Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jraystarkey@gmail.com. On to the questions:
cliff mcafee, @Cmac412Cliff: What do the #Steelers do with Green? Does he retire?
Starkey: Oh man, the first thing that comes to mind with that question is what a difference Ladarius Green and/or Martavis Bryant would have made — and let’s be real: Outgunning the Patriots was going to be this team’s only hope, even if you were dreaming of such a matchup back in August. The Steelers have proven over time to be ill-equipped, coaching-wise and personnel-wise, to slow Tom Brady in any kind of meaningful way.
I can’t help but wonder what Bryant was thinking and feeling as he watched the game. If it was anything but shame — anything but, “Wow, my selfishness might have ruined the season” — than he’s delusional. We all wondered how his absence might affect the offense. My initial feeling was that a possible all-time unit now had a ceiling. A high one, but a ceiling nonetheless.
It came crashing down over the past two games.
Combined with the Green injury, Bryant’s absence basically ruined the offense in the end. Sure, the Steelers took advantage of a ravaged Miami secondary in Round 1, but they did not score a touchdown at Kansas City and underachieved in New England, even considering Le’Veon Bell’s injury.
Read More
While we’re on the topic, these are the Steelers’ point totals in their past five playoff games, besides Miami: 17, 18, 16, 18, 17. Those are outputs the ‘85 Bears might not have overcome.
Anyway, that likely would have been Bryant instead of Sammie Coates when Coates alligator-armed the early bomb. Might have been Bryant, too, when Cobi “Dan Orlovsky” Hamilton stepped out of bounds and then back in, and earlier dropped a touchdown pass. Hines Ward had it right when he said of the first play that Hamilton should have ducked out of sight after stepping out of bounds, so as to make himself unavailable to Ben Roethlisberger. Terrible mistake.
You might remember that Bryant, when last seen in a playoff game, was making one of the most spectacular touchdown catches on record.
Of course, Green might have been the target on any number of plays, as well. He was a major difference maker in his limited time — and on Monday didn’t sound like a man contemplating retirement. The best option, clearly, is to keep him and his $5 million base salary for next season and pray his concussion issues clear up.
In short, the hope is that both Green and Bryant have full use of their brains by the time training camp begins.
Joe Starkey, @Joestarkey1: What about Coates’ future?
Starkey: Hi, Joe. You mean after he wins “Best Supporting Actor” for his role in AB’s Facebook Live video? First, I guess it depends on those troublesome fingers. How many, exactly, are broken? All 10? And when will they heal? Coates spoke Monday of having “more surgery” on his fingers. I certainly wouldn’t cast him aside — he was the league’s most lethal deep threat for the first month of the season — but he doesn’t strike me as the super-focused type, and he becomes redundant if Bryant is eligible.
Ricky Kolar, @Ricky_Kolar3: Do the Steelers have a quarterback sneak in their playbook?
Starkey: Apparently not, Ricky, based on that goal-line abomination Sunday and many games worth of evidence. But who needs a playbook to design a quarterback sneak? That’s a play their quarterback can run any time he wants — and the Patriots’ quarterback sure runs it a lot, doesn’t he?
Matter of fact, here’s a New York Times article from the Super Bowl two years ago headlined “A Tom Brady Sneak is the Patriots’ Unstoppable Play.”
I’ll share the the first two paragraphs:
The most automatic play in the Patriots’ offensive playbook over the last 14 seasons involves Tom Brady, but it is not a pass. It is having Brady tuck the ball and lower his shoulder and shimmy into a narrow gap, gaining inch after bruising inch, the quarterback with a fullback’s mentality.
Brady is as unstoppable as a crash of rhinos on third or fourth down and 2 yards or less to go, the rushing equivalent of a back-shoulder throw from Aaron Rodgers. Counting the postseason, Brady has run in those situations 115 times, according to play-by-play data from Pro Football Reference. He has gotten a first down or scored a touchdown on 105 of them, a success rate of 91.3 percent. Over one stretch, spanning more than seven years, he converted 60 of 61, including 37 straight.
How about that? The story goes on to quote Patriots’ offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels as saying Brady simply runs the play when he wants, even if it’s not the call.
“He just says, ‘I’m going to get it myself,’ “ McDaniels said, adding: “To go in there and stick your face in there, where there’s a lot of big people ready to hit you quickly, that’s something I’m not sure that every quarterback wants to do. But he’s never been afraid to do it.”
OK, so why don’t the Steelers ever run the play? Their quarterback stands 6-5, 250. Surely, it’s not for a lack of toughness. Ben Roethlisberger tries to make tackles after interceptions and has never been afraid to take a hit.
So why no sneaks? It’s such an easy way to get a yard, or in Sunday’s case, a foot. Brady once converted 60 of 61 attempts from two yards or less. Think about that! And please don’t tell me you’re buying what Ben was selling after the game.
“We just go with plays that are called,” he said. “Coach Haley calls a play to me, and we call it in the huddle.”
Yeah, OK. Just doin’ what the coordinator tells me to do.
Let’s make one thing very clear here: Ben can do whatever he wants, whenever he wants, and nobody in the organization can stop him (not that the coaches would be angry if he decided to take the ball and bull ahead for a foot every once in a while). For whatever reason, he apparently does not want to run sneaks.
