I’ll say this much: Because of the emergence of Justin Schultz as an all-star-caliber defenseman, the Penguins have a better chance to withstand the loss of Kris Letang than they would have last season. And they’ll still beat Columbus.
But let’s not kid ourselves. Their shot to repeat as Stanley Cup champions took a massive body blow Wednesday when the club announced that Letang will have surgery to repair a herniated disc in his neck. The recovery period is 4-6 months.
The news came just a week after coach Mike Sullivan answered with an emphatic “Yes” when I asked if he was confident Letang would be available to start the playoffs. Letang apparently was preparing to rejoin practice when an MRI revealed that his condition had worsened, in turn worsening the Penguins’ odds to navigate the Eastern Conference. Notably to get past the improved Washington Capitals, should it come to that.
Still, even if I’m not betting on the Penguins to defend their title, I refuse to write them off. That would be silly. The East isn’t exactly daunting beyond the Capitals, and, truthfully, what have the Capitals ever won?
The Penguins did OK without Letang in the regular season — 12-5-3 over the past 20 games — but I can’t put too much stock in that. The regular season doesn’t mimic the relentlessness of facing, say, the Blue Jackets and the Capitals 13 times in 26 nights.
Sullivan was asked about the spotlight turning to Schultz.
Read More
“He’s an important guy for us,” Sullivan said. “He has been for quite some time now. I don’t think he has to assume this great burden of responsibility. He has to continue to be the player he’s been for us all season long. We don’t expect any one guy to replace Kris Letang.”
Schultz has 12 goals, a total Letang has surpassed only once (last season), and 49 points, a total Letang has surpassed only three times. Schultz is plus-26. He is at least as good as Letang on the power play. But let’s not be unreasonable. Schultz is not Letang — certainly not the vintage Letang we saw in the playoffs last year.
That Letang was playing nearly 30 minutes a game.
That Letang was a voracious defender and puck-mover with a flair for the spectacular play — like his Cup-winning goal in San Jose.
You don’t replace that Letang, by committee or otherwise. Great defensemen, because they play so much, can have a more profound impact on a game than anybody but the goalie. Sometimes including the goalie. Look at recent history. Letang, Duncan Keith, Drew Doughty and Zdeno Chara basically have taken turns scribbling their name on the Cup (although Letang wasn’t yet great in 2009). And they all followed Nicklas Lidstrom.
Having said that, who knows if other teams will incur major injuries — and look at what the Penguins still have. If Evgeni Malkin returns, this team still is blessed with more firepower than anybody in the East. It remains plenty deep, plenty fast, plenty tough and plenty tested.
Murray is getting hot at the right time. Phil Kessel is showing signs of life. Nobody will be surprised if he finds his scoring touch in Game 1. Sidney Crosby has ideal collaborators in Jake Guentzel and Conor Sheary. Schultz will have to stay fresh — his minutes have increased lately — and the rest of the defense will need to get healthy fast.
It really could all come together, and, even if it doesn’t, the Penguins will be a tough out. But if you characterize the loss of Kris Letang as anything but a major blow, you’re fooling yourself.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.