Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Nathan, @nefergus: Early pick for what player goes to the Super Bowl next year as a Patriot after getting cut by Steelers. Martavis? Chickillo? Sensabaugh?

Starkey: Wonderful question, Mr. @nefergus. And it does depend on the criterion. If we’re talking another malcontent who gets cut during the season, goes to the Patriots and helps them to the Super Bowl — a la LeGarrette Blount and James Harrison — then the heavy favorite has to be Martavis Bryant, right?

I mean, Bryant is the Golden State Warriors in that scenario. He’s Steph Curry swishing rainbows from 35 feet. A couple more “I want mines, period” incidents, and the Steelers might as well make his flight arrangements to Foxborough. He might even get there in time for a cameo in “Tom vs. Time, Part II,” in which Tom throws Martavis a bomb only to have Martavis not look up.

Advertise with us

But if we could include players who might go to the Patriots during the offseason or under any other scenario, others should be included.

Let’s take a lot at the early odds:

• Bryant: 5-8. Still the obvious choice.

• Chris Hubbard: 10-1. Made himself some money this season, for sure, and would look great protecting “Tom.”

• Daniel McCullers: 15-1. Maybe Belichick could get him interested in football.

Advertise with us

• Stevan Ridley: 20-1. Just because.

• Anthony Chickillo: 50-1. Belichick had pretty good luck with another No. 56 during his days at Giants defensive coordinator, if I recall correctly.

• Le’Veon Bell: 100-1. If the Steelers cut ties with Bell — and they would be absolutely insane to do so — Belichick would persuade him to take less money, promise him the soundtrack for “Tom vs. Time, Part III” and bring him to New England.

Shawn Narry, @lawnman9: Have you seen the petition to have MLB force Nutting to sell Pirates? Do you think that will ever happen? Over 50,000 signatures so far.

Starkey: To paraphrase my friend Stephen J. Nesbitt (and only a confident writer includes his middle initial in his byline), this will be the only time all season where that many fans gather in the Pirates’ name, Mr. @lawnman9. But no, MLB will not force Nutting to sell the Pirates. That is a pipe dream.

Advertise with us

Still, fans have a right to express themselves, and that is an impressive number. I have never seen the fan base this livid — not after the Aramis Ramirez trade, the Matt Morris acquisition or the Neil Walker trade.

This is a new level of irate.

Stanley P Kachowski, @StanPKachowski: Pirates have me appreciating the downs and ups of being a Pens fan. Part 1: Lowest single moment of Pens franchise in last 15 years? Part 2: Single peak moment of Pens franchise since then (or has it not occurred yet)?

Starkey: First of all, Mr. @StanPKachowski, 15 years is a long time. Let’s agree on that. It goes fast, I know, but it’s a loooooonnnnnng time.

Do you know who played for the Penguins 15 years ago? Ramzi Abid did. Joel Bouchard and Dan Focht did, too. Marc Bergevin was on that team. Alexandre Daigle was on that team. Mario Lemieux captained it (and had 91 points in 67 games). Rick Kehoe coached it. Ian Moran was still around!

Advertise with us

Suffice to say, a few things have changed. You’re asking me for the single high point and low point since then? All right …

• Low point (at least on the ice): Getting humiliated by the hated Flyers — featuring Jaromir Jagr and superstar Max Talbot — in the playoffs. The Penguins never came close to figuring out the Flyers’ power play. They were an out-of-control mess.

• High point: Winning the Sidney Crosby lottery. And in a related note, winning Game 7 in Detroit against a great Red Wings team. And pretty much everything that has transpired over the past two years.

Jeff Lippert, @WILDTANKYMAN75: Are you watching Raw 25th anniversary?

Starkey: No. But I’m sensing by your Twitter handle that you probably are.

Advertise with us

Matt dicicco, @DiciccoMatt: With no changes on the (Steelers) defensive staff do you see any improvement next season?

Starkey: I do not see the defense improving next season. Their regular-season numbers were deceivingly impressive this season — fifth overall, seventh in scoring, first in sacks. They played a cake schedule featuring plenty of sorry offenses and bad quarterbacks. That isn’t likely to happen again. They must replace a great player in Ryan Shazier. They might need to draft yet another outside linebacker (please don’t blame Joey Porter for anything, though). They need to draft or sign a free safety, too.

JTGBG, @JTGBG: Jaime Dixon and TCU currently lead at the half against WVU (and won the game). With Pitt's falloff since he left and TCU’s growing relevance, how good of a coach did we lose?

Starkey: Only an idiot would tell you that Dixon is not a very good coach. But his time had come here. His program had plateaued. He wanted to leave.

This is what had become of Dixon’s program over his last five years, during which time attendance dipped and he missed the NCAA tournament twice:

Advertise with us

• Conference record: 45-45.

• Conference tournament record: 4-5.

• NCAA tournament record: 1-3.

Granted, those numbers look downright Duke-like compared to what is happening now. But just because Dixon’s replacement has been terrible doesn’t mean Dixon would have thrived.

It’s quite likely that worse was ahead for him, too. He went 7-23 in his final 30 games against ranked opponents. I was all for a change. I’m still willing to give Kevin Stallings some time, but I don’t remember the part of his introductory news conference where anyone talked about a total rebuild. I remember Scott “West Coast Basketball Guy” Barnes talking about “moving the needle.” I remember the words “Final” and “Four” were mentioned.

Advertise with us

“Worst team in ACC.”

“Start from scratch.”

“Lose by a thousand to Louisville.”

I don’t remember any of that.

Jake Leger, @JakeLeger: When will the Steelers finally replace Heath Miller?? (irreplaceable but you know what I mean.) & What are the stats on “Renegade” in big games / big drives? Should the team look to the future with a new song? (sacrilegious I know).

Advertise with us

Starkey: There’s a lot to unpack there, Mr. Leger. They will never replace Heath Miller, who surely would have survived the ground against New England. I don’t have stats on “Renegade,” other than the Twitter poll I ran in the wake of your question.

I asked people if they want to replace it, giving them three choices as answers:

Dear God, please

Don’t you dare

I don’t care.

Advertise with us

I received 2,054 responses: 49 percent said “Don’t you dare;” 34 percent said, “I don’t care;” and only 17 percent said “Dear God, please.”

So it seems the will of the people is to keep “Renegade.” I would prefer some Gordon Lightfoot, or, if you want to reflect the defense’s disorganized performance against Jacksonville, maybe the Beatles’ “Helter Skelter” or The Who’s “Won’t Get Fooled Again (although we’re getting fooled by Blake Bortles on nearly every play).”

Anyway, some of your responses:

• “If by Renegade, you mean (get rid of) Joey Porter then yes!” — Don Seroka, @dseroka

• “Have always thought the lyrics in Metallica's Search and Destroy were perfect for uplifting the crowd prior to defensive series.” — realdealneil, @njd9294

Advertise with us

• “Before we replace “Renegade,” let’s replace the defense with one that deserves it!” — Patrick Weyers, @pjweyers

• “Styx were always irredeemable platform shoe nonsense.” — WV Witness, @WVWitness.

• “for those of us who travel to one game a year it's part of the vacation package...would be disappointed if it wasn't played.” — costanza2k1, @costanza2k1

• “Evidently Joe, the Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald would have been apropos this year.” — Owtahear, @owtahear

Give that man his money.

Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).