Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jraystarkey@gmail.com. On to the questions:

Ryan Goodworth, @_rmg_: Should Quadree Henderson be considered for the Heisman? Haven't seen many players as dynamic as him at PR/KR in years.

Starkey: Probably not, Mr. Goodworth, but I love your question because of the research it sparked, and I’ll tell you this: Henderson is having one of the quietest all-time seasons on record. He is the second-most exciting player in the country, behind Lamar Jackson, in my estimation and should absolutely be a first-team All-American as a return man. You mentioning the Heisman piqued my interest. Here’s why: The player Henderson reminds me of most is long-ago Notre Dame star Raghib “Rocket” Ismail, who became a mega celebrity and finished second in the Heisman Trophy voting in 1990 — and Henderson is having a better year!

In fact, as I look at the best seasons of some of the great all-purpose players in modern college football history — Desmond Howard, Tim Brown, “Rocket” and Reggie Bush — I’m astounded to see that Henderson hangs with all of them in terms of raw numbers. Except perhaps for Bush, who had a ridiculous final season at USC.

Advertise with us

Start with this: Henderson and Howard are the only ones among those five to have touchdowns on a run, catch, kick return and punt return in the same season.

So the purpose here is not to prove Henderson belongs in the Heisman race, although if Pitt had won two more games, I might be convinced. It’s to look at some of those who have won the Heisman, or in Rocket’s case just missed, and compare the numbers. Let’s rank ’em by all-purpose yards per game:

Pretty remarkable, no? And Henderson still has one game left. Granted, Bush was predominantly a running back, so his yards per touch will naturally be lower than the others, and college football has changed over the years. Offenses have become more explosive. I’ll just say that Quadree Henderson is having one of the greatest, most exciting seasons of any football player I have ever seen — and if “Rocket” can make the cover of Sports Illustrated twice in a career, can’t Henderson make it once?

Joe Starkey, @joestarkey1: Joe, did you find a nickname for Henderson?

Starkey: Sort of. He apparently is already called “Squirrel” or “Gingerbread Man” which are wonderful names, but I put the call out on Twitter anyway, and this is what we have: “Jet” “Hollywood” “Hot Wheels” “Zoom” “Dart” “Wings” and “The Henderson Express.” I kind of like Jet, as it plays on one of Squirrel’s favorite plays: The jet sweep.

Advertise with us

Kehlis, @kehlis28: Sheetz or getGo?

Starkey: No offense to newest Post-Gazette sports writer Sean Gentille or to the fine folks at getGo — and I just learned about the lower case g — but I am a Sheetz man from way back (insert your Jeff Reed joke here). I feel safe and cared for at Sheetz. It always seems like Christmas there. All of my needs are met. My favorite one is located at 1408 Main St. in my wife’s hometown of Brockway, Pa. Main Street is essentially still Route 28, so it’s a straight shot from Pittsburgh. The selection of coffees, fresh donuts, sports magazines and bottled water is second to none. I love Sheetz.

In Brockway, incidentally, I am considered a friendly outcast/city boy by my wife’s family. They laugh at my fear of snakes/deer/dogs/coyotes/mosquitoes/worms, etc., and once made me shoot a rifle into the air. When it backfired and nearly knocked me over, they nearly died of hysterics. The best game we ever played there was stand-on-the-hill-and-hit-a-golfball-150 yards-into-the-forest-and-see-if-you-kill-anything. We also play dodgeball in the basement using hard plastic balls and goggles. This leads to injuries.

Alex, @alexjames2424: Is Tom Brady MVP?

Starkey: No, Mr. alexjames2424, he is not. He’s close. Anybody who puts up 18 touchdowns and one (1) interception to go with a league-leading 116.7 passer rating and a 6-1 record is obviously a candidate. But he has only played seven of 11 games. Dak Prescott is the MVP of the league at the moment. His rating (108.6) is only slightly lower than Brady’s — not that I’m putting everything on the flimsy passer rating stat. For one thing, it doesn’t incorporate rushing stats, and Prescott has rushed for 180 yards and five touchdowns. Mostly, though, he has been money from the pocket. That is the first thing you notice about him: his coolness in the face of an NFL pass rush. That is the one trait nobody can really know until a quarterback reaches the NFL. When Prescott came here to play the Steelers, his pocket presence reminded me of a young Aaron Rodgers in that wild 37-36 game in 2009.

Advertise with us

Prescott has 18 touchdown passes, two interceptions, a 10-1 record and plenty of clutch plays on his resume. There is no shortage of qualified candidates — Matt Ryan, Ezekiel Elliott, Drew Brees, Derek Carr, etc. — and plenty of season left. A guy like Aaron Rodgers (27 touchdowns, seven interceptions) or Ben Roethlisberger (23 TDs, seven interceptions) could make a late run. Two other Steelers aren’t having terrible seasons: Antonio Brown leads the league in catches and is tied for No. 1 in TD catches, and Le’Veon Bell leads in yards from scrimmage per game. But right now I’m going with the guy who is efficiently and sometimes spectacularly leading the best team in the league to win after win.

Brian Fennell, @BFGolferguy122: With 12 misses (two weeks ago) & a two-pt return for a win, has the PAT become one of the most exciting plays in the NFL?

Starkey: No, golferguy, it most certainly has not, although it’s better than it used to be. If we’re talking about altered special teams situations, I still miss kickoff returns. It feels like we almost never see one. The NFL tells us kickoffs are dangerous, and I suppose they are, but if we’re talking about long-term brain injury, I’d wager it’s the dozens of subconcussive collisions that take place every game that cause most of the damage. Which is to say, football. Bring back kickoffs!

Chester Copperpot, @Pburgh101Cline: Nickname in HS?

Starkey: Casper, as in Casper the Friendly Ghost. I was so horrifyingly pale that I was practically invisible.

Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille on one of his first days on the job and be sure to send me questions throughout the week (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jraystarkey@gmail.com). We’ll talk on Tuesday.