The initial goal was a top-10 list. It quickly became too difficult, too muddled, perhaps a reflection of our area’s recent sports malaise.
By the way, congratulations to the last playoff victory by the Steelers, Penguins or Pirates on completing the first grade. Crazy how it’s been seven years.
But there’s a question I’ve been considering lately when it comes to our teams digging out of this current hole: Who’s the most important person in Pittsburgh sports at the moment?
Can be a player, coach, member of the front office or owner. Doesn’t matter. The definition of importance, though, is fairly important: His or her ability to drive winning.
My answer feels strange and definitely something I couldn’t fathom typing at this time last year: Aaron Rodgers.
Seriously, how’s he not?
Read More
It’s not the greatest athlete in Pittsburgh sports, the most beloved, the kindest, most skilled or who resides at the top of their respective sport. At present, it’s whose performance matters most toward winning. That’s at least how I’m choosing to define importance.
That’s why I went with Rodgers over Paul Skenes, Mike Tomlin or Sidney Crosby, the same for Andrew McCutchen, Kyle Dubas, Dan Muse, Mario Lemieux, a wild card in Bob Nutting, Omar Khan, T.J. Watt or Art Rooney II.
A collegiate case could potentially be made for Pat Narduzzi, Jeff Capel, Eli Holstein, Desmond Reid or Allen Greene at Pitt to join the hypothetical list, the same for James Franklin, Drew Allar, Kaytron Allen or Nick Singleton at Penn State, where the Nittany Lions football team could conceivably play for a national title.
Pro sports have long driven the primary narrative around here, so I decided to concentrate my efforts there.
I also considered ancillary options such as Ben Roethlisberger, Lemieux and Nutting. The third one of those probably made you spit out your coffee, but what if the Pirates owner sees the Tampa Bay Rays potentially selling for $1.7 billion and changes his tune?
OK, it’s probably won’t happen. But the calculus would certainly change if it did. The same for the recent talk about Lemieux and Ron Burkle potentially buying back the Penguins. Think those guys won’t want to step on the gas?
Roethlisberger has created a really strong podcast and forum for himself after retiring. He’s also only 43, two years older than Rodgers. But I’m pretty sure the ol’ cowboy has already delivered his last comeback victory for the Steelers.
There’s an easy case for Skenes if we’re talking about top-of-your-sport greatness. As of Sunday morning, Skenes was first in MLB in ERA (1.85), second in innings pitched (102.0), second in WHIP (0.88) and first in batting average against (.175).
All of those marks lead the National League, and we’re probably going to see Skenes become the first starter to win the Cy Young Award with a losing record. He’s obviously incredible, even if his team is flawed.
And that’s where my breakdown occurs when it comes to importance.
Important on a larger scale, sure. When it comes to the MLB Players’ Association and his growing role there, Skenes’ incredible presence league-wide, on his continued positive impact in the city, no doubt. Skenes obviously matters a huge deal.
But unless more hitting and winning occur, Skenes can’t sit atop this list.
Sidney Crosby, you say?
If we’re talking about longevity or the ultimate blueprint for how a professional athlete should behave, you can’t do it better than Sid, who’s also ninth all-time in points with 1,687 and will surpass Lemieux (1,723) this upcoming season.
Can’t wait to see how that’s handled.
But the Penguins unfortunately aren’t in a place where Crosby’s incredible longevity and production matter enough toward wins and losses. It’s the same reason why I couldn’t rank the Penguins president of hockey operations or their new coach on my list.
That and the fact that I never actually completed it.
You might examine the Steelers’ ho-hum pass rush last season and argue for Watt, whose lack of contract extension and potential $40 million salary could dominate talk in Latrobe next month.
Watt had a down year in 2024. But he’s the best player on the team, and he obviously matters a great deal. Just look at the Steelers’ record with/without Watt. But I still can’t come up with a reason for why he should be higher than Tomlin or Rodgers.
The argument for Tomlin remains the No. 1 fan complaint: He’s the common denominator when it comes to the Steelers’ falling short of expectations over the past nine years (since their last playoff victory) ... and really before that time. We forget they had a four-game postseason losing streak prior to their AFC wild card win in Cincinnati following the 2015 regular season.
I’m also not disagreeing on Tomlin.
His record when it comes to games, drafts or other personnel decisions hasn’t been good enough. I’d be silly to argue otherwise, and certainly Rodgers might become another chapter in that book.
But lo and behold, the mercurial, contemplative and sometimes just plain odd Rodgers has amazingly become the most important person in Pittsburgh sports, with how much he has left in that right arm or those legs determining plenty when it comes to outcomes on the field, as well as the tenor around the team.
In other words, this really has become Mr. Rodgers’ neighborhood.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.