Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Pink, Buffalo and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Chris Boehme, @Cboehme2: After hearing your colleague say Sidney Crosby’s 400th goal would be like LeBron James banking in his 25,000th point on a foul shot, I would like to know. What individual achievement or milestone moment do you think is most memorable?

Starkey: I don’t know what you mean here, Dr. Boehme. Which achievement in all of sports, which between Sid and LeBron, which from my personal memory bank?

Your question is very poorly worded, although I appreciate it more than you know, because it gives me a chance to rip my dear co-host Mullsy, who did indeed intimate that Crosby’s 400th goal was merely a random act of luck and not particularly memorable.

Advertise with us

I beg to differ.

In fact, while it would have been wonderful to see Sid go end to end a la Bobby Orr or Gilbert Perreault (YouTube it. He played for the Sabres back when end-to-end rushes existed) for goal No. 400, this was more befitting of the brainy brilliance he displays on a nightly basis. And quite memorable, especially in the immediate aftermath, as Sid peered down into the net from above the crossbar like a man looking for his keys in a fish tank. The delayed reaction from everyone, including Doc Emrick, was fabulous. As if we were all saying, “No, wait … No, he didn’t just score from there, did he?”

How many times have we said that in Sid’s career?

How many times have we seen him score where we wonder if anyone else would have even tried the shot?

He’s like a pool-shark trickster, and on this one he found the only pocket that existed. I’m guessing 999 out of a thousand players fail to find that opening. This was no random act of luck, Mullsy. This was a cold and calculated act of pure brilliance.

Advertise with us

If you don’t believe me, listen to Blues goalie Jake Allen’s take on Crosby’s shot: “That’s why he's the best player in the world. I would never play that any differently. He's one hell of a smart player. It was a pretty good shot.”

No, it was a great shot. A classic shot. A Mario Lemieux-like shot. A one-in-a-million shot by a two-in-a-million player. And the perfect 400th goal.

So let us review …

— I am right.

— Mullsy is wrong.

Advertise with us

OK, onto our rapid fire segment …

TacoTom483, @TomHilliard483: What is your prediction for the outcome of the 2018 Pirates season as far as fan turnout?

Starkey: Low.

Steven, @Heysteve011: If you were an Olympian, what would your specialty be?

Starkey: Cornhole (it’s no more ridiculous than curling).

Advertise with us

Deb Utterback, @debsu14: Wondering when you and Mullsy plan to re-create the Eli-Odell advertisement for your show…

Joe Starkey: Actually, Deb, I’m planning to re-create the George Foreman-Michael Moorer fight later today. I’ll be Foreman. See here:

Cary Sutinis, @Carysutinis: Hey Joe. Are u a Pittsburgh fan? Bills fan?

Starkey: I’m really not a fan of any team, Cary. I grew up a Bills fan and a Pirates fan and certainly a Buffalo Braves and Sabres fan — I was once a Bills season-ticket holder — but this business, for better or worse, sort of grew me out of fandom. I see others who never grow out of it, and let’s just say I don’t want to be them. I tend to become a fan when I’m watching a particular game. Like the Super Bowl. I became an Eagles fan real fast.

Matt dicicco, @DiciccoMatt: Did you get your tickets for Pink yet?

Advertise with us

Starkey: No, but I plan to. She's a miracle worker. I wish she would sing all acoustic numbers, but then, I wish every artist would. Check this out and tell me she isn’t an all-time talent:

Although I must admit, Mr. Matt, I’m somewhat troubled as to whether rhyming “compass” and “accomplice” is a stroke of genius or reason enough to never listen again. I’m leaning toward the former.

Laces out, Dan!, @dkviper: Heinz Field and Beaver Stadium catch the same strand of Stadium-Super-Flu and are temporarily closed. The savvy old news hound is charged with picking the most interesting neutral site for the game. He chooses ___

Starkey: PNC Park. It could use a big game.

Which leads us into a new feature: Twitter Polls. Each week I will post a few and then share the results with my loyal readers ….

Advertise with us

POLL QUESTION (1,298 votes): If you owned an NFL team and could have any coach for next season (talent being equal on field), you’d have Tomlin ….

A. 3rd behind Bill B and Doug P (10%)

B. In Top 5 (53%)

C. Not in Top 5 (31%)

D. Other (6%)

Advertise with us

What did we learn? That people are still relatively sane. Mike Tomlin remains a top-5 coach, although he receded this season and Pederson certainly entered the conversation as “Best Behind Belichick.”

POLL QUESTION (697 votes): Who do you think has the better chance of winning the NHL scoring title this season? Phil Kessel, Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin or Nikita Kucherov (697 votes) …

A. Sidney Crosby (27%)

B. Phil Kessel (28%)

C. Evgeni Malkin (35%)

Advertise with us

D. Kucherov (10%)

What did we learn? Well, this was a week ago, when the Penguins’ trio was closer to Kucherov. What we’ve learned since then is that he’s going to be tough to catch. But if I’m picking among the Penguins Three, I’m still going Sid (who is nine points back as of this writing). I think getting that 400th goal will precipitate a scoring binge.

Man, that was a pretty goal.

Wasn’t it, Mullsy?

Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).