It’s been a running joke the past couple springs at LECOM Park, where Pirates manager Derek Shelton will poke fun at how much his beard has grayed during the past few seasons, for reasons every single one of the team’s fans can understand.
The bit received a a Pittsburgh redux on Sunday afternoon.
Reporters were rushing into the media room at PNC Park when Shelton again cracked a joke at himself and some obvious signs of age, pointing to a picture from the day he was hired as the remaining stragglers took their seats for his postgame press conference.
“See,” Shelton said. “That’s why you don’t write your stories [too early].”
Impossible, Derek, not in this age of digital media. Which is also how I might describe trying to figure out what the heck has been happening with Shelton’s Pirates, both during Sunday’s 3-2 walk-off victory or during the team’s 8-2 sprint out of the gates.
“They just keep playing,” Shelton said, repeating what has become almost a daily line about his team’s persistence.
Read More
“It’s beautiful,” Edward Olivares continued, with major league coach Stephen Morales translating. “An example of the team playing together and playing good baseball.”
Certainly won’t argue with the team sticking together or the significance of taking two of three from the 101-win Orioles, an accomplishment no matter where it falls on the calendar. There are also some individual and position-specific performances worth highlighting.
But the craziest part of what the Pirates have been doing might be this: They could absolutely be playing better baseball.
Just a few examples:
• In the bottom of the third, Jared Triolo hesitated coming around second. Third-base coach Mike Rabelo had Triolo try to score from first, anyway, on an Oneil Cruz double. It did not work out.
• In the top of the fourth, Cruz mishandled a relay throw, the error permitting an extra base, and Connor Joe made the Pirates’ second error of the game in the fifth when he fumbled a ball in right field.
• Only three teams have more than the Pirates’ nine errors, which puts them on a pace for 146 this season; they had an MLB-high 122 in ’22.
“We made a couple mistakes,” Triolo said. “Pitchers picked us up and got us out of the innings pretty clean. That’s great."
In a problem that dates back to opening day, either by failure to execute or unnecessary risks taken, the Pirates are also making too many errors on the bases. At the same time, they’ve won back-to-back games in walk-off fashion for the first time since August 2022.
These plucky Pirates have also matched their number of extra-innings wins from all of last season (three), while half of their wins have now come in the final at-bat.
“You’ll have to ask Shelton about that one,” Triolo said, answering another question about the wackiness we’ve witnessed. “I know he’s got some gray going on.”
Baseball is a funny game, isn’t it? Been around it my entire life. Played three decades. Yet there are still some days where it feels foreign.
Like how in the world the Orioles can look like Brooks Robinson or Ozzie Smith multiplied in the infield, Gunnar Henderson and Jorge Mateo making back-to-back dazzling plays, then the game ending on a throwing error by one of those guys (Henderson). Overall, the Orioles’ played amazing defense this series. And lost because of it.
Or how the Pirates can shoulder so many questions about their starting rotation — perfectly valid ones — throughout spring and snatch a series victory from Baltimore while getting quality starts in every game, including one from Bailey Falter.
“I know there were plenty of questions with our rotation coming out of spring,” Mitch Keller told me. “But I think everyone has shown that they can pitch at a high level. They’re a really good team, so getting a series win was huge. All of our starters pitched really well. It’s very encouraging to see.”
This might be the most underrated aspect of the Pirates right now, honestly.
Pirates starters have a 4.12 ERA through 10 games. It’s a little like George Constanza — ranked 17th as of this writing, not falling behind, not showing off. And exceedingly different than what anyone thought possible this spring.
Then again, that’s when Gonzales looked like a mere shell of his current shelf, when he couldn’t seem to keep the ball in the ballpark, his effectiveness questionable at best. These days, Gonzales looks like a steal for the pittance the Pirates are paying ($3 million).
Gonzales gave the Pirates six innings of two-run ball Sunday, striking out four. His ERA so far: 2.45.
“I wanted to get off to a good start coming out of spring training,” Gonzales said. “I wanted to go out and fill up the strike zone, make my outings quick and efficient, and I think that's what I've done the first two. Hoping to keep that rolling."
After Falter’s six scoreless frames Saturday, the emergence of Jared Jones and Martin Perez nearly going seven his last time out, the rotation has somehow become more of a strength than a concern.
“I think in any good rotation, there's healthy competition,” Gonzales said. “You're looking at the other guys and watching what they do and saying, 'I'm going to either match it or do better.’”
But again, still not full capacity, as Keller has hardly been himself. It’s the same sort of thing in the bullpen, too, where the Pirates are now without three of their top five with Ryan Borucki (left triceps) hitting the 15-day injured list. David Bednar also hasn’t reached peak form.
No big deal. Roansy Contreras went five up and five down, further acclimating to life as a reliever. After arriving in a pinch in Miami, Jose Hernandez did the same in the series finale against Baltimore — his flight delayed in Detroit — and wound up getting the win.
“He’s always prepared,” Shelton said of Hernandez. “He’s not scared.”
It’s a common theme with this group, as the Pirates have surged to their best start since 2018. They clearly weren’t intimidated by the Orioles, who are deep and talented in all facets.
What they did here said much more than taking down the Marlins and Nationals, the first of those clubs scuffling against everyone. This felt real and potentially sustainable considering some of the individual stuff we saw.
The first-base platoon isn’t so bad, is it? Joe worked a key walk late. Rowdy Tellez had been 5 for 12 over his previous three, pushing his OPS over .900, before going hitless in four at-bats in the series finale.
Only two teams have scored more runs than the Pirates (59). They began the day Sunday having seen the second-most pitches in MLB (1,642), trailing only the Dodgers (1,769). Ke’Bryan Hayes and Cruz are each hitting well over .300.
There are flaws, sure. The baserunning and fielding must improve. They also have several key players — Andrew McCutchen, Jack Suwinski and Henry Davis — slumping, while there are pitching questions about the health of the bullpen and if the starters can keep this going.
But the Pirates finding ways says something about their resourcefulness and disregard for not only the color of their manager’s facial hair, but also how they’re perceived from the outside.
“Not exactly sure what happened there at the end,” Bryan Reynolds said of the final play. “I’m just glad we were on this side of it. I think we’ve got a pretty resilient group.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG on X.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.