Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jraystarkey@gmail.com. On to the questions:
PixBurghKid, @tuitepgh: Rank Pitt wins (basketball and/or football) this century.
Starkey: That sounds more like an order than a question, PixBurghKid, but it’s one I will happily obey. Like Rob Fleming, the protagonist in “High Fidelity,” I have have been obsessively scribbling down lists since toddlerhood. My three favorite movies? 1. Almost Famous 2. Sideways 3. Sound of Music. Three most-reviled athletes: 1. Danny Ainge 2. M.L. Carr 3. Pete Rose. Three favorite days of my life: 1. Marriage 1. (tie) Daughter’s birth 3. Bills 51, Raiders 3.
So here we go: The best Pitt football and basketball victories this century (not including any that involve the letters CBI or BBVA, of course). I’ll go top 5, in descending order …
BASKETBALL
5. Pitt 60, Xavier 55, 2009 Sweet 16: Sean Miller was not spotted on Pitt’s campus after this one, I can tell you that. Levance Fields made that late 3-pointer, and Pitt finally cracked the Elite Eight. I’m sorry to report that by choosing this game, I’m leaving out lots of others, including Pitt-Wisconsin in the ‘04 Tourney, Ronald Ramon-beats-WVU, the miracle at Syracuse and perhaps most controversially, the Big East Championship win against Georgetown (four wins in four nights, and I will always remember Sam Young telling me he had to borrow somebody’s sneakers for the title game because he forgot his. I’ve had nightmares about such scenarios since I was very small).
Read More
4. Pitt 76, UConn 68, Feb. 16, 2009: Have they picked Hasheem Thabeet off the floor yet? Pitt’s first-ever win against a No. 1 team. DeJuan Blair, legend.
3. Pitt 65, Duke 64, Dec. 20, 2007: Fields won it on a fallaway jumper at the Garden, then nearly kicked Jamie Dixon in the face while celebrating.
2. Pitt 70, UConn 60, March 7, 2009: I dare say The Pete never rocked as loud, as Pitt again beat No. 1 UConn — the second time in a month — behind Young’s 25 points. “Every time I see those UConn jerseys,” he said afterward, “my eyes light up.” He wore his own sneakers for this one.
1. Pitt 74, UConn 56, Big East Championship, 2003: Sensing a theme here? There was just something special about this win. It felt like the coming of age of a basketball program. I’ll never forget Brandin Knight maniacally diving for a loose ball when the game was already decided. What a team. And what a desperate shame this rivalry died.
FOOTBALL
5. Pitt 41, Notre Dame 38, Nov. 13, 2004: Like Tyler Palko, all Pitt fans were so “proud of their $#*@!@#$%%^* football team!” Pitt hadn’t won at Notre Dame since 1986. Palko became the first opposing QB to throw for five TDs at Notre Dame Stadium. Once again, we must leave out some classics here, including Pitt winning at Notre Dame in four overtimes in 2008, Pitt beating a top-3 Virginia Tech team in 2002 (and the Lousaka Polite game against the Hokies a year later), and even Pitt 12, Penn State 0.
4. Pitt 42, Penn State 39, Sept. 10, 2016: What a game! Glorious day. Rivalry renewed. Stands packed with fans from both sides. Tons of big plays. Think maybe they should play this game every year? Penn State, are you listening?
3. Pitt 16, West Virginia 13, Nov. 26, 2004: Against a ridiculously talented WVU team, Palko capped a dramatic late drive with the winning score. That put Pitt one win away from the Fiesta Bowl and its only BCS bowl bid (remember the BCS?).
2. Pitt 43, Clemson 42, Saturday: “The Rally in Death Valley.” One of the finest college football games I have ever seen. I still can’t believe ol’ Dabo, after throwing about 347 passes, decided to run it twice in a row. Pitt played utterly without fear.
