Much is expected of the quarterback who arrived here amid plenty of fanfare from one of the sport’s more iconic outposts.

After all, he’s someone who was heavily courted, then eventually paid and entrusted to accomplish what a few others since the last big name could not.

Sound familiar?

Well, yeah. Aaron Rodgers should be interesting to follow this season, too.

Advertise with us

On the other side of the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex, there’s also a fascinating signal-calling storyline brewing, one centered around the growth of Eli Holstein crossed with the X-factor created by the arrival of Cole Gonzales, a two-time finalist for FCS Player of the Year who played for offensive coordinator Kade Bell at Western Carolina.

What happens will determine a bunch for Pat Narduzzi’s team, which wasn’t able to maintain momentum after a 7-0 start in large part because the quarterback play changed.

The end product didn’t square with what Pitt believed it had in Holstein, the Alabama transfer who averaged 258.3 passing yards and 2.4 touchdowns per game while completing 64.2% of his passes through the Panthers’ first seven games.

Comparisons were made to the Kenny Pickett-led group in 2021. We talked a lot about the pace and effectiveness of Bell’s attack, the quick snaps, the yards per play, all of it.

Then, whoosh. Starting with a dreadful performance on the road at ranked SMU (a 48-25 loss), it all disappeared.

Advertise with us

Bell’s trigger man (Holstein) hit a major wall, failing to finish any of the final five games of the 2024 season, including SMU, after he incurred a concussion and ankle injury.

Despite some hope that he might return, Holstein also sat out the GameAbove Sports Bowl and averaged just 140 yards (with zero touchdowns) over his final three games.

Whatever mojo Pitt discovered during non-conference play disappeared once the ACC portion rolled around, and it’s hard to separate that from the sudden downturn in quarterback play.

That’s why Holstein commanding Pitt’s offense remains imperative, though I’m not sure what we saw this spring helped anyone feel better about that possibility. In fact, I know it didn’t.

The performance of Holstein and Pitt’s first-team offense probably caused some concern during the annual Blue-Gold game, the quarterback inaccurate with many of his throws and looking similar to how he did down the stretch in 2024.

Advertise with us

Passes missed their marks. Reads were late. It was also one spring football game — hardly enough to warrant a depth-chart change. But it perpetuate the questions, at least for me.

Was good Holstein real?

Or were we simply fooled by those first seven games?

I don’t know. You don’t know. Not sure Pitt knows at this point. But it shouldn’t be too much longer before we find out.

This might sound obvious, but Pitt also really needs quarterback to be a strength.

Advertise with us

That’s the same whether we’re talking about Holstein or Gonzales, who had a brief stopover at Oklahoma but two years ago — with Bell coordinating — completed 66% of his passes for 2,803 yards, leading the FCS in passing and total first downs.

Not like the quarterback of a football team lacks for this sort of thing, but there are several reasons why Holstein should feel pressure to perform. Team success, obviously. But also what Gonzales could potentially do, as well as the fact that he’s pulling in around $1 million via NIL. With the money comes responsibility, and Holstein knows that.

“Eli’s emotional and intense,” Pitt head coach Pat Narduzzi said in March. “He’s got some swagger to him, and I think the guys feed off that, as well.”

They better.

Holstein talked during spring ball about the offense being “light-years ahead of where we were midseason.” That the timing and feel has been better and that the Louisiana native hasn’t been afraid to challenge his teammates and function as a leader.

Advertise with us

Great. I’ll take all of it.

We saw last year — albeit against lesser competition — how this could look when Holstein’s right. The quarterback mobility. Rhythm throws with accuracy. Deep shots to Kenny Johnson, Raphael Williams Jr. or Censere Lee. Feeding Desmond Reid.

To make it all click, the Panthers need the early-season 2024 version of Holstein to be real, though it doesn’t seem like many around the country expect it.

Andy Staples ranked Holstein the eighth-best quarterback in the ACC, ahead of Kyron Drones of Virginia Tech and behind North Carolina’s Gio Lopez. The Sporting News ranked Holstein and Pitt’s entire quarterback situation 13th.

For the Panthers to shoot higher than 7-6 and the GameAbove Sports Bowl — which should be an obvious starting point — Holstein must crush those modest expectations and flash the pedigree Pitt thought it was getting when he transferred here from Alabama.

The same as with Rodgers, I can’t wait to see the entire story unfold.