Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Chardee MacDennis, @StanKachowski: Was it worth it for Harrison?

Starkey: Was what worth what, Mr. MacDennis (and how did we get from Chardee MacDennis to @StanKachowksi?)? Was it worth it for Harrison to whine his way out of town in order to play in the Super Bowl?

Probably, yeah.

Advertise with us

Wouldn’t you want to play in the Super Bowl?

Or maybe you mean was it worth it to “tarnish his legacy” here in order to spend a month with the Evil Empire and then go home without a ring?

Let me answer that this way, Stan (or should I say Chardee): Harrison did not tarnish his legacy by going to New England; he tarnished it by quitting on the Steelers, by not staying engaged with his teammates in what was shaping up to be a memorable season. He didn’t even bother to stick around for some of their games once he learned he was a healthy scratch.

Who’s to say he wouldn’t have played meaningful snaps in the playoffs? One never knows. He was on the field for the final play against Baltimore. He played the final critical series against Kansas City. The way the Jacksonville game was going — reaching the point where the head coach opted for an onside kick in hopes of never having to look at his defense again — the Steelers might have called his name at just the right time.

I still can’t figure out what happened to make them release Harrison and keep Daniel McCullers when they did. They put up with Harrison all season. Besides, Harrison told the Post-Gazette’s Gerry Dulac that Tomlin, late in the season, called the idea of letting Harrison go “crazy” because it would squander the team’s insurance at outside linebacker.

Advertise with us

What happened to so radically change Tomlin’s mind? Or didn’t Tomlin make the ultimate decision?

It was crazy, by the way. The Steelers allowed a player to complain his way off the roster — something they did not do in Martavis Bryant’s case — and allow for the possibility he would wind up with a team that stood in the Steelers’ way.

Which, of course, he did. And even if he didn’t have a good Super Bowl (although his two quarterback hits would have made him Lawrence Taylor in these parts), and even though Steelers fans took much glee in seeing Harrison pull confetti off his shoulder pads after losing to the Eagles, he absolutely got the last laugh.

He made a big play in the playoffs, which is one more than the entire Steelers defense made.

He got his way and made them look bad in the process.

Advertise with us

He went to the Super Bowl.

Best of all: He didn’t have to watch the Jacksonville Jaguars walk into Heinz Field and put 45 points (38, really) on a once-proud defense. That was one game he would have been justified to walk out on.

OK, rapid-fire …

Brett Gray, @Cutch_22: Who wins the 2018 Daytona 500?

Starkey: Tiger Woods.

Advertise with us

Matthew Wilson, @MattWilsonMNC: What do you think the feeling will be around Ppg paints arena with the return of Fleury?

Starkey: Oh man, it should be one of the memorable nights in the building’s history, Mr. Wilson. No ex-Penguin who has come into that building with his new team is as beloved as Fleury. Bring your tissues. And don’t forget, he basically won the Penguins a Cup last season — or least prevented them from elimination — by stealing the series against the Capitals.

And while we’re on the subject, a shameless plug: You can read about some of Fleury’s other memorable nights in my book, “Tales From the Pittsburgh Penguins Locker Room,” available on Amazon.

Man Davison, @PlatinumBulge: Should the Steelers try and sign Malcolm Butler?

Starkey: Last year, I urged them to throw an offer sheet at Butler, Mr. PlatinumBulge (PlatinumBulge?). It seemed obvious how desperate they were at cornerback, a notion confirmed when they stepped way out of character to reel in Joe Haden.

Advertise with us

This offseason, chasing Butler would be too expensive, especially if the Steelers sign Le’Veon Bell. They better hope Haden stays healthy and Artie Burns fulfills his potential. Cam Sutton is a key player, too, whether at corner or safety.

Although, come to think of it, Butler might fit right in if he likes to break team rules.

Mr. Crawford, @jeffcraw22: If the Steelers went to RB by committee assuming Le’Veon is gone and James Conner is one of the 2/3, who would you think could be the others?

Starkey: I’m all for signing Bell, even at more than $15 million per year, Mr. jeffcraw22, but if that doesn’t happen, I would think the Steelers would take a running back in the draft (maybe the lower half) and sign somebody to join Conner. Dion Lewis and Carlos Hyde are among the available free agents who would intrigue me.

LeGarrette Blount is available, too, and what’s a Steelers season without a malcontent quitting in the middle of the year and helping the Patriots to the Super Bowl?

Advertise with us

Chris Hawthorne, @Hawthornee: If you could choose any star, living or dead, to perform during halftime, who would it be?

Starkey: I’d probably go with a Jimi Hendrix acoustic set, Chris, or maybe Mozart and Beethoven on dueling pianos.

If I could choose someone who is currently alive and dead, it would have to be Keith Richards.

Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).