From the minute it formed, the National League Central Division has been unkind to the Pirates. And not just because they’ve never won it (and haven’t finished ahead of the St. Louis Cardinals once this century).

Back in 1994, the Pirates were moved from the NL East, along with the Cardinals and Chicago Cubs, and thus stripped of two rivals in the Philadelphia Phillies and the New York Mets. They suddenly found themselves stashed with a bunch of teams from a different time zone.

It has been a 24-year disaster, actually, one from which the Pirates have tried to extricate themselves. As recently as 2011, team president Frank Coonelly lobbied Major League Baseball for a jump back to the NL East. I suggested a move to the American League might be even better, but the Houston Astros were plucked, instead, and switched leagues in 2013.

The NL Central has just never made much sense. Not for the Pirates. It has never felt like home. Which might be why a story that appeared on the Post-Gazette earlier this week garnered so much attention.

Advertise with us

The piece was based on Tracy Ringolsby’s reporting in Baseball America. Ringolsby spoke of a New World Order emerging sooner rather than later. He described a “growing consensus” in baseball circles, one moving toward a world where the American and National leagues would no longer exist. Where there would be two more teams and six fewer games and four divisions (East, North, Midwest, West) comprised of eight teams apiece.

And where the Pirates would mercifully be freed to renew their rivalry with the Phillies, at the least.

This all remains highly speculative, of course, but you can bet there will be expansion, and with it, many changes. And given the Pirates’ current plight, any flight of imagination is welcome.

Ringolsby says one proposal would put the Pirates in the East Division with Atlanta, Baltimore, Cincinnati, Miami, Philadelphia, Tampa Bay and Washington.

Other than rejoining the Phillies, there isn’t much cause for excitement there. You definitely don’t want to be stuck with the two Florida teams.

Advertise with us

My dream division for the Pirates would start with Cleveland. Am I missing something here? The Indians play five minutes from here. You’d have an instant rivalry.

No alignment would be perfect, or please everyone, but I would think MLB owes the Pirates one for keeping them locked in the NL Central all these years. So if they’re talking eight-team divisions, how about these:

ROBERTO CLEMENTE DIVISION: 

Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Detroit, Milwaukee,

Cincinnati, Philadelphia, Washington, Baltimore

Advertise with us

— The Brewers fit here in a “Rust Belt” sense but probably belong with Chicago and St. Louis. Philly probably wants New York around, too. Oh well, somebody has to suffer.

BABE RUTH DIVISION: New York Yankees, Boston, New York Mets, Toronto, Montreal, Miami, Tampa Bay, Atlanta

— Somebody has to play Tampa Bay and Miami all the time. Montreal would have to bring back Ellis Valentine, Andre Dawson and Warren Cromartie for Game 1, yes?

STAN MUSIAL DIVISION: St. Louis, Kansas City, Chicago Cubs, Chicago White Sox, Houston, Texas, Colorado, Minnesota

— This makes too much sense, although the Brewers really should be here. U.L. Washington was one of my all-time favorites, by the way.

Advertise with us

JACKIE ROBINSON DIVISION: Los Angeles, Anaheim, Arizona, Oakland, Portland, San Diego, San Francisco, Seattle

— This is the easiest one to form, based on pure geography. Portland should absolutely be required to invite Bill Walton to throw out their first pitch.

Meanwhile, there is plenty more to unpack from Ringolsby’s story.

Let’s take ’em one at a time …

• Reduce the schedule to 156 games. Bravo. Every sport should scale back, but none ever does, for obvious reasons. It would mean less revenue. Baseball apparently would have a plan for that: geographically sensible divisions.

Advertise with us

As Ringolsby put it, “Revenue could be made up by a major reduction in travel costs.”

• Give teams one day off per week. I love this, if only because it might eliminate the Pirates’ dreaded scheduled off days for players and the far-more dreaded “Sunday lineup.”

• Add franchises in Montreal and Portland. Not a big fan of 32 teams, but those are two awesome cities — and at least the addition of two playoff spots will keep most markets interested into September.

• No more American and National leagues. This is kind of big. But hasn’t the line become incredibly blurred, anyway, with so much interleague play? This might finally make the designated hitter universal, as well, and while I’ve thoroughly enjoyed watching Ivan Nova hit .055 in his time here, I’d rather see accomplished sluggers extend their careers across baseball (I humbly apologize to Greg Brown and Bob Walk for this take).

• The four first-place teams in each division would advance to the postseason. They would play the four survivors of play-in games involving the eight remaining teams with the best records. I love this. The opening round would mimic the one-game wild card, which is the best thing baseball has done in a long time.

Advertise with us

Getting the Pirates out of the NL Central would be even better.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.