Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:

Shawn Narry, @lawnman: Will Big Ben ever do another QB sneak on short yardage?

Starkey: That is an open debate, Mr. lawnman, and one of the strangest Steelers-related topics I can fathom. It’s also a topic I wrote about after last year’s AFC title game, when the Steelers failed to score from what appeared to be the one-millimeter line.

If you’re not going to run a sneak there, in that game, then when?

Advertise with us

Here’s the crazy part: Ben claims he likes the play and practically campaigned for it a few weeks ago.

Which raises a pesky little question: WHY DOESN’T HE RUN IT, THEN?

It’s interesting, though not particularly relevant, that Todd Haley doesn’t seem enamored with the sneak. I’m aware of what he said, in the wake of learning that Ben apparently likes the play: "Those are kind of general staff decisions. Some staffs choose not to let people earhole their quarterback in the side of the head. Other staffs take that risk at times. There is risk-reward with everything you do.”

Here’s the bottom line: Ben can do whatever he wants. Period. Nobody’s campaigning for the QB sneak to become a regular part of the offense, but nobody’s going to scold him if he runs it on his own twice a year, either. He is 6-5, 240 or whatever, so I’m sure he could gain a foot if needed. In fact, it might be the best way to gain a foot.

It’s a play that could help the Steelers win. Look at what it’s done for New England. Here’s another look at a New York Times article from the Super Bowl two years ago headlined “A Tom Brady Sneak is the Patriots’ Unstoppable Play.”

Advertise with us

I’ll share the the first two paragraphs, just like I did a few months back:

“The most automatic play in the Patriots’ offensive playbook over the last 14 seasons involves Tom Brady, but it is not a pass. It is having Brady tuck the ball and lower his shoulder and shimmy into a narrow gap, gaining inch after bruising inch, the quarterback with a fullback’s mentality. Brady is as unstoppable as a crash of rhinos on third or fourth down and 2 yards or less to go, the rushing equivalent of a back-shoulder throw from Aaron Rodgers.

“Counting the postseason, Brady has run in those situations 115 times, according to play-by-play data from Pro Football Reference. He has gotten a first down or scored a touchdown on 105 of them, a success rate of 91.3 percent. Over one stretch, spanning more than seven years, he converted 60 of 61, including 37 straight.”

Patriots’ offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels said Brady runs the sneak when he wants, even if it’s not the call.

“He just says, ‘I’m going to get it myself,’ ” McDaniels said, adding: “To go in there and stick your face in there, where there’s a lot of big people ready to hit you quickly, that’s something I’m not sure that every quarterback wants to do. But he’s never been afraid to do it.”

Advertise with us

Ben Roethlisberger is as tough as any quarterback I’ve ever seen. I cannot begin to understand why he won’t run this play. He told “Cook & Poni” this after last year’s AFC title game: “I have no problem sneaking. My sneak percentage, whether it’s fourth-and-short or a goal-to-go situation, is pretty successful. In the high 90s. I’ve never expressed not wanting to do it. … The plays come in from coach Haley and I call ’em.”

And, from time to time, he changes ’em. So please, for the love of all that is sacred, fall forward once in a while.

Matt dicicco, @DiciccoMatt: Do Pitt fans care more about the team winning or Penn St losing games?

Starkey: I will say this, Mr. dicicco: I experienced one of the oddest Twitter nights of my career Saturday. The instant Penn State lost to Michigan State, my Twitter feed was flooded with gleeful Pitt fans insulting me — some with very, very harsh words — and their logic both baffled and fascinated me.

I had written a few days earlier that Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi should have better things to do than mock Penn State, considering his team is 4-5, lost to Penn State, 33-14, and was 10-10 since beating Penn State early last season, while Penn State was 17-3.

Advertise with us

I’m not sure how any of that changed Saturday, other than Penn State dropping to 17-4.

If I were a die-hard Pitt fan, I’d be happy about a Penn State loss, too. One can be pleased with a Pitt win and a Penn State loss. My statement was more about the coach.

Incidentally, I also wrote that things can change quickly in college football, that Pitt and Penn State’s fortunes could reverse, that Penn State “could lose to Michigan State this weekend” and that “I’m not sold on Franklin as a game-day coach just because the past year has gone well.”

Somehow, that never made into the incendiary email attacks.

