Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:
Zack @zrich529: Should Matt Niskanen be given a life sentence or the death penalty?
Starkey: I think death by stoning should be sufficient, Mr. zrich529, but let’s get to the heart of the matter: Alex Ovechkin set the wheels in motion by tripping Crosby from behind and slashing him twice — once on an ax-chop to the upper body and again in the back of the head.
If that doesn’t happen — and how is that not penalized? — then Niskanen still takes his free shot but doesn’t have Crosby in such a vulnerable position.
Listen, the Niskanen hit was bad. When Tie Domi, he of the 3,515 career penalty minutes, is tweeting out a photo of the incident and mocking Capitals coach Barry Trotz’s assertion that it was “a hockey play,” then you know it’s bad. As one ex-Penguins player texted me: “The more I watch it, the more I don’t like it.”
" Hockey Play " Whoever uses that line on this is embarrassing to the game... pic.twitter.com/nUIDStC9tR
— Tie Domi (@thereal_tiedomi) May 2, 2017
Niskanen cross-checked a vulnerable player in the skull and followed through fully, a game after he viciously cross-checked Crosby in the back behind the Capitals’ net, long after the puck was gone. Cowardly hits, both of them. Reminds me of when Herb Brooks ripped Flyers defenseman Luke Richardson for intentionally firing a puck at Bob Boughner’s chest.
Read More
“I wonder if [Richardson is] a direct descendant of the coward who murdered Jesse James,” Brooks said. “I’m sure if you go back, he’s in the family tree somewhere.”
But the real outlaw here is Ovechkin — and there is a long history between Engine No. 8 and the Penguins. A long history of odd and unusual plays where you scratch your head and ask, “Wait a second, was he trying to maim somebody?” Ovechkin seems to have mastered the art of the reckless play that may or may not have been intentional and leaves everybody wondering what the blank just happened.
To my way of thinking, you make enough of those plays against the same team, and you lose the benefit of the doubt.
Some examples:
• Ovechkin blasted Sergei Gonchar out of the 2009 series with a knee-on-knee hit. Ah, he didn’t really mean it. Unless he did. But no suspension or fine, prompting Gonchar’s agent, J.P. Barry, to assert, “We now have Exhibit A of the extreme double standard that exists in the NHL’s approach to discipline. Alex clearly cuts back with his knee after missing his check, with devastating results. But of course, because it’s Alex, it’s all Sergei’s fault.”
Guy named Brooks Orpik, then a Penguins defenseman, had an opinion at the time, too, saying, “That’s three games in a row where he’s out there trying to hurt guys. You just watch the way he hits. And I love the way he plays … but he could get a charging penalty every time he hits. He leaves his feet and takes countless strides. We’ve gotten lucky up to this point. And he likes to target the Russian guys, for some reason. Everyone likes to play hard, and play physical. But there’s a line you can’t cross, and a lot of guys in our room felt like the last couple games he was taking shots where he was trying to hurt guys.”
• Ovechkin’s baseball-style swing that smashed Kris Letang in the back of the skate and sent him careening into the boards in February 2015. Ah, he didn’t mean that one, either. Unless he did. The Capitals maintained he was just trying to shoot the puck.
“Apparently,” Letang said, “my leg was a puck.”
The Capitals seemed indignant that Ovie would ever be questioned on such a play. Hey, it was a “hockey play,” right? Penguins GM Jim Rutherford was having none of it, saying at the time, “I know they’re from Washington, but I didn’t realize they used the same spin that the politicians use.”
I remember asking Barry Trotz about the swipe on Letang twice after the game, and he got all hot and bothered, the same way he did when pressed about Ovechkin’s play after Monday’s game.
• The slash on Crosby’s hand in last year’s playoffs that left Crosby fuming down the runway.
• The careless beanball that hit Ron Hainsey the other night (though I would agree there’s no way Ovechkin meant to hit Hainsey in the head, and the puck jumped on him, I can tell you that in the Penguins’ dressing room, the feeling was that it was a reckless play).
• For much of his early career, Ovechkin had a weird obsession with attempting to injure Evgeni Malkin — and there was no room for interpretation on some of the insane freight-train hits he would inflict on his countryman. The worst of those was Jan. 21, 2007, at Mellon Arena, when Ovechkin took a maniacal run at Malkin and nearly blind-sided him into 2008. Malkin dipped his shoulder at the last instant and sent Ovechkin careening into the boards.
“Very dangerous hit,” said Barry (also Malkin’s agent) at the time. “Had [Ovechkin] actually [landed the blow], it would been a disciplinary-type hit.”
The theory back then was that something had gone awry in August 2007 at a Moscow nightclub, where Ovechkin allegedly punched out Malkin’s Russian agent, Gennady Ushakov. Ovechkin denied the story. Malkin didn’t. I asked him at the time if Ovechkin punched Ushakov.
“Yes,” he said. “Bad situation.”
Apparently, the two have patched things up. To what extent? Who knows? Maybe it’s fine, maybe it’s not.
You’re never quite sure with Ovechkin.
Mike Sullivan talks about hit on Sidney Crosby in Game 3
Nich Olas @NHaas88: Do you think the Caps will dress Lorena Bobbitt for Wednesday’s game?
Starkey: Not sure, Nich, but I can tell you this: Her slash, egregious as it was, might have gotten her a minor penalty in the NHL.
Whatever happened to Lorena Bobbitt?
And did you know John Bobbitt was from Buffalo?
jkclo @jkclo9906: If 87 out??
Starkey: If 87 out, Penguins lose, Mr. jkclo9906. Sorry, but I can’t see it any other way. Do I really need to go into detail as to what Sidney Crosby means to the Penguins? Go back and watch Games 1 and 2.
Go back and watch Game 6 against Tampa Bay last year.
It was admirable the way the club fought without him in Game 3. And the Capitals are always capable of screwing up in a tight situation. But expecting the Penguins to survive without Letang and Crosby and with a severely comprised Patric Hornqvist would be asking too much.
Josh Williams @No1PittSports: Why does Billy Hamilton do nothing against the rest of the league but turns into Rickey Henderson against the Pirates?
Starkey: Truly, Mr. No1PittSports, it’s one of the more remarkable phenomenons in all of baseball. If you’re a Pirates fan, you must feel like lighting your teeth on fire every time Hamilton steps to the plate. And you probably didn’t bother watching when he came to bat with the game on the line Monday, because you knew what would happen. We all knew what would happen.
Hamilton has played more games against the Pirates than any team but the Cardinals, and of course — and this is really infuriating, I’m sure — he stinks against the Cardinals and is indeed some combination of Rickey Henderson, Lou Brock and Mike Trout against the Pirates.
In 52 games against St. Louis, Hamilton is hitting .225 with 27 stolen bases. In 48 games against the Pirates, he is hitting .323 with 43 steals!
He is a career .246 hitter with a .291 on-base percentage. Against the Pirates, his OBP is a robust .366. It’s almost laughable.
Maybe the Penguins could hire a couple of hit men to take him out. Anybody got numbers for Ovechkin and Niskanen?
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.