When Kurt and Donovan Hinish were younger, their parents had to ban board games from the family’s Whitehall home. During fishing trips to Canonsburg Lake or along the Monongahela River, the Hinish brothers would compete for the best spots to drop their lines, the battles sometimes forcing their father to intervene.

These days, clashes on “Fortnite,” “Call of Duty” or several sports video games are how the Hinish boys stay in touch.

As much as they’ve competed, the stakes this week have never been higher for Donovan and Kurt Hinish, two Central Catholic graduates with playoff games 72 hours apart in Miami and Houston and a chance to take their blue-collar, easy-to-love story to the masses.

Donovan Hinish plays defensive tackle for No. 6 seed Notre Dame, which will meet No. 5 seed Penn State at Hard Rock Stadium, site of the Orange Bowl, for the College Football semifinals Thursday. Kurt, meanwhile, plays the same position for the AFC South-champion Houston Texans, who will host the Los Angeles Chargers on Saturday at Reliant Stadium.

Advertise with us

“I think it’s pretty sweet,” Donovan said before boarding the team plane.

“We’re blessed,” Kurt said a day earlier between treatment sessions from the Texans’ practice facility. “We really are. We’ve been blessed with a great support system and a great family. That’s the foundation of who we are.”

The boys are most certainly products of their parents, Tawnie and Kurt Sr., who instilled equal parts toughness and compassion into their kids.

Kurt Sr. is a construction worker and seven-time colon cancer survivor, whose battle with the latter is genuinely impressive — but also not something on which he wants to dwell.

The older Hinish would undergo treatment, work a concrete job and lift weights in the same day, refusing to let it affect him and passing a hard-nosed mentality down to his kids — Donovan and Kurt; daughter Kadin, who competed in track and field at Slippery Rock; and Cory Nolton, the Hinish’s half-brother who played football at Robert Morris.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, Tawnie Hinish is an elementary school teacher who taught the kids “to be nicer, sweeter and have respect, to articulate yourself well enough to carry on a conversation with people,” Donovan explained.

“They’re like peanut butter and jelly,” he added.

However it happened, Kurt and Tawnie Hinish did an impressive job of parenting. They also created quite the pipeline to South Bend, Ind., where the No. 41 has become synonymous with the Hinish boys.

Anyone who watched the Fighting Irish beat Georgia in the CFP quarterfinals saw a large man wearing that number sack Bulldogs backup quarterback Gunner Stockton on fourth down to seal Notre Dame’s victory.

It was the latest chapter in what has been an evolving season for Donovan, a redshirt sophomore who has amassed 34 tackles (18 solo and five for a loss) to go along with 4.5 sacks in 14 games.

Advertise with us

Kurt, meanwhile, holds the Notre Dame record for games played with 61, including 35 starts. He finished with 81 tackles, 20 for a loss and 7.5 sacks, finishing in 2021 just before Donovan arrived.

This marks the eighth consecutive season there has been a Hinish at Notre Dame.

“He’s my older brother, so I’ve always looked up to him as a role model,” Donovan said. “He set the path, and I try to follow it.”

Donovan described the Hinish boys as “two peas in a pod,” with similar expressions and mannerisms. The difference is that Kurt — who signed with the Texans as an undrafted free agent and has 57 total tackles over 42 NFL games, is the more direct or blunt of the two, Donovan said.

Kurt said he has loved watching Donovan’s work ethic manifest at Notre Dame and also seeing how the additional playing time he’s received this season has been earned, not given, which squares with the Hinish family motto.

Advertise with us

“He’s an extremely hard worker,” Kurt said. “He’s kind of accepted the mentality of, ‘Put your head down and go to work every single day.’ That’s who we all are as a Hinish.

“He’s a great player, and he’s going to do great things.”

As kids, Kurt and Donovan Hinish walked similar paths. They were two-way starters and members of the Post-Gazette’s Fabulous 22, though Kurt started earlier and Donovan was more of a late bloomer. They also used to carry concrete blocks for extra conditioning, a nod to the family business.

Their maternal grandfather, Stuart Schroyer, played at Notre Dame, and Kurt wound up with a scholarship offer when a former high school and college teammate, David Adams, helped get Hinish’s game tape to the Fighting Irish’s recruiting coordinator at the time, Mike Elston.

Donovan saw what Kurt accomplished at Notre Dame — both on the field and off — and never really considered going anywhere else.

Advertise with us

“The legacy that he built, it was very easy to step into,” Donovan said.

But with that legacy comes responsibility, the type of thing that Kurt and Tawnie have always taught the boys.

To work hard and never give up. To be tough. To do what’s right and not take anything for granted ... yet also treat others with kindness and respect.

“It’s a family mindset,” said Dave Fleming, who was their defensive coordinator at Central Catholic. “A mindset of, ‘Conquer, be tough and a be a leader.’ It comes from their mother and father. They’re unique people.”

Especially when it comes to craving competition, most notably with one another.

Advertise with us

It started with board games and cards and has continued to nightly games of “Madden” or “NHL 2K,” the needling of one another never stopping. While describing this dynamic, Donovan couldn’t help but talk a little trash.

“If I made a great move — because I’m the better of the two of us at board games — he’d accuse me of cheating, then we’d go back and forth the entire time,” he said.

On the lake, Kurt used to get ticked when Donovan would catch more fish and admitted to sometimes trying to crash the party.

“I’d go over and stand next to him and get in on his success,” Kurt said. “He’d get mad at me and move, and my dad would yell at me.”

There’s enough success to go around for the Hinish brothers these days, as the next 72 hours should show just how competitive and successful they are: two intense, eye-black-smearing defensive tackles who have similar styles inspired by their Pittsburgh roots.

Advertise with us

“They didn’t grow up with a silver spoon,” Fleming said. “They were grinding. [Kurt Sr.] wasn’t lying in bed saying, ‘Woe is me.’ He got surgery and back to work.

“I’m not surprised by what [Kurt and Donovan] are doing now. They have that same mindset.”

Staff writer Mike White contributed to this story.