1. Pitt 13, West Virginia 9, Dec. 1, 2007: I still put this game slightly above “The Rally,” because it was an ancient rival, because WVU needed only this win to play for the National Championship, and because Pitt was a 28.5-point underdog. The game will reverberate in West Virginia for decades. Maybe centuries.
Nearly a decade later, I still can’t believe Pitt won.
I also can’t believe what Pitt linebacker Scott McKillop told me years later: Pitt ran only one defense the entire second half. Adjustments, RichRod?
Michael Reed, @MichaelReedPhD: Where have all the D-coordinators gone?
Starkey: Well, Dr. Reed — the PhD on your Twitter handle implies you’re a doctor, yes? — I assume you’re talking about Dick LeBeau, and his Tennessee Titans defense is giving up almost a field goal more per game than a very sorry Steelers defense, although it does have 15 more sacks. But who are we kidding, Doc? The players make a coach. When the talent started to fade here, so did LeBeau. I don’t think he got stupid overnight. I thought Keith Butler did a great job last season — third in sacks, tons of turnovers, lots of flipped fields for the offense — but you can only make up for a lack of talent for so long (and you wonder how much influence Mike Tomlin has on the defensive philosophy this season).
If you’re referring to Pitt’s recent string of defensive coordinators, it’s been a rough ride. The list includes Matt (Other Team Takes It To The) House, Keith Patterson, Phil Bennett and Paul Rhoads. Am I forgetting anyone? I’ll take Rhoads over all of them, solely on account of 13-9. Jury still very much out on Josh Conklin.
Tim Shady, @timmshady: Hello Starkey, Who can we all, as a nation, agree is awesome? With all of this political drama going on, we definitely know who is hated. But, who is so cool, so entertaining and wonderful — that everyone agrees upon their awesomeness? There has to be someone, no? It may be hard to pick an athlete, because they’re often hated for hitting a home run “the wrong way,” dunking a ball, or smiling while playing football. But still, there has to be someone everyone enjoys, right?
Starkey: Wrong. And hello, Shady. I’m not so sure there is a universally liked human in these fractured times. It certainly isn’t Skip Bayless. We made this a topic on the radio and did not receive a satisfactory answer. Does the person have to be alive? Kate Hudson might be a candidate, although I’m still angry at her for dating A-Rod. Anthony Rizzo seems like a very nice man, but he plays for the Chicago Cubs. Morgan Freeman? Bette Midler (did you know she’s only 5-foot-1)? Tom Hanks? Dalai Lama?
I don’t think so, Tim.
But I do find it fascinating that Dalai Lama is on Twitter. He has 13 million followers and follows no one. Bayless, incidentally, has 2.28 million followers and also follows no one. And you wonder what’s wrong with the world?
Mike, @coachpsu316: Matt Canada for OC of the Year?
Starkey: You’re talking about the Frank Broyles Award, Mr. coachpsu316, and that goes to the top assistant coach in the country. I don’t have the entire list in front of me, but I can tell you: Matt Canada should be a candidate. Creativity, execution, production. It’s all there. It’s been a wonderful offense to watch. Pitt is 22nd in the country in scoring (37.6 ppg) and third in the ACC, behind only Louisville and Clemson. My concern would be Canada leaving for a head coaching job. He was mentioned last year in the East Carolina search. His stock is only rising.
Interestingly, as I look through recent finalists for the Broyles Award, I see a lot of noted offensive minds who became head coaches, including Paul Chryst (twice), Gus Malzahn, Tom Herman, Kliff Kingsbury and Dana Holgorsen.
In other words, enjoy Canada while you have him.
P.S. In last week’s mailbag, I linked several Bob Dylan albums to current themes in Pittsburgh sports. For “Blood on the Tracks” I listed Pitt’s pending visit to Clemson. Well, Pitt shoved it. So now maybe, just maybe, we have a new one for Pitt football: “The Times They Are A’ Changin.”
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to send me questions throughout the week (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jraystarkey@gmail.com). We’ll talk next Tuesday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.