Considering they reside just a couple of streets apart (Interstates 79 and 90), the Steelers and Buffalo Bills share a remarkably scant history — except for the Bills trying to become the Steelers by hiring all of their ex-coaches and executives over the past 15 years, that is.

The teams easily could have and probably should have wound up in the same division when the NFL absorbed the AFL in 1970 — think “Rust Belt Division” with Pittsburgh, Buffalo, Cleveland and Detroit — but they have played just 24 times, including three playoff games, in 46 years.

And yet, as a person who has lived in both cities, I find myself mentally scrolling through some incredible Steelers-Bills moments as the teams gear up for a fairly important 25th meeting Sunday. Some of those changed the fortunes of one or both franchises.

Some just made you laugh.

Advertise with us

Do you remember Bills receiver Stevie Johnson blaming God for his dropped touchdown pass in overtime in 2010? If Johnson doesn’t allow Ryan Fitzpatrick’s pass to sail through his hands, the Steelers probably don’t win the AFC North or go to the Super Bowl.

Johnson went into the locker room, grabbed his iPad and pounded out the following tweet to God: “I PRAISE YOU 24/7!!!!!! AND THIS HOW YOU DO ME!!!!! YOU EXPECT ME TO LEARN FROM THIS??? HOW???!!! ILL NEVER FORGET THIS!! EVER!!! THX THO … “

“You’re welcome,” would have been the perfect troll response from God, who displayed a similarly cruel sense of humor in the final game of the 2004 regular season in Buffalo. The Bills needed a win to secure their first playoff spot in five years and justify the hiring of general manager Tom Donahoe three years earlier. The Steelers had already clinched their division and would rest several starters, including rookie quarterback Ben Roethlisberger.

The back story was that Bill Cowher in 1999 had prevailed in a bitter power struggle with then-Steelers GM Donahoe. The two were about as friendly as James Harrison and Roger Goodell, so I’m guessing Cowher gleaned some pleasure from his JV team eliminating the Bills, 29-24, in what proved to be one of the darker days in Bills history (and there have been plenty of those). The Bills fired Donahoe a year later.

Then again, those weren’t just any backups the Steelers put on the field. Consider The Associated Press lead from the game:

Advertise with us

“Willie Parker, Brian St. Pierre, James Harrison — who are these guys, you might ask? They represent the collection of Pittsburgh backups and scrubs that ended the Buffalo Bills’ playoff hopes.”

Cowher didn’t always get the last laugh against Buffalo, though. His first team gained the AFC’s top seed in 1992 only to be eliminated by a wounded Bills team coming off the greatest comeback in NFL history (think Oilers, think 35-3). Instead of going with hot hand Bubby Brister, Cowher opted for a rusty Neil O’Donnell, and the Jim Kelly-less Bills cruised, 24-3.

Then there was the time Jim Haslett stepped on Terry Bradshaw’s head.

It happened in 1979 at Three Rivers Stadium, after Bradshaw scrambled and fell out of bounds. Haslett, the Bills’ prized rookie linebacker, had grown up in Avalon rooting for the Steelers. So it hurt when he had to leave on officials’ orders after stepping on Bradshaw’s cranium.

“I’ll defend him and say I wasn’t kicked,” Bradshaw said afterward. “My wig company is going to have to send me a three-quarter inch piece of hair to cover [the mark].”

Advertise with us

Other notable Bills-Steelers moments:

• Legend has it that O.J. Simpson’s 88-yard TD run on Sept. 28, 1975, at Three Rivers Stadium marked the only time Jack Ham missed a tackle.

• Simpson also had the longest run ever against the Steelers, a 94-yard TD sprint in 1972. But in a playoff matchup two years later, the Steelers held him to 49 yards in a 32-14 victory that paved the way to the first of four Super Bowl wins that decade.

• In perhaps the first clear sign that the Bills were done after four consecutive Super Bowl appearances, the Rod Woodson-led Steelers defense bludgeoned them, 23-0, in a Monday night game in 1993. The Steelers knocked Kelly, Andre Reed and Don Beebe out of the game.

• East Brady native Kelly threw for a career-best six touchdowns in a 52-34 victory over the Steelers in 1991. Roethlisberger used to keep a Kelly poster in his childhood bedroom, by the way, telling me a few years ago, “I tease him about it all the time.” The two have developed a close friendship.

Advertise with us

• Marv Levy’s first game coaching the Bills was against the Steelers on Nov. 10, 1986 — a 16-12 Bills victory.

• The Steelers played the Bills on a horrendously windy day at Rich Stadium in 1982. Bradshaw was pulled after completing only two of 13 passes for 3 yards.

“I talked to Terry,” coach Chuck Noll said afterward. “He said he wasn’t able to do anything. We looked like — what? — a grade-school team.”

They’re expecting wind and snow and who-knows-what Sunday in Buffalo. Both teams could really use a win. God only knows what might happen.

I’m sure He will be tweeting about it.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.