Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:
Jeff Meyer, @jj_meyer18: Would the Pirates have won a World Series in my lifetime (1994) if Lemieux was the owner?
Starkey: My gut response is no, Jeff, but my brain has other ideas.
First of all, you can’t mention Lemieux without Ron Burkle. They are a pair, and Burkle’s got the thicker wallet (not that Mario’s hurting).
It was Burkle, you’ll recall, who reportedly made an offer to Bob Nutting to buy the Pirates in late 2009, not long after the Penguins won the Stanley Cup in Detroit. According to the Post-Gazette, Penguins sources said Burkle made a “very serious” offer while Nutting characterized it much, much differently and said, “The team is not for sale.”
That remains the case. But then again, Jeff, everything’s for sale for the right price, isn’t it?
Read More
Anyway, my gut response is to say Lemieux and Burkle would have been doomed without a salary cap in the NHL, let alone Major League Baseball. Just go back and listen to Lemieux after the Penguins won the Cup in Nashville.
“The salary cap gave us a chance to spend to the cap and be on level playing fields with the other teams,” he said, “We couldn’t compete with the Rangers and L.A. and the big markets, and Chicago and Detroit.”
That is why Lemieux and the other NHL owners, to their eternal credit, were willing to turn out the lights on a full season in order to get what they wanted.
Always remember: No cap = No Cups.
Now switch to baseball. Take Lemieux’s words “We couldn’t compete” and add “with the Cubs and L.A. and the big markets.”
Not on a yearly basis, anyway. But that wasn’t your question, Jeff. You wondered if the Pirates might have won a World Series with Mario (and Burkle) owning the team.
My brain tells me they would have had a better chance, because compared to Nutting, Burkle might have been just a little less lustful of the bottom line. Just a little more willing to treat his team like an expensive sports car.
As in, why buy one if you’re not going to have some fun with it?
Pirates GM Neal Huntington has said on many occasions, most recently in the wake of the trade deadline (emphasis on “dead”), that he could have made some big deals in past years and that those deals might have meant “winning a few more games” in a given season at the expense of losing a good young player or several prospects.
I wonder if Burkle would have pushed Huntington to take that risk, the way he did with the 2007-08 Penguins, when he urged GM Ray Shero to go for broke with Marian Hossa. Even if that wasn’t what the “five-year plan” mandated. Even if the Penguins were ahead of schedule and potentially behind on the budget.
When you think about it, Jeff, “a few more wins” might have meant all the difference for the Pirates. They finished three games behind the Cardinals in 2013 and two games behind in 2014 and ’15. A “few more wins” might have meant avoiding wild-card scenarios and clinching home-field advantage in a playoff series or two and, who knows, maybe even winning a World Series.
Jeff?
Jeff?
You were drifting off, my friend. Looked like you were dreaming. Wake up!!
Brady Carrier, @carrier3brady: Does Nutting hear the complaints on the talk shows and do you think he cares?
Starkey: I’m guessing he doesn’t sit around listening to “Starkey & Mueller” every day (”Hey guys, Bucco Bob here, big fan, first-time caller”) but who knows? Just be sure he is aware of the anger and apathy out there. All he has to do is look at the plummeting attendance figures and TV ratings.
Does he care?
I think he does. Just not as much as he cares about running a sound business. Which is to say, one that generates a nifty profit and maintains its value regardless of what happens on the field. And make no mistake, the money to be made on this franchise is in the eventual sale.
For what it’s worth (and it is apparently worth plenty), Forbes Magazine in April estimated the Pirates’ worth at $1.25 billion, more than its estimate on the Penguins ($570 million) and less the Steelers ($2.25 billion).
Of course, as I discussed with Jeff above, something’s only worth what somebody wants to pay, right Brady?
Meanwhile, Nutting really should have the guts to get in front of his season-ticket holders during the “Ask Pirates Management” portion of Pirate Fest. His absence leaves Huntington, team president Frank Coonelly and manager Clint Hurdle to face questions about putting profit over winning.
This is how Coonelly answered one such question in December:
“I’m so tired of that narrative,” he said. “As these gentlemen [Hurdle and Huntington] can explain to you, as my wife sitting out there can explain to you, there’s nobody more competitive than the three men up on this stage (Starkey interruption: Notice he didn’t mention Nutting?). And there is nothing more that anyone can do for you — not for us — than to win a World Series championship here in Pittsburgh. That’s why we do what we do. That’s why I get up every single morning — to do that.
“It’s not about profiting. It’s about putting together a winning team, allocating resources to the major league team to win a championship here in Pittsburgh. I get it. It’s a long winter. I can’t wait until spring comes. We need — in the media and otherwise — to talk about a lot of things. But the narrative that we don’t care about winning is just flat wrong. It’s offensive, too, but that’s another matter.”
That was before the Pirates opened the season with a smaller payroll than the year before.
Devin Walsh, @Wa4l4sh: Years from now will Orpik’s time in PGH get the respect it prob deserves for his 10+ years here or has that been ruined by past 2 seasons?
Starkey: A cynic might say Orpik helped the Penguins win three Stanley Cups — one here and two as a member of the Washington Capitals.
The cynic would be right, incidentally. Orpik was a robust minus-5 over his two playoff series against the Penguins and is minus-10 overall in his playoff career in Washington. I don’t even want to see his advanced stats.
But let’s be very clear about his time here: He was a hugely important presence in the Penguins’ resurgence, on and off the ice.
He played 703 regular-season games here, more than any defenseman in Penguins history and fifth overall on the franchise list when he left.
If he accomplished nothing but “The Shift,” against Detroit in the 2008 Stanley Cup final — when he shot down a bunch of Red Wings like clay pigeons — he would be a legend.
But there was much more. Orpik once told me these were his top three Penguins memories:
1. Winning the Cup in Detroit. He had game highs of nine hits and five blocked shots in Game 7.
2. Getting drafted back-to-back with former Boston College teammate Krys Kolanos in 2000. The Penguins brilliantly snagged Orpik 18th overall. Ten of the 13 players drafted directly in front of him did not play even two full seasons.
3. Playing his first NHL game: Dec. 10, 2002, against Toronto.
He should be remembered fondly here.
GaryMorgan, @garymo2007: Is there any way SRod coming back doesn’t lead to JHay departure?
Starkey: I’ll say this, Mr. garymo2007: An early look at next year’s salaries tells me that Harrison ($10.25 million), Rodriguez ($5.5 million) and David Freese ($4.25 million) would account for about 20 percent of a $100 million payroll. So your observation is well-taken. Harrison could be on his way out.
Or the Pirates could significantly bump the payroll. Are you betting on that after a horrible year attendance-wise?
GaryMorgan @garymo2007: Any team in Pittsburgh. Favorite player acquired by trade in your memory.
Starkey: Ron Hainsey.
yin @chuckybuckle22: Are you throwing the quiz shows to muellsy on purpose? Or does he win because he has more time 2 study since he doesn’t go into locker rooms?
Starkey: Pay the man, Shirley (apologies to the great Norman Chad).
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.