Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jraystarkey@gmail.com. On to the questions:
Bryan Tinsley, @Bryan_10s: Blount has better stats than Bell since his release. Did we let the wrong guy go? Blount will be cheaper.
Starkey: What you have you been smokin’, Bryan? LeGarrette Blount is good. He's not on the same planet as Le'Veon Bell, who is the best running back in football and one of the best I've ever seen. That being said, your contention that “Blount has better stats” since he quit on the Steelers two years ago in Tennessee intrigued me. And even though Bell has 419 more yards from scrimmage in nine fewer games, your stats argument has merit. Let’s take a look at these two since Blount quit the Steelers:

Blount has stayed healthier and more trouble-free and has, in fact, produced more on the ground, albeit with a significantly smaller per-carry average. Honestly, though, Bryan, if I asked you whom you’d rather have right now, starting today, you can’t tell me it would be Blount. Can you? Bell is so good that if I’m the Steelers, I have to look beyond his recent issues and seriously consider giving him a multi-year deal. If they ever did part ways, I can tell you one coach who’d be mighty interested. Did you hear Bill Belichick heap praise on Bell last week? “Oh my God,” he said, when Bell’s name was mentioned. The idea of Bell in the Patriots’ backfield is a nigthmare almost beyond comprehension. Quick aside: Bell and Blount exchanged jerseys after the game Sunday. Blount left the locker room clutching a No. 26 Steelers jersey in his left hand. So there’s that.
Larry Kress, @middleageschmo: Does your face still hurt from the 6-6 tie? Mine still does. That game was awful prime-time viewing.
Starkey: Hello Larry. Shame about your face. I actually found the Cardinals-Seahawks debacle to be wildly entertaining. Judging by the Twitter reaction — which isn’t always an accurate gauge — much of the rest of the country shared my opinion. The dueling missed chip shots in overtime were laugh-out-loud funny. I also happen to enjoy defensive battles more than shootouts, so I was riveted. Those are two very good defenses. I would, however, make the larger point that most NFL games these days stink. We spend all kinds of time and energy analyzing the drop in TV ratings. THE GAMES STINK. Who wants to dedicate three hours on a Sunday to watching Titans-Colts? Or Browns-Jets? Or Rams-Giants (did you see THAT debacle?). It’s horrifying. People don’t have three hours to do anything anymore, let alone wait five minutes between bad plays while Ed Hochuli peers into a replay machine. Finally, what’s so bad about a tie? It’s no way to end a baseball All-Star Game, I’ll grant you, but in regular-season football, if you can’t decide a winner in 75 minutes, then by all means, end it.
ja.ME.s (James), @SlowFocus: If AaronRodgers retired today, is he still a first ballot HOF’er?
Starkey: First ballot? No. Hall of Famer? Yes. Rodgers is a two-time NFL MVP (matching the two won by Joe Montana and Tom Brady) and a Super Bowl MVP (in a game that marked the first solid signs of decay in a once-vaunted Steelers pass defense). He also owns the highest passer rating (103.4) in the history of the league, if you value that stat. And maybe you shouldn’t value it too much, seeing as Tony Romo has the third-best passer rating of all-time, and Chad Pennington’s passer rating was better than Dan Marino’s or Brett Favre’s. Rodgers also is the greatest Hail Mary passer of all-time, for what it’s worth (not much). Anyway, he’s had seven very good-to-great years. If the world ended today — and let’s really hope it doesn’t — then Rodgers is in my top-five QBs of the Century (Brady, Peyton Manning, Ben, Brees, Rodgers, yes?). And now that we’re on this topic, I can’t help but think of one Eli Manning, as confounding an athlete as I have ever laid eyes on. Does he belong in the Hall of Fame? I can’t put him in, even though he’s won two Super Bowls. I just can’t. I might be very wrong. His overall numbers are good. He has thrown for 302 touchdowns (and 205 interceptions). It’s just that when I think of him, the word “greatness” does not spring to mind.
Jim Kienzle, @Tripgreat: After witnessing the injuries of the past few weeks: "WHY? WhywhywhywhyWHYwhywhywhy?!!!?"
Starkey: I don’t know.
James in Monaca: My wife and I got in an argument last week. I said that fall is the best season of the year. She said spring. Who is right?
Starkey: Neither of you. Summer is the best season of the year, James. Swimming pools, whiffleball, nights at the ballpark, beaches, sunsets and my outdoor George Foreman Grille. Come on, man.
paulgollob, @Paulgollob: Do u think the Pirates move #cutch rather then put him in left or right field?
Starkey: I think if the right deal comes along, the Pirates will move McCutchen, regardless of where they planned to play him. If he returns, he doesn’t sound all that interested in moving to a new position. Consider what he told MLB.com: "I don't see myself needing to move. I don't feel like I'm slowing down and hurting my team because of where I play. Playing center field is one thing, but being a leader out there is another. That's something we need.”
I’m not sure I understand how “being a leader” relates to playing center field, but there are a few things to consider here. One is that left field at PNC Park is roughly the size of Montana. If McCutchen is having trouble covering ground in center, what makes anyone think he can do the job in left? His arm would be more of a liability in left or right field, as well. I’m guessing he will stay in center if he returns. Maybe it would help if the Pirates didn’t play him two feet behind second base. By any measure, McCutchen is not a very good defensive center fielder. And if his bat returns to MVP form, nobody will care.

PixBurghKid, @tuitepgh: What was your favorite Halloween costume when you were a kid?
Starkey: My Evel Knievel costume was legendary. It had the mask plus the full red-white-and-blue body suit. I believe gloves were included as well. This prompted me to go out on my banana-seat bicycle and try to jump over a giant puddle in my yard. It didn’t end well, kind of like Knievel’s Grand Canyon jump, which I watched on closed-circuit TV at my friend Pete Nusbaum’s house. Runner-up was my Joe Namath get-up, complete with a New York Jets helmet given to me by my Aunt Viv (a legend in her own right), plus eye black and a “12” jersey.
Thank you to all, and to all a good night. Have a great Halloween! Be sure to send me questions throughout the week (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jraystarkey@gmail.com). We’ll talk next Tuesday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.