The not-so-old newspaper remains in my desk drawer, a tangible link to my predecessor in this space, Ron Cook.

Our Pittsburgh Post-Gazette headline the morning of Jan. 21, 2024: “T.J. WATT: DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR AND … TRADE BAIT.”

The page designer’s subhead — no, writers don’t do that stuff — essentially called any potential trade “preposterous.” It also pondered the idea of what the Steelers could get in return. I’m guessing Ron caught some flak for writing what he did at the time, but he’s not wrong.

Would you pay Watt $40-plus-million? I wouldn’t. And it’s interesting to observe how sentiment has shifted this offseason.

Advertise with us

When 93.7 The Fan host Andrew Fillipponi asked recently what I’d do with Watt, and I responded that I'd be open to trading him, the reactions were split. Half agreed. Others thought I’d lost my mind.

But at this point, given how the offseason has played out, I simply can't imagine endorsing a deal that would pay Watt more than his Browns rival, Myles Garrett, which means at least $40,000,0001. And I don’t think I’m alone.

It would be a shame because Watt is obviously a great player, a generational talent and someone who theoretically should wear one helmet for his entire career. But I'd never begrudge his desire to make money, the same as I think the Steelers should always make the smartest decisions for their business.

I just don't think that involves paying someone who will turn 31 in October that kind of money, especially when investing so heavily on the defensive side clearly hasn't worked out in their favor.

The correlation between one player commanding so much salary and potential team success is also tough to ignore.

Advertise with us

Just look at the top dozen salaries for defensive players in the NFL. It's not a shot at the guys making that money, but their teams aren't good.

While that does include the 49ers (Nick Bosa), Chris Jones (Chiefs) and Texans (Derek Stingley Jr.), I’d argue those are situational outliers within a group that also includes the Browns, Raiders, Jaguars, Giants, Patriots, Panthers and Bears.

Yes, the 49ers went to Super Bowl LVIII (after the 2023 season) in the first year of Bosa's new deal. Now, and quickly, they’re stuck in a transition or rebuilding phase. Kansas City is also just one season into the five-year, $158.75 million contract it gave to Jones.

The others … what have any of those teams won?

It's the same when you look at the teams that don't spend a ton on defense. The Eagles, Bills, Chargers and Lions are all in the bottom seven. They’re doing just fine because of smart drafting and efficient spending.

Advertise with us

Paying a premium player a lot of money feels like something teams do because they feel like they have to, not because it makes a bunch of fiscal sense. Although again, I certainly don’t want to diminish the ability of the player, how much of a game-changer Watt has been for the Steelers or the enormous role he has played within our city’s sports landscape.

I just wouldn’t want to pay a player $40 million when I have some decent available backfill in the form of Alex Highsmith, Nick Herbig and a plethora of picks over the next two drafts.

Would any of those options become Watt? Almost assuredly not. But I’d simply live with the difference and lean into offense.

I’m also aware of what the Steelers have done with Watt in the lineup versus when they don’t have him available; they’ve lost 11 of 12 games while allowing basically a touchdown more, plus accumulating 1.81 fewer sacks and 1.39 fewer interceptions/fumbles per game.

None of this, for the bazillionth time, is meant to denigrate or disrespect Watt as a player. I’d just like to see the Steelers spend their money a little differently.

Advertise with us

If the peace sign Watt flashed was goodbye, or an indication that he’s unhappy with contract negotiations and views the relationship as irreparable, it’ll certainly stink for some fans. It would be weird seeing Watt in another jersey.

But I also think this sort of stuff is the byproduct of not enjoying playoff success.

When you continually lose in the playoffs — not to mention the manner in which that has happened — it’s natural to seek change. The argument from this seat remains that the Steelers have not sought enough of it, though this makes it feel like Watt would be paying for the team’s stubborn sins.

But it’s not so much that as, again, smart business and whether quality teams are constructed around players who command so much of the salary cap. It’s rare, and a lot of those involve special cases.

There’s Patrick Mahomes and a clear identity with the Chiefs. The Texans, 10-7 the past two seasons, haven’t exactly been a juggernaut. Like the 49ers, they also had a quarterback still on his rookie deal.

Advertise with us

That’s obviously a long-term goal for the Steelers, but who knows where Watt will be at that point. There’s plenty of miles on the tires now, and one of the few knocks against a guy who should be a two-time NFL Defensive Player of the Year is that he’s occasionally had a tough time with injuries.

He’s also T.J. Watt, and I refuse to act like he’s anything other than an elite player, the NFL’s premier pass rusher since he debuted, a first-ballot Hall of Famer and all of that. But the Steelers have made cold, calculated decisions on players before, and they’ll continue making them long after Watt retires.

I’m certainly not advocating letting Watt go for nothing — and neither was Ron.

I’d also be open to the idea of general manager Omar Khan getting creative with the salary cap and making it all work.

But if that’s not an option and there’s an opportunity to add premium draft picks and spend money efficiently to build the deepest roster possible, it’s the Steelers’ responsibility to do that.

Regardless of how much of a fan favorite it might involve.