Deep into our conversation Friday, following a question about why he continues to own the Pirates, Bob Nutting said something that I didn’t necessarily expect.

It involved remaining in place as the team’s owner so he could advocate for changes to baseball’s financial landscape when the current collective bargaining agreement expires in December 2026.

I’m not about to disagree with the need for economic reform within Major League Baseball, but what about ... well, everything else?

If Nutting wants to effect some change, there’s plenty available at PNC Park, Pirate City and really anywhere there’s baseball being played.

Advertise with us

The Pirates haven’t been good enough in several essential areas for small-market clubs. Pittsburgh’s decision to fire Derek Shelton was a half-measure and remains difficult to understand.

Ben Cherington has leveraged the draft in no meaningful way … but Nutting is going to allow him to make a bunch more picks?

The Pirates have been a three-ring circus lately while simultaneously infuriating and/or alienating fans ... yet they’re keeping the guy in charge of connecting with those people who plays a sizable part in shaping the team’s image?

Makes no sense.

“I think if we make a broad, real restructure of the organization midseason, right now, we will not improve the team for 2025,” Nutting said. “I don’t think that makes us better.

Advertise with us

“I’m not willing to give up on what we expected in 2025, which involves a significantly better performance than you’ve seen. I believe we can get to that. I don’t think that blowing everything up 38 games into the year is gonna help us do that. I think that would be distracting. I think that would get us off track.”

I don’t know about you, but I’m not exactly clinging to anything the Pirates have done through 38 games. I’m certainly not concerned about going in a different direction, which is why I disagree with the Pirates’ decision to stop at Shelton.

It doesn’t solve the organization’s biggest problems. It also conveys the wrong message to fans, who are already ticked — and justifiably so — with how the Pirates have handled themselves since last August.

That, of course, was when a relatively promising start went to hell. It has involved poor fundamentals, a lack of offense, incorrect pitching decisions and relievers struggling, among other things. A few of those were fixed with Shelton, but plenty of problems remain.

The offense still hasn’t been good enough. We’ll see how Don Kelly handles his bullpen. Nothing has changed fundamentally. And the morale around the Pirates is the lowest I’ve seen since moving into the beat in May 2019. That’s why Nutting said the Pirates had to fire Shelton, and I can’t disagree — at least on that part.

Advertise with us

“We made the move with Shelty because we have an urgent need to get this team better in 2025,” Nutting said. “I believe that move will make us better in 2025. I believe Donnie [Kelly] will bring a fresh voice in that will help this team get refocused.

“You’ve been in the clubhouse. We needed a change now to get that done. I think that will help us now. I don’t think the other changes that you or others have discussed make us better right now. Our focus has to be on getting better.”

It does, yes. I might be one of the few who isn’t willing to completely punt on 2025, although it will obviously be hard.

By the way, Kelly might be the nicest man on the planet. He’s been a few places, knows plenty about the game and is adored by players. He deserves to manage for the first time before anyone plans his funeral.

But it also worries me because I don’t think Nutting is looking at the problem here. He’s looking at 2025 and the need to win baseball games, which means he’s getting warmer. However, the work remains incomplete.

Advertise with us

And a full shakeup, contrary to what Nutting believes, won’t take the Pirates off track. It might actually do the opposite and signal to everyone that what has happened isn’t acceptable.

A soft restart? A reboot? I don’t know what you call it, but it’s not pretending that things are OK because you removed the manager who never had a chance.

The Pirates right now are lost in many ways. There are alums who don’t feel welcome around the team they still love. Drafting, development and international player acquisition — small-market tenets Cherington has tried to fix — have obviously lacked. There’s an alienating, closed-off culture that has been allowed to persist. Plus the continued inability to connect with fans.

There’s also the issue of this past offseason, which I still don’t understand, especially after I asked Nutting why he didn’t do more to add to the big-league roster this winter. He made it seem like Cherington was authorized to do more but did not.

“That’s 100% a fair criticism,” Nutting said. “And there are several pieces to that. I have and will continue to view the allocation to baseball budget as a larger lump sum. I have to trust Ben to allocate between the various pieces, whether it’s minor league, development or acquisition. I also believe we’re underperforming. We need to believe that we have a team that can perform at a higher level and do everything we can to get this group to perform at the highest level that we can. That’s everyone’s responsibility.

Advertise with us

“We also need to continue to make this team better. We need to provide better players, more resources, more opportunity. Some of that has been injuries. Some of that has been looking at opportunities to bring other players in that didn’t quite work.”

I don’t know what Nutting meant by that last part, whether it was deals that didn’t land or Cherington signing bats that haven’t worked like Rowdy Tellez, Tommy Pham, Yasmani Grandal and others. It might not matter.

Bottom line, the Pirates haven’t been good enough in this space, the same as they haven’t been good enough with the small-market stuff that I brought up to Nutting.

His answer when I asked about his concern there: “Those are things we have been and will continue to be focused on. It’s not the right time to do a draft-by-draft debrief. I know you’ve done some of that work. I believe it’s critically important that we get those things right.”

If Nutting was willing to spend this offseason and Cherington didn’t properly execute that, why is he still employed? And if Nutting wasn’t willing to spend more than about $2.3 million (the increase from 2024 to ’25) on his opening day payroll, why does he own a major league team?

Advertise with us

There’s no good answer there. I also think there are flaws here unrelated to major league payroll that should be setting off alarm bells for Nutting.

The Pirates might be innovative with compiling information and creating fancy ways to display it, but it hasn’t been anywhere close to impactful enough on the baseball side.

As far as the other principles the Pirates have botched, Nutting might be thinking about small-market change in 2026, and there’s nothing wrong with that. But it would be cool if he took care of 2025 first.

Or, if he’s unwilling or unable to do that correctly, please let someone else try to fix both scenarios.