Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan (who apparently now sings Frank Sinatra songs) and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:
Big Ry, @Ryan Schliniski: Do you think Shazier has a shot at winning defensive MVP?
Starkey: An outside one, Big Ry, but I feel compelled to start with this: He has competition for defensive MVP of his own team. Cam Heyward is having a spectacular season.
But you asked about Shazier. As electric as he’s been, he’ll need a big finish. One thing working against him is that voters tend to be impressed by high sack totals (Khalil Mack, J.J. Watt, etc., in recent years), and that isn’t Shazier’s game. He doesn’t have any sacks, though it’s worth noting that Luke Kuechly won this award (Associated Press Defensive Player of the Year) in 2013 despite having just two sacks. Kuechly had four interceptions and roughly 8 million tackles.
What Shazier does have is ridiculous range, violent finishing ability and extreme aptitude against the run and pass (his biggest challenge, at times, seems to be reining in his immense ability and not missing angles in the run game). His numbers aren’t bad, either.
Shazier is tied for fifth in the league in solo tackles (60). He is tied for seventh in interceptions (three), tied for 13th in passes defensed (10) — less than a handful behind the NFL’s elite cornerbacks — and tied for 13th in forced fumbles (two). If he’d held onto that Matthew Stafford pass and returned it for a TD late in the Detroit game, his resume would stand out a bit more.
Read More
Then there is this, from Pro Football Focus, which named Shazier as the Steelers’ best pass defender: “Following the theme of the year, Shazier is also having a career season overall but perhaps more importantly has improved his coverage ability as well. His coverage grade of 85.9 ranks sixth among linebackers while his passer rating against 75.7 is the seventh-lowest at the position.”
In the meantime, a popular pick for midseason Defensive Player of the Year was Jacksonville’s Calais Campbell, who has 11.5 sacks. Nobody has registered as many as 20 since 2014 (Justin Houston and J.J. Watt).
Aaron Donald is always a candidate, regardless of his numbers. Joey Bosa (10.5 sacks) is a force. Jalen Ramsey is an emerging superstar. Bill Barnwell of ESPN.com chose Dallas Cowboys star DeMarcus Lawrence as his midseason Defensive POY. He had 10.5 sacks and 17 knockdowns through eight games and added another sack Sunday night to tie Campbell for the league lead.
If Shazier finishes strong and wins the award, it would mark the eighth time a Steelers player has won it since they started giving the thing away in 1971 (Joe Greene twice, Mel Blount, Jack Lambert, Rod Woodson, James Harrison, Troy Polamalu). The Steelers are to this award what the Penguins are to scoring titles.
Scott Thomas, @RadicalWarlock: Who will win a title first, the Pirates or Pitt football?
Starkey: Radical Warlock? Really? All right, Mr. Radical, this is a great question. Both are literally unimaginable at the moment, but if I had to pick one, I’d pick the Pirates (in the year 3047).
I have a good question, too, after watching the Pitt debacle Monday night: Was that the worst Pitt basketball loss of the 21st Century?
I’m glad I asked.
And my answer is yes, because it was Penn State, because it struck me as so utterly sad and because it had the likes of Joe Giglio of the Raleigh News & Observer tweeting this: “Kevin Stallings might have the worst team in ACC history.”
The ACC has kind of a long history. This of course sparked an argument, and not the kind you'd want your basketball team to be involved in. A man named Brian Barbour (@briancbarbour) responded: “That 2016 BC team was 7-25, 0-19 vs ACC teams, 225th in KenPom and 320th in offensive efficiency. Not sure Pitt is that bad but we'll see.”
Unless we choose to cover our eyes, he might have added.
Other horrible 21st Century losses spring to mind, notably the 62-39 home loss to Rutgers in 2012 and three last season: the nine-point loss to Duquesne; the 72-46 home loss to Miami; and the 106-51 squeaker against Louisville.
But I’m not sure any elicited the feeling of watching last night’s game, even though Penn State is pretty good. Pitt was down by 40 points to Penn State. Wow! Talk about unimaginable.
jon montag, @JonMontag: Will the @pirates bobbleheads have different uniforms you can change them into? #SeanCaseyBobblehead
Starkey: To my knowledge, no, although that would be fascinating, Mr. Montag.
And it sparks a thought. My Top 5 off-the-radar (non-star) Pirates bobbleheads would be these (in case you’re new to this, I have a Rob Fleming-like obsession with list-making. Fleming was the main character in Nick Hornby’s novel “High Fidelity”) …
5. John Milner
4. Jim Bibby
3. Pokey Reese (there might have already been one of these)
2. John Holdzkom
1. Lee Lacy
Steven, @HeysteveO11: Other than the Pats, who do u see as a threat to the Steelers this year? Including themselves!?!?
Starkey: Hey Steve! Yes, I'd put the Steelers first on that list. Certainly Jacksonville, too.
But I will tell you this, and you might think I’ve lost my mind: Other than the Patriots, the last team I’d like to see if I'm the Steelers is Baltimore. They know the Steelers so well, usually play them well and often beat them.
I think John Harbaugh, despite his team’s recent issues, is a terrific coach. All you need to know is that he has gone into Foxborough outplayed the Patriots three times in the postseason. He won two of them and would have won a third if ex-Buffalo Bill (“Buffalo’s got a spirit, talkin’ proud, talkin proud!”) Lee Evans hadn’t dropped a touchdown pass right before Billy Cundiff missed a 3-foot field goal.
RAPID-FIRE SEGMENT
Mike, @PITT1pap: If you could take 1 player from another NFL team and put him on the Steelers, who would it be and why?
Starkey: Gronk. Can you imagine him roaming the middle of the field? Red-zone issues = gone. Jalen Ramsey a close second.
Ed Millie, @JohnEMillie2: Your pick on tonights Pitt vs PSU hoops game and who should Pitt start at Qb against Miami ?
Starkey: I’m confused. Is your name Ed or John? Anyway, I’m going to pick Penn State, since the game already happened and they won by 423 points. And I can’t imagine why Pat Narduzzi wouldn’t start Kenny Pickett against Miami. He’s the future, apparently, but he’s also the team’s best quarterback at this moment.
Incidentally, have you ever eaten at General Pickett’s Buffet in Gettysburg? Fabulous.
Jack, @Pitt_Is_Lit: Best and worst Thanksgiving dishes?
Starkey: First, I must tell you, Jack, Pitt is most definitely not lit at the moment. But I digress.
Best: Sweet potatoes with lots of butter, a touch of brown sugar and some sea salt (I’m one of the suckers easily swayed by terms like “sea salt.” It makes me think I’m getting very special salt, from the sea, as opposed to regular old granulated salt that is only for very unhealthy and extremely unenlightened people).
Worst: Cranberries in any form, except juice.
Max Switalski, @MXSwitz: On a scale of 1 to "you were born without a soul", how unacceptable is it to use water instead of milk to make hot chocolate?
Starkey: It depends on if you’re lactose intolerant, Max, but the following is true: The only thing worse than a fully lactose-tolerant person using water for hot chocolate might be a person who dislikes apple sauce with pork chops.
Robert Ewing, @SuprStud84: will the pirates ever make a big free agency signing?
Starkey: No.
PGH mom of 2 boys, @jeduffy: Would it be at all possible for Pitt football to play at PNC Park?
Starkey: Yes, and I would strongly suggest a Brandon Miree Bobblehead Night.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.