The saddest part of it all, to me, is the small faction of ultra-defensive and seriously delusional Pitt fans who believe there is a media conspiracy to bury their team and glorify Penn State. I received a number of emails and tweets to that end — that the Post-Gazette favors Penn State. Those Pitt fans give the rest a bad name. They are the reason I once wrote that the practice facility on the South Side should be called “The Inferiority Complex.”

Advertise with us

A Penn State bias? OK, except that Gene Collier once called for Penn State to suspend its football program indefinitely. That’s a pretty strong opinion, no? Ron Cook ripped James Franklin twice in the same week — after Penn State beat Pitt this season (and I heartily agreed with both columns). I once wrote that Bill O’Brien should get rid of every assistant coach that was at Penn State under Joe Paterno, drawing the ire of that fan base.

You can’t win, I suppose — but if Pitt football found a way to do so more often, we wouldn’t be having these silly discussions.

Robert Ewing, @SuprStud84: best Pittsburgh pirate not in the baseball hall of fame

Starkey: Thank you, Mr. suprstud84, for sending me down a rabbit hole from which I might never return.

The first name that comes to mind is the great Dave Parker, one of my first favorite players, and, when right, one of the greatest all-around players I have ever seen. A true five-tool star — he could hit, hit for power, run, throw and field.

Advertise with us

Back in the late 1970s, Parker was winning a batting title and multiple gold gloves and throwing people out in All-Star Games and smashing line-drive home runs and wearing hockey masks on the base paths and generally scaring opposing players to death.

We could argue all day about whether his final numbers are HOF-worthy (maybe slightly below) and about how drug use cut into what should have been prime years (it did). I just know this: I will always remember Parker as an all-time great, even if it was for a Terrell Davis-like tiny window.

On the other hand, there was Parker, 19 years into his career, hitting 21 home runs and driving in 92 runs for the 1990 Milwaukee Brewers. He is probably the all-time argument for the merits of the designated hitter.

I mean, I’m sure it was fun watching Neal Heaton go 2-for-50 for the 1990 Pirates. I’m just glad the American League had a position where we could keep watching Dave Freakin’ Parker, who started 153 games as DH that year.

Anyway, Parker’s in my Hall of Fame, and my Hall of Fame doesn’t include Tony Perez, Luis Aparicio and his .311 career on-base percentage or sportswriters invoking morals clauses.

Advertise with us

Who else from Pirates history comes to mind? Maybe Wilbur Cooper, a left-handed pitcher from 1912-26. In fact, Bleacher Report made a case for him in a wonderful piece from 2009.

I can’t say I ever saw Cooper pitch, but one other name pops up in Pirates history when I look at all-time batting stats: Brian Giles.

It’s mind-blowing, actually. All the great sluggers in franchise history, and Brian Giles had the best career OPS in a Pirates uniform.

On-base percentage? Giles is second all-time to Jake Stenzel (no relation to Jake Guentzel). Slugging percentage? He’s first! Giles left here with a .591 slugging percentage, just ahead of some guys named Ralph Kiner and Willie Stargell. He also left with 165 home runs, seventh on the Pirates’ all-time list — and one fewer than Dave Parker.

RAPID-FIRE SEGMENT

Advertise with us

Timothy Scott Oneill, @TimothyScottOn1: Fingers are crossed Joe, what do you believe are the odds cutch will be a pirate next season?

Starkey: I have to believe, with attendance figures and local television ratings sinking faster than Antti Niemi’s career save percentage (three goals on 21 shots in his Panthers debut), that the Pirates will keep their best player. But I wouldn’t bet your 401(k) on it, Mr. Oneill.

Luke Phillips, @lukewphillips98: Is pitt hoops worth watching?

Starkey: I’m somewhat intrigued by the utter mystery surrounding this team, Mr. Luke. I cannot remember going into a season quite like this one.

Joey Wagner, @TheTruthSwagner: Has Mar-trade-vis Bryant finally learned from his mistakes or will he continue to whine about JuJu?

Advertise with us

Starkey: With all due respect, how should I know, Mr. TheTruthSwagner? My guess is that if he is still inclined to whine, he will do so privately. But you should probably check his Instagram page at around 4:30 p.m. Sunday.

MattyM325, @steelcity325: How do we (Steelers) overcome the stigma and culture of losing to bad teams?

Starkey: By beating them.

Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).