Nothing, not even “Pitt 43, Clemson 42” can match “13-9” in terms of sheer astonishment … or can it?
I’m beginning to think a Pitt victory Saturday at Beaver Stadium — the Panthers are 21-point underdogs — might constitute the biggest upset in school history, depending on the circumstances and how the season plays out.
A little background work is in order.
The late, great Beano Cook used to say the 13-0 victory over Fordham in 1941 was Pitt’s greatest upset. The numbers don’t harm his opinion.
Pitt was 0-5 and had been outscored 133-21. Third-ranked Fordham was 5-0 and had outscored opponents 115-38. Time Magazine called it the “greatest upset of 1941” and delivered this little gem:
“ ‘Get your rose-colored glasses so they won’t look so bad,’ bawled butchers in Pittsburgh’s 70,000-seat stadium last week as a scant 27,000 football fans trickled in to watch Pitt play Fordham.”
Read More
Wait, did they have live butchers at football games in 1941, or was that an early reference to scalpers?
And Pitt’s attendance issues were already a thing?
I’m not sure if Beano deemed “13-9” superior to “13-0” on the upset meter, and he wasn’t around to see 43-42 (how he would have loved it). I can only tell you this: If Pitt wins Saturday, I will be nearly as shocked as I was sitting in the press box Dec. 1, 2007, at Mountaineer Stadium, and maybe more so — and that result was literally unimaginable.
After all, I had been sitting in the same press box a week earlier watching the Mountaineers hang 66 on a decent Connecticut team while Pitt was falling all over itself against South Florida. I’d seen Steve Slaton and Pat White shred Dave Wannstedt’s defense for nearly a thousand yards rushing in their previous two matchups (you can look it up), once prompting Wanny’s legendary halftime response when queried on what Pitt needed to do to control WVU’s read-option.
“Run faster,” he said.
I thought West Virginia would cover the 28½-point spread. But then came the miracle, which, as I look ahead to Saturday, triggers a memory of what the great Russian hockey player Slava Fetisov told me as we discussed his team’s unfathomable 1980 Olympic loss to Team USA …
“That’s why they call it miracle: only happens once.”

So no, I don’t think Pitt will beat Penn State. I think Penn State will cover the spread, and I’m not sure 21 points is enough.
I mean, did you watch the games last Saturday?
Penn State wrecked Akron, 52-0, flashing all the talent that has it ranked No. 4 in the country. Saquon Barkley again looked like the next coming of Barry Sanders. I do not see him as currently containable, particularly by a defense void of playmakers.
Meanwhile, Pitt blew a 21-0 lead against Youngstown State — now prepping for the big Robert Morris game — before escaping in overtime.
Week 1 can be deceiving. I grant you that.
But if I’m a Panthers fan, I’m horrified by the fact that Youngstown State outgained my team 276-85 in the second half. I’m worried about the offensive line, the entire defense (which again will be without safety Jordan Whitehead), the kicker and especially the new quarterback (Max Browne).
I’m willing to entertain the notion that Browne needed a game to shake the rust after not playing for a year. But he never looked comfortable. He even got clobbered while trying to place the ball for a late field goal. I’d never seen that before.
Unlike a decade ago in West Virginia, the Panthers appear to lack a transcendent player such as Shady McCoy, who seemingly got the ball on every play in “13-9” and gained 148 yards.
All of which is why it’s nearly impossible to envisage a scenario by which Pitt wins this game.
Pitt sports historian Sam Sciullo would list a win Saturday as the fifth-biggest upset in school history. His top five:
1. Pitt 13, WVU 9
2. Pitt 13, Fordham 0.
3. Pitt 43, Clemson 42 (Pitt was around a 21-point underdog in that one, too).
4. Pitt 7, Georgia 7, 1973. A tie? Sciullo recalled that Georgia was a 17-point favorite at home in the first game for Johnny Majors and Tony Dorsett, so I guess I’ll buy it.
5. Pitt 22, Notre Dame 19, 1952, at South Bend.
Here’s how a Pitt win could top “13-9,” in my estimation:
• Barkley and Penn State’s other stars stay healthy. One thing about “13-9” is that White, who was as explosive as any player in the country, injured his thumb early and missed much of the game. If that could have been known beforehand, the spread would have come down by at least a touchdown.
• Penn State goes on to have a big year, while Pitt struggles. And it would be especially relevant if this win, like last year’s, keeps Penn State out of the College Football Playoff (kind of how the win over WVU kept the Mountaineers out of the national title game).
I can’t imagine it, but I’ve been horrifically wrong before.
Maybe miracle happens twice.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.