The race to four. Remember when Dan Bylsma coined that phrase? It still applies in the most important category of all: Stanley Cups.

Look at the scoreboard, the big one that hovers over all 31 NHL arenas. It counts championships, and if we’re talking 21st Century, it reads like this:

Penguins 3, Blackhawks 3.

Just two years ago, the Blackhawks were ahead of the pack after winning their third Cup since the turn of the millennium and third in six years. If they weren’t a dynasty, they were pretty darn close. Right behind them were the Detroit Red Wings, Los Angeles Kings and New Jersey Devils with two Cups apiece since 2000. The Penguins had one.

Advertise with us

Then along came Mike Sullivan. Now we have a tie ballgame. And if you don’t think players pay attention to that giant scoreboard, you’re nuts.

I visited the United Center a few weekends ago to get the view of the Penguins from Chicago, and I asked Blackhawks captain Jonathan Toews that very question: “Do you keep the tally in your head, that now you’re even?”

“For sure,” he said. “I guess that’s the other team we’ve been trying to keep up with and the other way around. … I guess at the end of the day, we thought we were ahead of the pack. But not anymore.”

For many, I’m sure, the dream matchup in June would pit the Penguins against the Edmonton Oilers. Sidney Crosby against Connor McDavid. I wouldn’t complain about it, but I’d rather see Penguins-Blackhawks. It just seems appropriate that these two teams, who have combined to win six of the past nine Cups, would meet on the biggest stage.

Sure, the Blackhawks have lost key pieces. But they still have Toews and Patrick Kane and Brandon Saad (second act) and Duncan Keith and Corey Crawford. They still have a smart management team. They’re still a factor.

Advertise with us

The Penguins own the tie-breaker at the moment because they did what the Blackhawks could not by winning back to back. But might the hockey gods have it in them to provide a truer tie-breaker, a “Game 7” of sorts by pitting these teams in the final sometime soon?

“Well, if it’s worth having faith in anything,” Toews said, tongue only half in-cheek, “that’s what we’d definitely have faith in. For sure.”

Blackhawks assistant general manager Norm Maciver, who played for the Penguins in the mid-1990s, smiled when I broached that topic. Maciver was an assistant coach on Sullivan’s Boston Bruins’ staff from 2003-06 and had a major role in bringing Sullivan to the Blackhawks as a prospect development coach in the 2014-15 season.

“It’s funny, Mike and I talked about [meeting in the Cup final] last year after we had a pretty entertaining game here [a turbo-paced, 4-1 Chicago win March 1],” Maciver said. “We said it’d be pretty fun if we met in the finals. Obviously, it didn’t work out for us. But it certainly worked out for him and the Penguins.”

How about this year?

Advertise with us

“That’d be great, great for the sport,” Maciver said. “I think the amount of Hall of Fame players, players who are some of the best who’ve ever played going head to head would be pretty fun.”

With that he sighed, drew a deep breath and added, “But that’s a looong way off.”

Indeed, hockey season is a life unto itself. Nine months of twists and turns if a team reaches the final. And just when you think you have it pegged, you don’t.

Remember when the Blackhawks waltzed into PPG Paints Arena two weeks before the playoffs last season and toyed with a wounded Penguins team in a 5-1 victory? No sane person, even knowing the Penguins would get healthier (excluding Kris Letang) would have left the arena believing the Penguins were the better bet to win it all.

Within days, the world changed. The Penguins survived a seven-game battle against the Capitals in Round 2; Nashville swept the Blackhawks in Round 1.

Advertise with us

Toews watched with admiration as the Penguins kept finding ways to advance. It reminded him of his past two titles.

“I thought of our series against Anaheim in ’15 (Chicago trailed 3-2) and Detroit in ’13 (trailed 3-1 ),” he said. “It seems like it didn’t matter how badly they had their backs up against the wall, they just seemed to rely on their experience, and they knew when it came down to it, they could just out-execute.

“I think maybe when other teams want it so bad, and they feel the pressure that it might be their time to win, sometimes you maybe overthink or the pressure gets to you, whereas Pittsburgh just kind of played hockey. They knew in the big moments that big players can make it happen.”

The way Maciver sees it, and he’s right, it really is about the stars. We can talk depth all we want. The Penguins had all kinds of guys step up over the past two years. But everything begins at the top.

“At the end of the day, it still boiled down to their best two players being at the top of their game,” Maciver said. “And that’s what we had. I mean, in 2015, Duncan Keith probably played defense as well as anyone has ever played defense in the National Hockey League. Without that, we probably don’t get out of the first round. He took his game to a level I’ve never seen a defenseman play at. He carried us to the Cup.

Advertise with us

“The Penguins, you’ve had Crosby playing at this level you’ve probably never seen before, and he’s done it for two years in a row. So when you go into a series that’s fairly even, but you have the best players on your team and they’re playing extremely well, you have a significant advantage.”

The Penguins and Blackhawks are scheduled to play twice this season — Oct. 5 at the United Center (Chicago’s home opener) and Nov. 18 at PPG Paints Arena.

It’d be real nice if they met again in June.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.