Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:
Austin Meadows Season, @bensaveus: Mike Tomlin has wasted this talent on this team for far too long; how much longer will he be head coach?
Starkey: I believe he will be the coach for many years to come, Mr. @bensaveus, but I also believe he should be operating under increased scrutiny and forced to make changes on his staff.
This defense, in which Tomlin has a major hand, is embarrassing. As ex-Steelers safety Ryan Clark put it Tuesday morning on ESPN: “How many points, total, were scored in Jacksonville last week? Thirteen. And you give up 38 to this offense? Something has to be changed on that end, whether it’s the way you call plays or the people who are doing it.”
It’s commendable that Tomlin’s team has won consecutive AFC North titles and is 20-3 in its past 23 regular-season games. It truly is. You don’t fire a coach who’s winning at that kind of clip. Many franchises would kill for such success. But many franchises aren’t the Steelers. The standard is and should be different here.
It seems to me Tomlin’s teams are looking an awful lot like Dan Bylsma’s later Penguins teams: fancy individual numbers and big regular seasons followed by massive and disturbing playoff failures.
Read More
Bylsma won the Stanley Cup in 2009 and followed it with five disastrous postseasons. It took a different coach to lead the Penguins back to the promised land.
Tomlin won it all in 2008 and got back to the Super Bowl in 2010. He hasn’t really come close in the seven years since, once getting to the AFC title game only to see his team slaughtered on live TV.
This just isn’t good enough. Doesn’t mean the coach should be fired. Does mean he has to be held accountable in some way for these failures, for a team (a defense, in particular) that looks totally disorganized at the biggest moments of the season.
Let’s give Snoop Dogg the final say, shall we? He put it this way, in a cloud of smoke, as he was watching the game: “It sucks being a fan of a team that lets you [expletive] down year after year after year. And they’re fully loaded, talented.”
Snoop was particularly incensed with the late onside kick, and that leads to a question …
Joe Starkey, JoeStarkey1: Did Tomlin go temporarily insane in the final 2:18?
Starkey: He must have, because nothing he did made sense.
First, the onside kick. What in the world was he thinking? The Steelers have gone something like 14 onside attempts in a row without a recovery. That’s one issue. The larger one is the fact that you give away the game if you don’t recover. The percentages scream to kick it deep there and hope for a stop against a team that is likely to keep it very conservative.
That doesn’t guarantee a stop. Goodness knows, the Steelers easily could have given up a 75-yard touchdown run on the first play. But Tomlin’s explanation — basically that he didn’t trust his defense to make a stop and thus had no choice but to go onside — was nonsensical. His defense, bad as it was, made two stops when the score was 28-21. The odds were far, far, far greater in forcing a punt than in recovering an onside kick.
Then, the clock. There was 2:18 left when Jacksonville got the ball. Tomlin elected to let the clock run to the two-minute warning, then use his timeouts. He probably cost himself 10 seconds there. The time of a single play, for sure, and you can ask the Minnesota Vikings about the value of a single play.
Finally, at the end, the Steelers needed to kick a field goal, and fast, when a penalty pushed them back to the Jags’ 15 with 23 seconds left. You kick the field goal, hope for your first onside recovery in about a decade, and take a last shot. It was their only chance. Instead, they kept trying to score a touchdown and finally did with one second left, which turned a minuscule chance into none.
Absolutely mind-boggling.
Thomas Glovier, @pittsburghkeys: Do you think the Steelers have a good chance of winning in Foxborough on Sunday? What’s the current line on the game?
Starkey: It’s Patriots minus-70. Mike Mitchell and Anthony Smith starting at safety for the Steelers.
John Knight, @jknight841: Would you rather have Bortles or Tebow if you’re playing the Steelers in the playoffs?
Starkey: Man, that’s a toughie. The Steelers made Tebow look like Steve Young and Bortles like Roger Staubach. It does raise an interesting question, though, Mr. @jknight841: Who is the worst quarterback the Steelers have lost to in the playoffs?
Here is one man’s list, not including Tommy Thompson of the 1947 Eagles, Earl Morrall or Stan Humphries:
5. Peyton Manning, 2015. This version of Manning might be worthy of No. 1 on this list. He was a decrepit shell of himself in his final year. He had the worst TD/Int ratio of any QB who has ever beaten the Steelers in a playoff game (9 to 17 that year). He could barely propel the ball downfield (although that didn’t stop him from converting on 3rd-and-12 against Keith Butler’s defense when it mattered most). It truly is a miracle — and a testament to Denver’s great defense — that the Broncos won it all that season with this guy behind center.
4. Craig Morton. Broncos quarterbacks, everywhere on this list. Morton did receive MVP consideration in 1977, the year he beat the Steelers. But he wasn’t very good.
3. Tim Tebow: Horrifying. Absolutely horrifying.
2. Blake Bortles: Horrifying. Absolutely horrifying.
1. Frank Reich. I love this man. The week before, he executed the greatest comeback in NFL playoff history. But really now, Bill Cowher, losing to Frank Reich at home with a 12-4 team?
aka chadd, AlbinoBoogeyman: What position need do u see the steelers drafting in the first round this year?
Starkey: Not quarterback, now that Ben Roethlisberger apparently will play several more years — which comes as no surprise to yours truly. I would go nearly all defense in this draft, starting with an inside linebacker and a free safety.
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: What are the Pirates going to do with all of the “Years of Control” they acquired over the weekend?
Starkey: With apologies to the great Norman Chad: Pay the man, Shirley.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.