Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Matthew Testa, @mtesta36: Where’s Rico Fata on the worst Pens list?

Starkey: If you’re talking “Worst Penguins of the 21st Century,” Mr. Testa, he belongs in the discussion, if only because he’s Rico Fata. But he did score 21 goals in his Penguins career, which looks pretty impressive compared to, say, Zach Sill, who very nearly left Pittsburgh as Zach “Nill” in the goal-scoring department but did manage one goal (assist: Andrew Ebbett) in his 61 games here.

This topic arose the other day, in the wake of Jaromir Jagr clearing waivers, as a counter-balance to the obvious topic: “Best Penguins of All-Time.”

Advertise with us

So let’s get that out of the way first …

1. Mario Lemieux. Obviously.

2. Sidney Crosby. Obviously.

3. Evgeni Malkin. By a very slim margin over Jagr.

Here’s why: Malkin plays center and thus can have a more dramatic overall impact on the game, particularly in the defensive zone. Like Mario, when Geno is of a mind to play all 200 feet (see: playoff time), he is a dominant overall force. Also, he did not have the benefit of playing in a high-scoring league. Jagr did, for about four years.

Advertise with us

When Jagr broke into the league, teams averaged 3.46 goals per game. When Malkin broke in, it was below 3.0. Jagr broke in at a time the average save percentage was .886. It was .905 and has mostly gone up (to .913) since Geno came in.

Also, Malkin’s playoff numbers (157 points in 149 games) are equal to that of Jagr in a Penguins jersey (149 in 140 games), though Jagr’s regular-season numbers — (0.54 goals per game, 1.34 points) are superior to Malkin’s (0.47 goals, 1.17 points). Malkin has three Cups, too, and wasn’t exactly a bystander.

4. Jagr. A phenomenal offensive force, so much so that even when league-wide offense died, he kept winning scoring titles with monster numbers.

Now for the main course: The Worst Penguins of the 21st Century. We’ll go in descending order. There is no minimum game limit.

With apologies to Adam Payerl, Eric Tangradi, Kelly Buchberger, Rob Klinkhammer, Zach Boychuk, the triumvirate of Kris Beech, Ross Lupaschuk and Michal Sivek (it’s too hard to separate them) and good ol’ Crankshaft, the envelopes please …

Advertise with us

4. Konstantin Koltsov: He earned his nickname — “The Headless Horseman” — by basically skating wind sprints up and down the wing for parts of three years while seemingly unaware that he was engaged in a game of ice hockey.

3. Krzysztof Oliwa: My lasting memory is of Oliwa becoming enraged with a teammate (I don’t remember who) and slashing the guy’s skate blades together in the Southpointe locker room. That made Kevin Stevens angry. Oliwa did not do it again. He had one goal (assists: Lemieux, Jagr) and 283 penalty minutes in 83 games here.

2. Antti Niemi: He only played three games, but, man, they were something, weren’t they? The man somehow allowed 16 goals in 128 minutes. He made Martin Brochu look like Martin Brodeur.

1. Sergei Plotnikov: It wasn’t bad enough that Plotsy did not score a goal in 32 games in a Penguins sweater. He had the nerve to ask for a trade! The Penguins happily complied, sending him to Arizona the day the Coyotes visited PPG Paints Arena. What an epic disaster.

OK, to the lightning round:

Advertise with us

Joey Wagner, @TheTruthSwagner: Todd Haley is with the Browns now...Can Coach Cowboy cure Cleveland?

Starkey: Not unless he gets a quarterback.

Peter Thompson, @TherealPeteyT: What is the Steelers’ most pressing need in the draft & can Mike Tomlin ever improve at clock mgt?

Starkey: Inside linebacker, free safety, and of course Tomlin can improve. He did improve, I thought, until the final few disastrous minutes against Jacksonville. Why not, like Philly’s Doug Pederson, utilize analytics experts when it comes to clock management and other specialized situations? Pederson would have had analytics people in his ear telling him to, you know, CALL YOUR TIMEOUTS BEFORE THE TWO-MINUTE WARNING and DON’T TRY AN ONSIDE KICK HERE!” and “KICK THE FIELD GOAL NOW BECAUSE YOU’RE DOWN 10 AND THE CLOCK IS NEARLY AT 0:00!!!!”

Jeff Meyer, @jeff_1813: Jagr goes to the rafter and so do Sid and Geno. Does Fleury and or anyone else?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Absolutely Fleury. Without question. Nobody else yet, unless you want Plotnikov.

Matt dicicco, @DiciccoMatt: Is there a bald bias against Stallings? Dude needs to go full Bruce Willis if he is going to get respect

Starkey: The half-bald look isn’t helping. I’ll agree there.

Colin Dunlap, @colin_dunlap: question(s): will the Pirates sell out Opening Day...also will attendance average 20k this season — over or under?

Starkey: Hi Colin! I’m going to say no to selling out Opening Day — OK, maybe it’ll be an announced sellout, but there will be many empty seats — and that attendance will crawl in just below 20,000 per game after plummeting to 23,697 last season.

Advertise with us

robbie sacunas, @Scoonz: how long would you last in the royal rumble if you drew a middle number?

Starkey: I literally have no idea what you’re talking about.

Dave Duke, @PTDukie33: If you could choose one person to do your radio show with (Mullsy excluded), who would it be, and why?

Starkey: Jerry DiPaola, because he’s nice.

Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).