Ben Cherington wasn’t wrong when he spoke Wednesday at PNC Park about the Pirates needing to get better, faster.
The same for what will ultimately drive success here: better development and drafting, obtaining talent internationally and finding more value via trades.
But there was a bunch of other stuff throughout Cherington’s 45-minute, end-of-season press conference that confounded me, answers that will almost assuredly fail to placate a frustrated fan base.
Here’s what I mean:
“There’s clear evidence progress has been made and clearly not enough. We’re winning more games. We’re not winning enough. It has to happen better and faster. I really do believe we go into 2025 already with the strongest, deepest roster we’ve had since I’ve been here. We need to make it better.”
OK, plenty to unpack here.
Read More
Clear evidence? Where?
Pitching-wise, the Pirates are in a decent spot. They’re nowhere close with hitting.
Furthermore, while Nick Gonzales has sort of completed his development at the major league level, Henry Davis, Jack Suwinski, Jared Triolo (offensively), Liover Peguero, Quinn Priester, Tucupita Marcano, Ji Hwan Bae and Rodolfo Castro either have not or did not.
The Pirates haven’t improved with fundamentals or playing clean, smart baseball. They’ve probably gotten worse. The bullpen, an alleged strength, was hardly that in 2024. They just fired the hitting coach after watching their team OPS drop 30 points despite having better players.
There’s also this, and it’s important: They won the SAME NUMBER OF GAMES as last season — 76.
They’re winning more than 2020, ’21 and ’22, sure. But think about the logic there.
Either they were rebuilding — which they were, meaning these results should not count when referencing improvement — or your front office actually tried and put together three seasons played at a 100-loss pace.
“[Payroll] is not what's gonna drive winning here the most. That's mostly because just simply of the structure of the game in a place like Pittsburgh to win. There are other places. There’s no place exactly like Pittsburgh, but there are other places that are similar and you look at how those teams win and how we're gonna win here. It's gonna be through all those other things we were talking about.”
I’m tired of hearing how Pittsburgh is some magical place, where the financially limiting things only occur in our little vacuum.
They don’t.
Statements like that are a crutch, and I’m tired of seeing the Pirates use them.
The Brewers are 22nd in spending on major league payroll since 2007, and they won the NL Central. They’re pretty much always competitive. The Royals spent nearly twice as much on major league players this season, while the Guardians spent more than $100 million.
I understand with smaller-market teams that payroll must be baked into the stew with drafting, development, international signings and trades. That’s fair. But a larger payroll can and absolutely should happen here.
“At the time, we felt in order to execute the plan that we wanted to execute, that trade was an important component. We weren’t looking to get rid of Martin Perez necessarily but in the portfolio of what we were trying to do, it fit into that and allowed us to do what we wanted to do.”
Read that quote again. Pretty sure Cherington admitted he was forced to trade Martin Perez and his $8 million salary to add dollars in the form of Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Bryan De La Cruz.
Either that, or the Pirates were just that enthralled with the 18-year-old Ronaldys Jimenez, who has pitched a whopping 15 1/3 pro innings, none out of the Dominican Republic.
This also isn’t entirely Cherington’s fault.
I can’t imagine he wants his hands tied behind his back when it comes to roster building. But if this is the only way for the Pirates to “add” at the trade deadline, when they’ve become the talk of the town, what the heck are we doing here?
"We've said before, I'll say it again, we'd love to find a way for Andrew to finish his career in a Pirates uniform. That's as far as we've gone to this point.”
This is about Andrew McCutchen, obviously. I had asked Cherington if he anticipated Cutch coming back in 2025.
He’s the most popular Pirate in decades and hit 20 homers with a .739 OPS in 2024. He’s also been incredibly open about wanting to come back. Why’s the answer not just yes?
Saying you’d love to find a way for McCutchen to finish his career in Pittsburgh sounds like you’re going to talk him into retirement. Hope I’m wrong about that.
“One of the things this year clarified for me is that, while relative to free agency to trades is, that I think our approach to free agency the last two offseasons, and sort of the overall results we got from that, have been fine.”
Now, to be clear, Cherington later added that “fine’s not going to be good enough,” but ... how can you say that sort of stuff has been anything better than horrible?
Trades and free agency this past offseason yielded eight players: Yasmani Grandal, Rowdy Tellez, Michael A. Taylor, Edward Olivares, McCutchen, Perez, Aroldis Chapman and Marco Gonzales.
Their 2024 salaries: $37,550,000. Their production: 1.3 wins above replacement, per Baseball Reference ... and 1.0 of that belonged to Cutch.
The general standard is that 1 WAR costs about $8 million, meaning the Pirates should have gotten back roughly 4.5 bWAR. Obtaining below 30% of what you paid for is not fine.
"It's much more about consistency of messaging, consistency of follow through. Clarity, simple clarity. What are we trying to improve, and how are we trying to beat this pitcher? That’s a lot easier for me to say than it is to actually do every day. But I think it's more that than a brand new philosophy.”
This was Cherington when asked whether the offensive philosophy needs to change with the hiring of a new hitting coach.
And, no, it’s not “much more about consistency of messaging, consistency of follow through. Clarity, simple clarity.”
Did Pirates players stare at an absurd number of called third strikes last season because the coaching staff wasn’t clear enough that you should swing? Doubt it.
They didn’t swing because the coaching staff, through a philosophy originating with Cherington and Derek Shelton and facilitated by Andy Haines and his staff, routinely put players in a position to fail, acting like they’re all the same.
Isn’t the first step to fixing a problem admitting that you have one?
Based on what Cherington said Wednesday and how he described the Pirates’ situation, it sure sounds like we could be here awhile.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG on X.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.