I have no idea, after half a century roaming planet Earth, if tough talk matters in sports. If bold words can actually influence an outcome.

Did it in any way affect the game when Joe Namath guaranteed victory in Super Bowl III? Did it somehow galvanize his team when Kevin Stevens told the world the Penguins would sweep the Boston Bruins after losing the first two games of the 1991 conference finals?

Did it galvanize the other guys when Anthony Smith guaranteed a win over the Patriots in 2007 or when the Steelers got cocky — or were perceived to — before the 1994 and 2001 AFC title games?

The other guys sure thought so, even if some of their claims were dubious.

Advertise with us

Review the Patriots’ quotes from the ’01 title game. They thought the Steelers were out of line for talking about Super Bowl travel plans to New Orleans when, in fact, every team has to make such plans ahead of time.

Bill Belichick even used a T-shirt (“Big Nasty D in the Big Easy”) and the point spread (10) as fodder to motivate his team.

"You never disrespect anybody when you're at this point in the season," said Patriots safety Lawyer Milloy. "All you do is make it harder on yourself.”

"I think it definitely rubbed us the wrong way a little,” Belichick said of the travel talk. “Maybe printing some of these T-shirts (which the Steelers did not do) was a little premature."

Of the point spread, he said, “It’s the same as when Pittsburgh played 1-12 Detroit a few weeks ago."

Advertise with us

So yes, coaches and players use anything and everything to try to gain an advantage.

Does it ever work? Who knows? I just know this much: Big talk creates heroes (Namath, Stevens, Mark Messier, etc.) and goats (Smith, Hollywood Henderson, etc.) who are remembered forever.

Which brings us to Steelers-Jaguars. And of course to Steelers-Patriots, which at the moment remains an imaginary matchup. The Steelers keep talking about it, though.

Mike Tomlin is on the record saying his team “should” win the Super Bowl and that he expects a Patriots rematch.

Now along comes safety Mike Mitchell, who tells Sports Illustrated — as his team is preparing for Jacksonville — “We’re going to play (the Patriots) again. We can play them in hell, we can play them in Haiti, we can play them in New England. … We’re gonna win.”

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, Ben Roethlisberger broke with a billion years of sports tradition when he admitted that he did, in fact, have a preference on his playoff opponent. He wanted Jacksonville, clearly aiming to atone for the 17 interceptions he threw in the first matchup.

The Jaguars haven’t been shy, either.

First, A.J. Bouye’s response to Ben: “Be careful what you wish for. This is what he wanted, so this is what he’s going to get.”

Now go back and revisit the Jaguars’ yappy locker room after that 30-9 win in Week 5. I was there, and it was beautiful. Linebacker Telvin Smith told anyone who would listen that he was the fastest linebacker in the league and maybe the defensive MVP. Safety Barry Church spoke of Roethlisberger being flustered.

I asked him to elaborate.

Advertise with us

“Oh yeah, we could definitely tell,” he said. “We were showing him multiple looks. He would go to first look, third look, man, and he would get flustered trying to make one of those miraculous Big Ben plays.”

A few lockers down, defensive lineman Malik Jackson said Ben looked OK to him but added, “You could definitely tell he’s a little older and he was getting a little tired.”

Late last week, I brought those quotes to Steelers center Maurkice Pouncey. Was he with Ben on wanting Jacksonville?

“Heck yeah,” Pouncey said. “Why not? That’s the matchup the football world wants to see.”

He backed off, saying, “I honestly don’t care who we play” but perked up when I mentioned the comments on Roethlisberger looking “flustered” and old.

Advertise with us

“That’s what they said? We shall see,” Pouncey said. “Sometimes when you talk too much, you end up lyin’ in it.”

Oh, we’re lyin’ in it, all right. And it’s glorious. I have no idea if any of this will matter, but in the spirit of the topic, I can guarantee this much: Somebody’s gonna look good here, and somebody’s gonna look bad.

Real bad.

CORRECTION: A previous version of this article misspelled Telvin Smith’s name.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.