench against Sean Miller, and UB women are in Sweet 16

Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille (no relation to Sean Miller) this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).