Johnny Cueto is scheduled to pitch Friday night at PNC Park, an occurrence that always brings back memories but seems especially poignant this time around.
Couple of reasons for that.
One is that I can’t help but juxtapose the glorious night from four years ago, the night “Cueto dropped the ball!” with what I’m staring at from the press box on this perfect summer evening: lots of empty seats.
It’s not a terrible crowd for a weeknight (22,595). Not at all. But it’s still a reminder that the Pirates are in danger of posting their biggest attendance drop since their second year at PNC Park — the precipitous plunge that followed the 100-loss season of 2001.
The average crowd (23,505) has shrunk by nearly 4,000 per game through half the home schedule. That ought to set off alarms in Bob Nutting’s office. It would mark a third consecutive drop.
A sports franchise’s worst enemy — apathy — has begun to set in. Can you imagine what this place would look like if the Pirates threw a yard sale at the trade deadline?
Read More
You’d have more Pierogies than people.
On the other hand, Cueto’s appearance isn’t just steeped in nostalgia or symoblic of a possible attendance Armageddon. It’s a reminder that the Pirates, unbelievably, are smack in the middle of the National League Central race and that Cueto himself — or a similar stud — could wind up in the hands of the rival Chicago Cubs.
So the question becomes: Will upper management step up and compete?
I don’t mean compete for Cueto. I mean compete, period. Will it keep the two biggest stars on the team in Andrew McCutchen and Gerrit Cole?
Will it add to the roster, perhaps in the form of a legit starting pitcher sooner rather than later (because if you keep waiting to see if you’re really, really in contention, you just might fall out)? Will it actually try to win a division that is up for grabs?
I doubt it.
But if I were a fan, I’d surely hope so.
After his team’s 4-0 win against the Tampa Bay Rays, manager Clint Hurdle gave the only answer he could, I suppose, to the question of whether he is confident upper management will add to the club so long as it stays within striking distance of first place.
“I have every confidence if there’s something they can do, they’ll do it,” he said. “They’ve shown that.”
This is a gift, you know. The Pirates don’t deserve to be in contention. But the baseball gods — perhaps as compensation for the 98-win season that netted just a second-place finish — have given them real opportunity.
You don’t snub a gift like that. You accept it gratefully and try to maximize it. You might even part with a prized prospect in order to bolster your team (trust me, the franchise would survive).
It’s not like the Pirates would be going all in for a one-game wild card. This is the division we’re talking about, and take a look around:
• The Milwaukee Brewers just lost ace Chase Anderson for several weeks.
•The Cubs were beset by internal squabbling earlier this week, lost Kris Bryant to an ankle injury and have multiple pitching issues.
The Pirates’ 37-42 record doesn’t matter. The fact they are a mere four games out of first place (albeit barely out of last place) with 83 games left indisputably defines them as a contender.
For all their issues, this team has reason for hope. It presumably will add an All-Star outfielder (Starling Marte) in three weeks. It has an excellent front end of the rotation in Cole, Ivan Nova and Jameson Taillon, who tossed 6⅓ shutout innings Thursday.
It also has a lights-out closer and the potential for a better bullpen overall in the second half, if the past two nights were any indication.
Tony Watson had an especially heartening appearance, striking out Corey Dickerson and retiring Evan Longoria on a single pitch to preserve Taillon’s shutout through seven.
It kind of looked like old times these past two games. Quick lead. Efficient effort from starter. Lock-down bullpen. No errors. Nice and clean.
“That’s how we play,” said shortstop Jordy Mercer. “The five years I’ve been here, that’s how we’ve won: pitching and defense.”
I give credit to the fans still showing up. They’re incredibly faithful. Enthusiastic, too. The roars were real when McCutchen rapped an RBI single, when John Jaso and Gregory Polanco (man, could they use his bat) smacked home runs and especially when Taillon left the game.
Listen, there will never be another Cueto moment. That was once in a lifetime. But I’m telling you, it wouldn’t take much to light this place up again.
The Pirates, in spite of themselves and their unsightly record, are in it.
They could use a little help from above — and I don’t mean the baseball gods.
They’ve done enough already.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.