Baseball is almost always too long and grueling to distill any team’s season down into a single series or even a homestead.
Must-win games in May? Easy now.
At the same time, as the Pirates enjoy a day off at home, their 2024 season feels like it’s teetering.
They’ve lost 16 of 21. Their offense might dominate a staring contest but seemingly can’t hit its way out of a wet paper bag, the group totaling just nine runs in six California games and averaging 2.5 per contest during the current slide.
Yeah, it’s been bad.
The worst number when it comes to the current state of the Pirates might be this: They went 2 for 36 with runners in scoring position on their recent road trip, stranding 46.
Read More
I’m honestly surprised they got two.
“We're not getting [the big hit] right now," Pirates manager Derek Shelton told reporters Wednesday afternoon in Oakland. "We've got to keep going, have a ball fall and go from there."
Pirates fans likely have a few different suggestions when it comes to how the team might want to fix things, and we’ll get there. For now, take a look at the upcoming schedule.
If there was ever a chance for the Pirates (14-18) to get right, to snap out of this current funk, it’s now. The Rockies (7-24) and Angels (11-20) visit PNC Park before a three-game set next weekend against the Cubs, where you-know-who may start the Friday opener.
Colorado has dropped 14 of 16 on the road and has the worst pitching staff (6.00 ERA) in MLB. Los Angeles has found its own funk, dropping 11 of 13 and recently learning Mike Trout will be out indefinitely due to knee surgery.
If the Pirates need the proverbial window — and they do — it’s now.
It’s also not really optional if the Pirates want to keep their season from spiraling out of control.
Sift through numbers, as I’ve done this week, and you might make yourself sick.
The Pirates’ have a minus-41 run differential during their past 21. They’re also hitting just .199 with 197 total bases and a .571 OPS during that time. Last, last and last.
The next-worse teams in those categories and what they produced: .202, 218 and .617. In other words, they’ve been the worst offense in MLB for nearly a month, and it hasn’t been particularly close.
Furthermore, only three qualifying Pirates — Connor Joe, Bryan Reynolds and Ke’Bryan Hayes — have a full-season OPS over .713, while four members of the team’s opening day lineup are currently under .600.
The Pirates might be getting baserunners, but they’re hitting just .205 with runners in scoring position, 26th in MLB.
“Things aren't falling for us when we need them to fall for us right now,” Joe said. “That's what's making for a long couple weeks here.”
We’re past the point where we can sweep any of this stuff under the rug. The Pirates are taking on water fast, and there are seemingly no answers in sight.
At minimum, Nick Gonzales, Ji Hwan Bae and Yasmani Grandal should join the club in Pittsburgh.
Jack Suwinski (.168 average, .533 OPS) isn’t anywhere close to where he should be and probably needs a reset, even if it’s some sort of phantom injury. Jared Triolo has been excellent defensively at second base, but his .217 average and .552 OPS guarantee nothing.
Davis has been relegated to backup duty because Joey Bart has played well but could also use a stretch in the minors to get his swing right and his confidence back.
Is that enough? Personally, I don’t think so.
The problem with the Pirates is bigger than those three players slumping, although that has certainly played a factor, along with the ongoing struggles of Oneil Cruz, Rowdy Tellez, Andrew McCutchen and Michael A. Taylor. None of those guys has an OPS higher than .634 (Cruz).
Of greater issue, in my opinion, has been a team-wide approach that clearly isn’t jibing with players’ comforts, desires or strengths.
They’re force-feeding the idea of seeing pitches and working walks. The unfortunate byproduct has been exactly what this group promised it would avoid: a one-size-fits-all approach.
As much as the new Pirates regime talked about being player-centric, it’s hard to see how the current offensive approach helps hitters on the other end of the spectrum, those who rely on aggression and instincts and spend their careers trying to avoid overthinking things.
Should the Pirates continue on this trajectory and fail to score against two of the worst teams in baseball, they’ll seemingly have no choice but to relieve hitting coach Andy Haines of his duties and/or take a long, hard look at Derek Shelton as manager.
I hope it doesn’t get there. Haines and Shelton aren’t bad people. They’re certainly not dumb, and it’s also incumbent on players to perform. But it would also be foolish to try and say that things are good right now.
Looking at what the Pirates have done compared to expectations set this offseason, two quotes have been rattling around in my head this week.
“With the current playoff system, another step forward means we can be in contention throughout the season,” owner Bob Nutting told me in January.
“Our goal is to play playoff games in October,” Shelton added, speaking at PiratesFest. “Whether that’s winning the NL Central — which is definitely the goal — or being a playoff-caliber team, that’s something we’re striving for.”
The Pirates’ goals are simple.
Their owner, right or wrong, thinks they can compete for the playoffs. The manager is on record saying that’s the goal — and something every staff member and player thinks about all day every day.
But to get there, clearly what has festered since April 9 can’t be allowed to continue. The first step has to be the Pirates ripping off at least four wins in six games, then hopefully getting a boost if/when Paul Skenes arrives next weekend.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG on X






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.