***Starkey update: Roethlisberger was asked by Ron Cook on “Cook & Poni” today why he doesn’t use the sneak, whether he or the coaches like it or not. This became a rather minor point when Ben later refused to commit to even playing football next season, let alone running QB sneaks -- anybody ready for the Zach Mettenberger era? -- but this is what he said.
“I have no problem sneaking. My sneak percentage, whether it’s fourth-and-short or a goal-to-go situation, is pretty successful. In the high 90s. I’ve never expressed not wanting to do it. … The plays come in from coach Haley and I call ’em.”
Looks like that's his story, and he's sticking to it.
Oh, and for those rejoicing when Jesse James was stopped because it would burn more time off the clock before the Steelers inevitably scored, remember this: Touchdowns are good. Get them when you can. Scoring from a foot out is never guaranteed.
All of that being said, I was heartened to see Rosie Nix and David Johnson get involved in the passing game. Could there be a more useless play than throwing to Johnson in space in hopes he makes somebody miss? He never will. He never, ever will. So please don’t call that play again. Please take that play out of the playbook and light it on fire.
Maybe replace it with a quarterback sneak?
Nathan, @nefergus: In hindsight, I’d rather have played the Texans at home.
Starkey: Thank you for the dose of sanity, sir. I assume you’re referring to a radio topic we discussed last week, where we asked: Would you rather have played the Texans at Heinz Field or are you happy to be going to Foxborough? Those were innocent times, Mr. @nefergus. The citizens were feeling frisky, flexing their radio-talk muscles (which are much like Twitter muscles), even though the Steelers barely survived the Kansas City Chiefs despite badly outplaying them.
Yup, eeeeevvvvverybody wanted Tom Brady. In Foxborough. Because that has always gone well. This would be Ben’s legacy game. It was the best route to take. The only route to take. The right route to take.
How did it work out?
Brady’s numbers against the Steelers in Foxborough are so thoroughly embarrassing that I’m reluctant to write them. They are an unbelievable indictment of this coaching staff and the previous one. Brady’s great. We all know that. Might be the greatest ever. But somebody’s beating him. Ten of his past 11 seasons have ended with a loss.
Yes, Brady tortures most teams. But he tortures the Steelers in a special, historic kind of way.
In six home games against the Steelers, dating to 2002, Brady is 171 of 239 for 2,147 yards, 21 touchdowns and no interceptions. That’s a 71.5 percent completion percentage and a hilarious 128.6 passer rating.
Brady doesn’t do that against everybody. Just the Steelers. They have tried blitzing him. They have lived in their fears and tried a three-man rush with zone behind it. Nothing works. Their best plans have been rendered useless and even laughable.
Did Steelers players really say they were surprised by New England attacking quickly in a no-huddle?
What would be surprising about that?
I feel quite comfortable saying that no quarterback, in the history of the game, has destroyed a good opponent more often or more thoroughly than Tom Brady has destroyed the Steelers.
Thank you, Mr. @nefergus.
Johnny Nowhere @spider_ramone: Why do the #Steelers insist on soft zone vs. Pats every time? IT. DOESN’T. WORK. You guys make my day.
Starkey: Thank you for the compliment, Johnny Nowhere. But if you’re saying the Steelers always back off against Brady, that’s not true. They have tried to blitz him many times, to disastrous results. According to ESPN’s numbers, they blitzed often in last year’s opener, and Brady went 8-for-10 for 63 yards and four touchdowns against the blitz.
This year, they backed off. That worked OK in a regular-season matchup, although Blount just butchered them on the ground. It didn’t work Sunday. And if you’re saying you’d rather go down fighting by playing man-to-man and going after Brady, I agree.
Problem is, the Steelers don’t have elite pass rushers. The last time they beat Brady was in 2011 when they used aggressive press coverage all over the field and had an elite pass rusher — LaMarr Woodley, who had two sacks in the first half (becoming the first Steeler to get multiple sacks in four consecutive games).
Sadly, Woodley injured his groin late in the first half and was not the same for the rest of his Steelers career. After that day, he had nine sacks in his final 27 games with the team. So even a good day against the Patriots was cursed.
Meanwhile, it turns out the Steelers’ big defensive numbers down the stretch were a mirage. Consider that 12 of their 31 sacks over the final nine games came in two meetings with the Cleveland Browns. That leaves 19 in seven games. Still a nice pace, but the reality is that the Steelers played only one top-10 offense during their winning streak, and that was the Colts-minus-Andrew Luck (which means it was actually a bottom-five offense).
This defense is still nowhere near where it needs to be. If you didn’t think Brady was going to do what he always does to the Steelers, you weren’t paying attention. And as Hines Ward told me after the game, “I don’t see him slowing down anytime soon.”
deplorable AJ @fullerlondon: Big players and coaches come up big in big games. Where were our big players?
Starkey: Well, if you’re talking about the “Big Three,” AJ, the breakdown went like this: Le’Veon Bell got hurt on his second carry and was a shell of himself; Ben was hanging in there without much help from his receivers (just runnin the plays that were called!) and Antonio Brown was getting shut down by Malcolm Butler with plenty of safety help. Let the record show that before garbage time — before the Patriots went up 27-9, that is — Brown had four catches for 39 yards.
As for Bell, getting injured obviously wasn’t his fault, but I’m quite certain it would help the cause if he was around for the beginning or the end of a season one of these years.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jraystarkey@gmail.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.